And Just Like That, Billy Ray Cyrus is Cool Again
“If you wait by the river long enough,” the old Chinese proverb goes, “eventually the bodies of your enemies will float by.”
Wonder what the proverb for living long enough for Billy Ray Cyrus to be cool again is?
I was my daughter’s age when “Achy Breaky Heart” was the biggest thing going, inspiring line dancing, pop-accessible country, and an appreciation for a Hall of Fame-level mullet.
I was the same age a few months later when the craze died down, and the burn-out level on the Achy Breaky craze reached scorched Earth status.
Like sands through the hourglass, time moved on and so did Billy Ray. Most notable in the years from then till now is Cyrus being one half of the parties responsible for Miley Cyrus, and is known to the younger generation from his role as Robby Stewart on another pop culture success, Hannah Montana, during the mid-to-late 00’s.
More than once, Cyrus poked fun at his biggest hit on the show, and has done several winks and nods to it over the years. He also continued his own, if much lower key, music career of recording and touring. A whole generation of kids grew up with Robby Stewart, model father, the way other kids had Danny Tanner, Carl Winslow, or Jason Seaver around the time Achy Breaky was doing it’s thing.
Meanwhile, the world changed again. Whereas Billy Ray rode the music video medium to stardom, and his daughter the Disney express to fame, Montero Lamar Hill took the newest method of social media content creation to stardom. Known professionally as Lil Nas X, he spun a popular Nikki Minaj fan account into his own music career. It worked, and his track “Old Town Road” has become a viral sensation. All was well…until Billboard decided to intervene:
“Old Town Road” became popular earlier this year on the app TikTok before leaping onto the Hot 100 four weeks ago. The track was labelled “country” on SoundCloud, and country radio stalwarts like Florida Georgia Line’s Brian Kelley later endorsed the song on social media. “Old Town Road” initially debuted on Billboard‘s Hot Country Songs chart.
Billboard subsequently removed “Old Town Road” from the country chart, suggesting “it does not embrace enough elements of today’s country music.” While Cyrus did not directly address the genre credentials of “Old Town Road,” he showed his support for the song last week in an Instagram post to his 1.4 million followers. “Don’t try and think inside the box,” Cyrus wrote. “Don’t think outside the box. Think like there is no box. #HorsesInTheBack” — a reference to a lyric from “Old Town Road” that subsequently became a popular meme.
“Old Town Road” is at Number 15 on the latest Hot 100. The track continues to stream this week — it’s currently the only song on Spotify’s Top 5 in the U.S. not by Billie Eilish. It’s also gaining support from pop radio: 39 new stations added the song this week, according to Nielsen BDS.
Cyrus did one better than just support the crossover hit on social media. Last night, the remix of the song, featuring Billy Ray Cyrus, hit the interwebs.
Some will debate if that finally makes it “country” enough. But who cares. What a fun story. From a guy who has had high highs and low lows of a career to make something fun, and a good tune, in the most modern of formats with a decidedly new-school star, this is the stuff that needs to be appreciated. It’s hardly the first genre mashing. Ludacris performed onstage at the CMT awards in 2011, Nelly and Tim McGraw collaborated before that, and there are other examples including the aforementioned Florida Georgia Line and Nelly again.
And country purists have no room to talk anyway. Those are the people who once insisted that the “outlaw” movement would ruin the genre but now worship at the auditory altar of Waylon, Willie, and the boys. Long before metalheads found it cool to wear black and sing about murder and death, Johnny Cash had already been there and done that. Hank Williams wrote some of the definitive country songs and one of the most beloved gospel songs of all time. And speaking of Willie, he went from button down song writer for Patsy Cline and others to legendary status both for music and being the only person to make Snoop Dogg hit the time out button smoking. Now there are some who think modern country is too pop/rock/rap/whatever else they don’t like.
Oh, shut up.
You really want to argue that lyrically, Billy waxing poetic about diamond rings and Maseratis on Rodeo Drive isn’t musically acceptable considering where he’s come from as an artist? I lived through Achy Breaky; this is much, much better.
The beauty of the streaming age is kids, unlike we who had our music dictated by what you could get on the radio or at the store, can instantly access anything. And with apps and programs, making and mashing together songs and genres has never been easier.
But more importantly, the 38-year-old me got to roll up to the middle school and drop my kid off with a song featuring Billy Ray Cyrus playing a bit too loud, and not only did I not get beat up for it like would have happened were it 1992, but she thought it was cool. I know because she downloaded it to her playlist immediately, thanked me for telling her about it, and immediately ran up to a friend to share it with her. What fun. Plus, no line dancing this time. Life is good.
