Fall!
Sigh.
I knew this day would come, when I was compelled to try to explain the long-running Manchester post-punk cult combo the Fall.
Willfully primitive, purposely abrasive, bewilderingly prolific, yet showing fairly limited stylistic and melodic range (despite drawing from garage rock, rockabilly, punk, German experimental rock, noise, and even electronic experiments and the occasional stab at something like “pop”), I am not sure I understand the Fall myself; so how to explain them?
Here’s an eleven-track attempt (all attempts should go to eleven).
Up top, “Totally Wired”, one of their more, dare I say it, catchy numbers.
“Wired” illustrates the most distinctive quality of the Fall; or more specifically, of headstrong head honcho and only constant member (“If it’s me and yer granny on bongos, it’s the Fall”) Mark E. Smith – his cut-up surrealist wordplay.
Smith, as a lyricist/vocalist (and notice I didn’t say “singer”…), is the kind of gimlet-eyed, tattered-Camus-and-Burroughs-paperback-toting barfly who will rant from his tobacco-clouded barstool perch for hours, inspiring both fear and fascination from the other patrons.
Fiercely intelligent and headily belligerent, Smith will take a phrase that makes no sense on its face, and through repetition and/or rearrangement of its phonemes, syllables, or concepts, destabilize the listener’s consciousness, in hopes of achieving something like insight or epiphany (or, perhaps just as frequently, make them feel like they are going crazy). The Fall’s sixth album was called Perverted By Language, and the constantly-mutating virus-like nature of words is embedded in the Fall’s DNA via Smith’s peculiar and torrential verbosity.
“Wired” becomes “weird” becomes “worried” (with “biased”, another term with an electrical meaning, thrown in for good measure). The “opposite applies”.
A band that took a lot of inspiration from the Fall was Pavement (Smith: “Listening to Pavement, it’s just the Fall in 1985, isn’t it? They haven’t got an original idea in their heads.”) – see especially Pavement’s early albums, covered with spidery reams of cryptic text on the outside, filled with blasts of noise and oblique wordplay on the inside (though Pavement is usually more “mellow stoner” than Smith’s, er, “wired” and demented carnival barker of the damned).
Like, this is basically Pavement’s “Conduit For Sale!” (but with kazoo, which automatically gives the Fall the edge):
While Pavement openly took from the Fall, the Fall had the gall to claim they had never heard the Stooges’ “I Wanna Be Your Dog”.
What do you think?:
At least this one they openly acknowledge as a cover, by garage-rockers The Other Half:
But frequent US garage-rock covers aside, the Fall are very, very British.
Which is one thing that makes their exuberant and unexpectedly-faithful cover of the also-very-British Kinks so weirdly apposite and so great:
Did I mention that the Fall are very, very British?
This is another of their catchier tunes – for those that don’t know, Northern Britain (from whence hail the Fall) is sort of the mirror image, in England’s self-conception, of the American South – that is, Northerners are frequently perceived by the British as “bumpkins”, it is they who have an “accent”, unlike the supposedly more worldly Southerners (though flipping the mirror yet again, the South of England is far more politically-conservative than the North). There’s a Fall lyric that goes “We are the Fall/Northern white crap that talks back”:
The Fall believe strongly in the three R’s: repetition, repetition, repetition (and also, repetition).
Hence this mission statement:
Good luck ever getting THIS out of your brain (BANANA!):
Who, indeed (NO POLITICS)?:
Are we reusing a video now, but for a different song? Well, it IS the Fall, so I guess that makes as much sense as anything:
Check the record, he is not appreciated:
Post header image sourced from Wikimedia Commons.
Elves is pretty much a dead ringer for I Wanna Be Your DogReport
I’m honestly shocked they even claimed otherwise; not just because the resemblance is unmistakable, but because for punks of that age and scene to be unfamiliar with one of Iggy’s best-known songs seems….improbable in the extreme.
Either they were messing around with the interviewer, or else the proper way to look at the Fall is weirdly akin to hip-hop – they “sample” what they want, as a bed for Smith to rant over.Report
I always confuse the Fall with the Alarm. Not sure why…
As always, good post @glyphReport
Thanks!Report
i’ve never been able to get past his voice. he sounds like the dude from the b52s.
this may well be a personal failing on my part.Report
Hmmm…Black Francis…Fred Schneider…Mark E Smith….There’s a common thread here, I think you just have an aversion to possibly-insane hectoring ranters.
As a native New Yorker, this may be inevitable.Report
think of it as musical colorblindness. there’s stuff going on here with all of these people – presumably – but i simply cannot hear it.Report
Victoria was always my favorite Fall song.
FWIW when they hired a guy from The North to play Dr Who people it was a real thing to people. It was different. And as Capaldi said in the last Dr W season, every planet has a North.Report
I can’t see that their cover adds anything to the original.Report
@greginak – well, for obvious reasons, it’s one of their least Fall-like songs.
@mike-schilling – see above, and I DID say ‘surprisingly-faithful’. I would have expected the Fall to take a sledgehammer to it, not play it straight.Report
@greginak RE: “The North” obviously GRRM plays with this concept/stereotype in GoT as well.
There’s probably a parallel you could make between Detroit and Manchester – cold industrial centers that have seen grim periods of economic devastation, and (not coincidentally) punch way above their weight classes when it comes to musical output.Report
Always loved them.
Awesome.Report
Also, that first video is… I want to watch the original now.Report
For me they were an acquired taste, and it took me a long time to “get” them to even the degree I do. And I certainly don’t want to listen to them all the time.
But, there are times when simply nothing else will do, and I will listen to nothing but Fall song after Fall song for an entire day, and that…DOES something to your thought processes.Report
It was exactly the sort of music I dug in the mid-90s (which was probably when I first listened to them), probably because it was an acquired taste. I mean, it was the 90s, and I was listening to a lot of stuff that was heavily influenced by them as well, probably because that stuff was an acquired taste as well.Report
Apropos of nothing more than this being a music thread, I just finished listening to some Iron Maiden (hellz yeah) and the suggested music for after that included Europe and Guns and Roses (and not something like Coma or Locomotive or something awesome but November Rain).
Has it come to that?Report
Artists played in Five Guys tonight:
Hooters – “And We Danced”
Hole – “Malibu”
Donovan – “Season of the Witch”
Gerry Rafferty – “Baker Street”
Big Star – “September Gurls”
Men At Work – “Be Good Johnny”
It was electic.
Also, is anyone else just drowning in new music? I have more things bookmarked to check out, or queued up, or ripped but barely played, than I know what to do with. 2015 is shaping up to be solid.Report
Coincidentally over at Hooter’s five guys got played.Report
I am drowning. Been listening tob the sxsw stuff too, which just adds to it.Report