Craig Shirley, defending Ronald Reagan’s opposition to sanctions against apartheid-era South Africa, offers the following:
“When Mandela came to power, one of the first things he asked for were the sanctions to be lifted. So it’s a very complex issue and they present it [in the film] in a very simplistic fashion.”
The idea that sanctions should be ended after they had achieved their goal is very complex indeed.
Mike Schilling
Mike has been a software engineer far longer than he would like to admit. He has strong opinions on baseball, software, science fiction, comedy, contract bridge, and European history, any of which he's willing to share with almost no prompting whatsoever.
Due to problems related to a WordPress update, the site's layout had to be moderately altered. Some of the changes are temporary.
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForI have little respect for “process” arguments because we wouldn’t apply them in other situations. It… on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForIs Columbia and Trump’s crackdown of the pro-Palestinians the ‘Canary in the coalmine’ (link at bott…
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForIf they want that then they need to have police prevent the Protesters from shutting the U down and/… on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForIf they don't want politics to matter, then they shouldn't be threatening Jews and insisting that ev… on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForThere is a vast difference between "a single narrative" and "a crack down on the idea that 'No Israe…
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForI know: Columbia should appeal to the importance of the academy being a place where difficult ideas… on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine VandalsIt hailed about 5 minutes before we left the theater last night. We walked outside and saw a half in…
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForThe word that does the real work is "academically." I don't share what you describe, and I haven't b…
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForAmong the things the administration doesn't understand is that every department is different. Differ… on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came ForI have little respect for "process" arguments because we wouldn't apply them in other situations. Ex…
The Greatest Strike in History
March 30, 2025
March 28, 2025
They’re Acting Queer in Cleveland
March 27, 2025
A Loaf of Bread, a Container of Milk, and a Stick of Butter
March 26, 2025
on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came For on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came For on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine Vandals on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came For on Sunday Morning! A Working Man reviewed
on Sunday Morning! A Working Man reviewed
on Open Mic for the week of 3/24/25 on Martin Niemöller, and Who First They Came For on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine Vandals on Open Mic for the week of 3/24/25 on Open Mic for the week of 3/24/25 on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine Vandals
on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine Vandals on Weekend Plans Post: Pantherine Vandals
on Open Mic for the week of 3/24/25
I don’t think any of these people have actually seen the movie.
Nancy Reagan comes across great. Ronald Reagan in fact gets credit for something I think LBJ actually did (achieving pay parity between white and black White House domestic staff).
The scene about South African sanctions is a bit contrived, but they all are. It does stack the deck by not explaining the reason for the opposition to sanctions, even if it was incorrect – it was in the context of the Cold War, as everything else was between 1947 to 1989. And the movie has Reagan saying at the end “I think I’m on the wrong side of history”Report
The Zulu tribe, representing 6 million blacks, was vehemently opposed to the sanctions.
This is deceptive. It’s true that Buthelezi and Inkatha (at least its leadership) opposed the sanctions, arguing that it hurt black farmers, but he didn’t speak for all Zulus, and after the fall of the Apartheid regime we learned that the white government was funding Buthelezi and Inkatha because they were actively working against the ANC and other groups who were more militant in their opposition to Apartheid.Report
Conservatives have often found themselves on the wrong side of history.
But it’s only recently that they appear to have become unable to recognize this _retroactively_.Report