Line Dancing is a good thing.Report
I’m not saying I’ve never partaken, mind you…Report
This is morally and aesthetically true.Report
I should have opened with “actually”.Report
Line dancing, like war, is necessary and can serve the greater good, but we shouldn’t pretend like there were not casualties involved in the process, is all I’m saying…Report
I should have concluded with “always and everywhere, amen.”Report
Never done it. But since I’ve done contradance and square dancing, and other genres, I figure I’d like it. What little I’ve seen looks like fun.
AND, like Andrew says, there have been casualties.Report
No. No it’s not. Songs like “Still Doin’ Time” are a good thing and that’s not conducive to line danging.Report
Although I had a casual acquaintance with country music (mostly classic and outlaw), knew who Billy Ray Cyrus was, and had heard of his big hit, when I clicked on the link to Achy, Breaky Heart I realized that I had never heard it until today. Not that I’d missed much, but I try not to be completely out of touch.Report
You’ve heard the song.
Learn the dance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbHBbFIFH2oReport
I was a huge fan of Helene Fischer, who is a “country” artist in Germany, though she was born to German parents in the far reaches of the Soviet Union because Stalin. She’s the eighth most highly paid female musician, bringing in $32 million in 2018.
But German “country” is hard to describe. It’s like a love child of Lawrence Welk, the Mandrel Sisters, and maybe the Muppets. It’s what you might expect as the entertainment at an Elk’s Lodge in Minnesota.
Guardian article on her
Anyway, there are tons of videos of her on Youtube, and they’re kind of like Achy Breaky Heart cranked to 11. Stick Billy Ray in a Victoria’s Secret Angel costume, add backup dancers, and have him belt out Ethel Merman hits and you’ll be close to the horror of it all. Yet she’s soooo good at it.Report
Country has always had a “No True Scotsman” problem. You sort of either grew up with it, like baseball, or you wouldn’t really “get it”. As dance music, I think the cross with swing was the most effective variant. If you played Ray Price shuffles, they danced. As dance music, it wasn’t polkas but it was good to dance to, and it had a lot of musical value.
There is a video interview with the eminent Junior Brown, who says ” the society that supported it (country music) just died out.” And he’s right. It’s about 1:30 into the video.
It’s “sleepwalk guitar talk, Jun 13, 2013 ” on teh YouTube.
It’s rather a bizarre thing to have an affinity for. But you get steeped in it when you grew up around certain radio stations that the adults you were around liked.Report
The society of American country music is really global, so it will do fine.
Clip from Kenyan TV
The most requested artist on radio stations in Nairobi and throughout Kenya is Kenny Rogers.
From an NPR story about it: “Henry Makhoka heads programming for the Kenya Broadcasting Corporation, the nation’s oldest and largest radio station. Makhoka says the allure of country music in Africa is its iconic characters – the gamblers and the highway men, the handwringing mothers and the cock-sure sons, the Rubys, the Lucilles, the Joleens, the grievous angels and the folks who just ain’t no good. These are the characters whose stories Kenyans identify with more than anything that smells like teen spirit.”
Here’s Don William’s obituary in Kenyan media
“While mourning the great singer, satirist and journalist Ted Malanda wrote: “Moment of silence for the thousands of Kenyan kids who were conceived with Don Williams crooning in the background,” underpinning the influence the crooner had in the daily lives of Kenyans from different backgrounds.”Report
Country has also found a serious home in Europe in general, and Scandinavia in particular. But it’s marginal at best. There is support enough to keep professionals employed. I’d say that that’s only marginally true within the US.
What I mean by “having a society” is whether or not new catalog will be developed and whether that new catalog will exist along side say, Kenny Rogers. The acts like Florida Georgia Line are constructed acts and other than people dancing to them at a prom, nobody’s going to remember than in 20 years.
Om general, we’ve lost the monoculture and what advantages came from that. Kenny Rogers is of that. But I doubt we’ll see even any Kenny Rogers rising on the horizon. You can’t have narrowcasting and strong product at the same time.Report
Looking at a list of net worth, the only ones higher than Kenny Rogers are George Strait, Garth Brooks, Toby Keith, Shania Twain, and Dolly Parton.
The big threat to other musical styles was shown in a rendition of “Amarillo by Morning” on Mongolia’s Got Talent. A nomadic horse people, bursting from the steppes to spread country music across half the known world is a real threat. But on the bright side, it would be much scarier if they were singing death metal.
And judging by an amazing performance on Vietnam’s Got Talent, country is winning there too.Report