“Do you think it’s an accident that when the neocons were in charge Hezbollah led the Lebanese elections but when we ditched the neocons, the Lebanese ditched Hezbollah? Do you think it’s an accident that when we ditched our far-right extremist government here in favor of a realist liberal that the liberals in Iran advanced their cause remarkably? Much further than anyone had a right to hope?” ~ a friend of mine, in a forum online somewhere
Erik Kain
Erik writes about video games at Forbes and politics at Mother Jones. He's the contributor of The League though he hasn't written much here lately. He can be found occasionally composing 140 character cultural analysis on Twitter.
We had a recent outage due to ongoing problems with the latest WordPress update. We were also forced into some theme changes. Some of these changes are temporary and some are probably not. We apologize for the inconvenience.
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25Sorry, not sure why that posted multiple times on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25That seems plausible, sicne their estimates of the tariffs each country is putting on the US are way… on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25That seems plausible, sicne their estimates of the tariffs each country is putting on the US are way… on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25That seems plausible, sicne their estimates of the tariffs each country is putting on the US are way…
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25The new tariffs seem to have be set by AI: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:h3bil6wi4j2odx5exizuwh3j…
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25Here is the Treasury Secretary freaking out: https://bsky.app/profile/fffanatic06.bsky.social/post/3…
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25Ha! I miss Norm.
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25On this 'liberation day' I'm reminded of Norm's clip about going to war ... with the… on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25Well here comes the big f- you to working families everywhere. I predict hard lessons are about to b…
on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For DeportationIt's also right after we were breathlessly and repeatedly told Biden was showing no signs of age. Th…
A Would-Be Buyer at an Automobile Show
April 2, 2025
April 1, 2025
The Greatest Strike in History
March 30, 2025
March 28, 2025
on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25 on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25 on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25 on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation
on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation
on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation
on Read It For Yourself: How Trump Admin Defines “Gang Members” For Deportation on Open Mic for the week of 3/31/25
And so, once again, Americans get to claim responsibility for progress in the Middle East.Report
Right – and Larison has grabbed this now and made some very good points. However, I would just add that when a country is directly involved with the affairs of another country – when, for instance, there is the feeling that American might very well invade said country for instance, or assist in the invasion of said country, the citizenry might (just might) vote for hawks who promise to do a better job keeping us out. We certainly use that national security line all the time in our voting. Doesn’t that play a role in who many Americans vote for – wasn’t that part of why Bush beat Kerry in 2004, because of the perceived threats elsewhere? Why wouldn’t other nations do likewise when they perceive a certain American administration to be more of a threat than another?Report
They might, sure.
Then again, Bush might have beaten Kerry because Kerry was so god-awful and a grown-up nominated by Democrats (Gephardt?) would have beaten Bush handily (or, say, a Dean).
It’s possible to come up with any number of theories for why this is happening now… foremost, of course, is the Neocon theory that it *CAN* happen now because Saddam is gone.
It seems safer to wait for them to tell us, in their own words, why they did it.Report
This “Do you think it’s an accident?” style is out-and-out conspiracy theory. Or, rather, it’s an egregious example of post hoc ergo propter hoc so-called reasoning.
The most intelligent thing said about this so far: It seems safer to wait for them to tell us, in their own words, why they did it.
ED Kain wants to claim some sort of credit for “ditching” the “neocons” and then that this has somehow generated changes that we can agree with in the Middle East.
Once they do “tell us, in their own words, why they did it,” ED Kain & Friend will be eating their own words. Or probably not. They’ll still find a way to take credit for doing nothing.Report
“It’s possible to come up with any number of theories….”
And thank you My Sweet Lord for that. Otherwise this comments section would be largely empty.Report
Frankly, I do think it’s a coincidence. Iran and Hezbollah were successful while Clinton was President; they did not need a Republican in the White House to use as a bogeyman. Whatever the virtues or drawbacks of a purportedly “realist liberal” U.S. Administration, it must be the case that leadership groups in Iran and Hezbollah have their own dynamics and their own politics.Report
I think the diverse pressures of modernity have more to do with it than any US political party in power. It’s affecting China, India, Iran, the whole world. The time they are a’changin’….
Medieval mindsets just can’t survive in this quickly changing world. Technological progress alone is enough to cause discombobulation.Report