Numerous articles and blogs have noted the strong case to doubt Christmas’ authentically “Christian” origins. Christ probably wasn’t born on Dec. 25. The Puritans banned the holiday because it wasn’t authentically Christian. And many of its rituals trace to the pagan celebration of the Winter Solstice or Saturnalia.
The modern understanding of Christmas is also significantly influenced by Charles Dickens’ class “A Christmas Carol.” Some Christians argue we need to put “Christ” back into Christmas and remind folks what “Christmas” is supposed to be all about. They might want to turn to Dickens’ classic in support of that cause; but it would do them no good.
Charles Dickens, you see, was a Unitarian Christian. And “A Christmas Carol” preaches a decidedly (19th Century) Unitarian message on Christmas. To Unitarians, “Christianity” was all about good works and good will, NOT God’s grace through Christ’s atonement. Indeed, Unitarians view Jesus as the greatest moral teacher, someone who “saved” man through his stellar moral example, not blood atonement. And “A Christmas Carol” hardly ever mentions Jesus at all.
Now, orthodox Christians likewise appreciate good works and good will. But that is secondary to God’s grace through the shed blood of Jesus Christ — God the Son Incarnate. And “A Christmas Carol” celebrates this message that the orthodox could consider at best secondary or incidental, not the central theme of the Christian religion.
That said, have a Merry Unitarian Christmas.
As a lifelong Christian, I have not ever heard another Christian (lay or clergy) try to lasso Dickens into a defense of “Christ back in Christmas…” As interesting as the historical tidbit is, I think calling it in is a strawman.
Not that it matters. 🙂
Merry Christmas!Report
Similarly, your description of Unitarianism seems a bit off: Unitarianism (and Unitarian Universalism) may well value good works over salvation by the blood of Christ (or whatever), but the defining credo of Unitarianism is simply the rejection of the trinity.
Not that it matters. 🙂
Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, and so on, etcetera!Report