Skip to content

Ordinary Times

A place of politics, culture, and discourse

Primary Menu
  • Log-in
  • Welcome!
    • Masthead
    • Inquiries
    • Guest Posting Policy
    • About Feature Images
  • Community
    • Commentareum
    • State of the Discussion (beta)
    • Commenting Policy
    • The 500kth Ordinary Comment
    • The 750kth Ordinary Comment
  • Follow Us
    • On Facebook
    • On Twitter
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
  • Friends
    • Arc Digital
    • Outside the Beltway
    • Splice Today
    • Elections Daily
    • Liberal Currents
    • The Bulwark
    • Conservative Pathways
    • Misfits Politics
    • American Creation
  • Blog Archives
    • Blinded Trials
    • Mindless Diversions
    • Bookclubs!
    • Not a Potted Plant
    • Dutch Courage
    • Journeys in Alterity
    • The 49th
    • Jubilee
    • Safe Depository
  • Home
  • 2013
  • September
  • 26
  • One Further Thought on Internet Commenting

One Further Thought on Internet Commenting

Conor P. Williams September 26, 2013

A Twitter “conversation” with our own Tim Kowal yesterday reminded me of something that I neglected to mention in my previous post. Part of why comments sections struggle especially hard to move beyond style to substance is because of the way they manage visibility. After all, if comments sections were just about providing feedback to the author, I’d get a lot more email. If comments sections were just about having a spontaneous discussion with the author, I’d get a lot more tweets sent my way. 

But that’s not what comments sections are for. They’re for discussing a post in a way that prioritizes commenter attention-seeking. It’s possible to get at substance there, but I’ve concluded that that’s like swimming against the current. You get substance until someone gets frustrated. Then you get called a fascist in some esoteric way. Then you get called a fascist in a blunt way. Etc.

This is why I use Twitter, by the way. I’m interested in what readers think about stuff I’ve written. I’m interested in explaining more about what I write. But Twitter is structured in such a way that readers who want to respond are actually responding to me without the certainty of a commentariat audience. Ad hominem or abusive attacks there can be easily filtered and blocked. Anecdotally, I’ve had much better dialogue on Twitter than I’ve ever had in comments sections.

One final note: this is what bothers me most of all when people write me (usually anonymous emails) accusing me of “stifling debate” or “opposing expression” or “being an elitist” or “fascist” or etc. It’s not like I’m hiding. I’m on Twitter a lot. I often include a footer on my posts with my email address (punditconor@gmail.com). A Google search will reveal a few other email addresses. I have a public Facebook page. I try to respond when other bloggers critique my work. I’m not hard to find.

So: if you’re mad that I don’t allow comments on my posts, that’s your right, but don’t pretend like I’ve put up some insurmountable wall to engaging with readers.

Continue Reading

Previous: A Simple Desultory Menippic
Next: Weekend!

Related Stories

OTLC-Airship-e1612526045259-1024x515.jpg

Linky Friday: Lies, Slander, and Calumny Edition

Andrew Donaldson June 4, 2021 30
OTLC-Airship-e1612526045259-1024x515.jpg

Linky Friday: Tangled Webs, Weaved and Otherwise Edition

Andrew Donaldson May 28, 2021 48
OTLC-Airship-e1612526045259.jpg

Linky Friday: People, or Lies, Slander, and Calumny Edition

Andrew Donaldson May 14, 2021 13

Recent Comments

  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025Where the theory doesn't work you should change the theory, not insist that facts don't matter.
  • LeeEsq in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025Yeah, it should but that doesn't mean it will. Everybody with half a brain cell realizes that the Pa…
  • Fish in reply to Jaybird on Weekend Plans Post: The Last GraduationYeah, CU Boulder is doing this as well...the big ceremony with everyone but you only walk and get yo…
  • Dark Matter in reply to InMD on Weekend Plans Post: The Last GraduationWe have a thousand plus in my kid's graduating High School class. I think we're going to have them a…
  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025That means people expect them not to go full out. They're using the USA as the example on how things…
  • LeeEsq in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025None of the wars you invoked involve developed democracies. Israel is a develop democracy and is hel…
  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025it’s war logic hasn’t applied since World War II. Russia v Ukraine (or Russia v anyone). ISIS v anyo…
  • LeeEsq in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025The it's war logic hasn't applied since World War II. Humanity, especially in the democracies, is su…
  • Jaybird in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last GraduationWell, we had ours at the Air Force Academy Field House and there were all of these rules to get on t…
  • Jaybird in reply to InMD on Weekend Plans Post: The Last GraduationOh... yeah. I can see that. When I was a kid out in the sticks, my school had about 25ish kids in my…

Devcat Reports

Devcat image

Problems persist. We appreciate your patience.

More Comments

  • InMD in reply to Jaybird on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Marchmaine in reply to Jaybird on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Brandon Isleib in reply to DensityDuck on A Hopeless Semantic
  • DensityDuck on A Hopeless Semantic
  • Jaybird in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • DensityDuck in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Marchmaine in reply to InMD on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • CJColucci in reply to Chris on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • InMD in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Jaybird in reply to Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Marchmaine in reply to Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris in reply to Jaybird on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
September 2013
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  
« Aug   Oct »

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

You may have missed

vexed

Saturday Morning Gaming: It’s Time to Talk About Bloodlines 2

Jaybird May 17, 2025
sulk

Getting a Talking To

Clare Briggs May 16, 2025
Archiebald MacLeish - Ars Poetica

POETS Day! The Honorable Archibald MacLeish

Ben Sears May 16, 2025
Hopeless semantic

A Hopeless Semantic

Brandon Isleib May 16, 2025 2

Recent Comments

  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • LeeEsq in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025

Recent Comments

  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • LeeEsq in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Fish in reply to Jaybird on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Dark Matter in reply to InMD on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025

Ordinary Twitter

Tweets by Ordinarians

Recent Comments

  • DensityDuck in reply to Dark Matter on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Marchmaine in reply to InMD on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • CJColucci in reply to Chris on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • InMD in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Jaybird in reply to Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Marchmaine in reply to Chris on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris in reply to Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Chris in reply to Jaybird on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Marchmaine on Weekend Plans Post: The Last Graduation
  • Jaybird in reply to CJColucci on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • CJColucci in reply to Jaybird on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Jaybird in reply to CJColucci on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • CJColucci in reply to Jaybird on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
  • Dark Matter in reply to Chris on Open Mic for the Week of 5/12/2025
Copyright © All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.