Driving Blind: Democracy as First Resort
Because daily “Driving Blind” posts began to feel both overly taxing and to some degree redundant, I’ve decided to try combining them into one longer list of links to be posted each Friday afternoon. Also, since certain topics seem to come out naturally from the writing I come across and the stories that interest me, I’ve decided to start grouping them accordingly. As always, I’m open to feedback and please do feel free to share your own recommendations down in the comment area!
***
The Greatest Nation on Earth
In the wake of the 4th of July, it’s worth pondering American Exceptionalism. Even more important than praying to the right God in American political life is believing in and worshipping our nation state’s divine status. Ed Kilgore gets at the irony of those who laud the United States for its distinctively liberal democratic traditions while abhorring the universalism that political philosophy necessarily engenders.
Also, I’m not the only one who doesn’t think the U.S. is the “greatest” country in the world. A growing number of my fellow millenials don’t either. Whether that’s because of the condition the baby boomers are leaving it in or a deeper philosophic commitment to cosmopolitanism is hard to say. Indeed, a devotion to American Exceptionalism comes in all shapes and sizes, and is very rarely ever explicit.
And Eric Jett points out a short documentary series for “those of you who think America is pretty cool, yet hate going outside to prove it.”
Surveillance State
A look at the Snowden Generation and why they (we?) find it so easy to support the “29 year old hacker” and his stated objectives. While I disagree with the essay on just about every particular, I think it’s a good example of not just the kind of thinking a silent majority subscribe to, but the ethos of style and contrarianism that has driven so much of the NSA debate to be about so many things other than the good and bad of state sponsored surveillance.
Meanwhile, Scott Horton looks at the “Real Insider Threat,” pondering how the NSA’s surveillance regime will affect the Atlantic Alliance. Derek Khanna on the other hand looks at the logical extremes surveillance could be taken to, including intrusive monitoring of web browsing and highway speeding.
Plus, a video game that explores a world of surveillance and violence that Snowden’s leaks aimed to reveal.
Environment
I didn’t get around to commenting on the President’s environmental speech a week and a half ago. Suffice it to say I was both a little bit energized and a little bit more hopeless about the world’s climate situation. On the one hand the President is promising (relatively) specific actions, but on the other it won’t be nearly enough to make a meaningfully preventative impact.
The environmental movement appears political impotent, but then again the policy wonks are scrapping the bottom of the barrel when it comes to search for alternatives to a carbon tax which are at once politically feasible while also being in any sense meaningful action on climate change.
Now is as good a time as any then to re-read Nicholas Lemann’s “What happened to the environmental movement?” piece from last April at the New Yorker. Though if the Affordable Care Act is any indication, it’s going to require a lot more than a resurgence in grass-roots organizing to turn the political tide on carbon emissions.
Egypt
Juan Cole has some of the most measured and knowledgeable posts on the subject of anyone out there right now, but I recommend one in particular for a good picture of what’s at stake in the popularly supported military coup.
As Jon Lee Anderson puts it, “Depending on one’s perspective, Egypt is either in a political limbo or an extended purgatory.” And yet glib constructions like these belie a more complex and difficult truth I’m sure, as do pronouncements that in Egypt, “
The democrats are illiberal and the liberals are not democrats.”
Mazin Melegy explains why a do-over is actually the best thing for Egypt right now, and why popular democracy should trump liberal proceduralism for the moment. In addition, Dave Zirin explores the roll of Egyptian soccer fans in shaping the country’s political future now that the military is explicitly in power again. Finally, Sal Robinson attacks the Guardian for its recent condescending and stunted, “let me introduce you” styled list of Egyptian literature.
Culture and Media
The number of “withdrawn” young Japanese men (hikikomori) is increasing, and the BBC asks why.
An interview with Richard Rodriguez starts by discussing the problem of journalism and MFA programs without “any external reason” for existing.
Some time ago I pointed to a public speaking event at which Malcolm Gladwell suggested the New York Library’s main branch should be closed and replaced with luxury apartments. Now, as a result of renovations which would involve removing research stacks, a law suit has been filed claiming that the library has violated its charter, and the state’s constitution.
This week was apparently “Independent Booksellers Week,” so here are survival strategies for local bookshops and five reasons why we should even care about them in the first place.
Oliver Sava at the A.V. Club lists several new books starting up at Image written and illustrated by former Marvel elites. I can say from personal experience that Matt Fraction and Christian Ward’s Satellite Sam is top-notch.
Hollywood heavy weights who could get their video game projects off the ground.
I get that you don’t want to post as often but I’m wondering if listing all of your links on Fridays is more of a redundancy worry since Will already has his Linky Friday posts.Report
You are soooooo right–I’ve been missing Will’s Friday round-ups at NaPP.
Back to the drawing board then, but thanks for the heads-up!Report
How about Monday? A start the week off post?Report
What Joanna said. There’s already Trivia Monday, Stupid Bloody Tuesday, and Linky Friday. Maybe Driving Blind Thursday?Report
Would Mr. Gach link on the Sabbath?Report
He’d get a Shabbos Goy to write his HTML.Report
RE: A look at the Snowden generation:
There are people who disagree with me. Allow me to enumerate their deep personal flaws. First, “the disastrous inability to conduct a dispassionate argument”.Report
Regarding independent bookstores. As someone who spent his happiest working years as the night buyer at a used bookstore, the fact that we are still having this discussion 15 years after Borders came to town, and left, speaks volumes. I don’t think they will go anywhere as long as people still read printed materials.Report
A friend has a store where he sells DVDs, furniture, records, and whatever else strikes his fancy. Recently, he’s let me sell good books there and it’s been a real eye-opener. The readers are out there and come from all walks of life and, if you supply good books, they will come. Thank god.Report
“Also, I’m not the only one who doesn’t think the U.S. is the “greatest” country in the world. A growing number of my fellow millenials don’t either.” I’m not part of the millenial generation, far from it, but I think this sentiment is quite common amoung those who 1) think about it and 2) don’t make their voices heard all that much for one reason or another.Report
The issue that the NSA is having is that the vast majority of its current talent pool were brought up in a culture where the response to “do what you’re told” is “fuck you”.
That is to say, not the military. Back when the NSA was first getting organized, it could draw from a large pool of WWII veterans, and it was sustained by the Cold War (and, later, the Gulf War.) What they’re finding now is that everyone they might want to hire is the product of twenty years of counterauthority programming by every aspect of culture, and that means they need to do better than “shut up and soldier” to explain why morally-ambiguous activities should be continued.
A military man is taught that the system is the important thing; that it’s in place for a reason and that reason is a good one; that the people superior to him really do know better than he does; and that if he’s got any qualms about what he’s doing then the appropriate response is to squelch them and keep on doing it because orders are orders, and nobody ever really got in trouble for following orders.
That’s not a justification that really works for someone brought up on a steady diet of media where the hothead kid runs out on his own, disobeys authority, follows his heart, and turns out to have been right all along and ends up a winner.Report