Provoked by a great Battlestar Galactica-Sabotage mash-up, Sonny Bunch gets curmudgeonly about remix culture. The ensuing comment thread is pretty interesting; the (awesome) video that started it all is below the fold:
Will
Will writes from Washington, D.C. (well, Arlington, Virginia). You can reach him at willblogcorrespondence at gmail dot com.
Thanks to your generosity, we were able to upgrade our service plan. Hopefully this will help us address some of our performance issues.
on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024That's one I wouldn't put money on. Never should have changed it but now that it's done it's never g…
on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024Personally, I am relieved that Hitler has been cut off at the knees. We'll get some weird techno-fut… on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024I heard that there is movement to change the name *BACK*. on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’Depends on what we're talking about. "She held steady!" Well, in that case, we could easily say "yea… on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024That stuff seems dumb. But it also included giving the RFK stadium site back to DC which was step 1…
on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024The word on the street is that it was President Musk, on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024Josh Marshall on Musk as Trump's Trump: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/trumps-trump "But none… on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’The Federal Government does not set housing policy. Perhaps it should but housing/building policy is…
on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’They out number the global population of Jews in the United States alone, so that isn't much of a co…
on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’Oh, sorry, and I failed to mention the third thing that looks like 'inflation', but isn't really, th…
December 18, 2024
Moving Picture of a Handy Man Around the House
December 17, 2024
Somebody is Always Taking the Joy out of Life
December 16, 2024
December 15, 2024
on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’ on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’
on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024
on From Semafor: Kamala Harris’ digital chief on Democrats ‘losing hold of culture’ on Are Republicans Waking Up? on Are Republicans Waking Up? on Are Republicans Waking Up? on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024
on Are Republicans Waking Up? on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024
on Are Republicans Waking Up? on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 12/16/2024
Since when does an honest assessment of a lack of originality make one a “curmudgeon”? Every time I hear about a sequel or movie remake like The Karate Kid (I wonder if Hollywood will remake each sequel as well) or the movie incarnation of a TV show like 21 Jump Street I feel the same way. I’m still trying to forget about the remake of BSG.Report
The Karate Kid itself was a remake. Check out any given kung fu movie from the 70’s. You’ve got a dorky kid, you’ve got a gang of toughs, you’ve got the dorky hero getting the itshay kicked out of him, you’ve got a drunken master who hasn’t had a student for a while, you’ve got a training montage, and you have a rematch.
Dude, this is, like, half of Jackie Chan’s pre-Hollywood career. They just took the formula and made it American (adding, for example, a sweeet car).
We’ve started remaking remakes. I’ll probably not really get worried until we start remaking remakes of remakes. (“They’re remaking ‘Last Man Standing’!”)
That said, I’d rather see a perfectly executed, if unoriginal, piece than, say, something like ‘9’. Original only takes you so far.Report
Well Drunken Master was 20 kinds of awesome.Report
And that the original Sabotage video was itself a sort-of-remake/parody of 70s cop shows and movies. Really, Spike Jonze’s career was built off the Weezer video which was a high concept remix of Happy Days. I don’t really think that remakes of movies and television shows fit into the same dynamic as internet remix videos, as one mostly lifts characters/scenarios that people already know to build off an existing audience, while the other combines two incongruous cultural objects to make a joke that depends on an audience’s recognition of what is being played with. It’s what made A Very Brady Movie more than just a remake of The Brady Bunch and more like a remix. I think the best remixes are the ones that are not only funny but can illuminate the things being combined – the Weezer video not only was funny but also fit perfectly with the aesthetic of the band and capitalized off co-opting a cultural signifier that many people had strong connotations with.Report
I will say that humor that is based on little more than “I remember that!” is probably the worst thing to happen to humor since the pun.Report
Sure, although I do like puns.Report
“Since when does an honest assessment of a lack of originality make one a “curmudgeon”?”
I think it has something to do with the fact that, as far as I can tell, nobody anywhere is extolling this video as exemplary in terms of originality.
It’s kind of like walking into a diner and complaining that the meatloaf platter is not fine French cuisine. Well, nobody SAID it was fine French cuisine. If they had said that it was, the critique might be valid. But nobody did.Report