Erik will be happy: Canada is getting rid of the penny. A loonie for your thoughts?
Rufus F.
Rufus is a likeable curmudgeon. He has a PhD in History, sang for a decade in a punk band, and recently moved to NYC after nearly two decades in Canada. He wrote the book "The Paris Bureau" from Dio Press (2021).
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024My poll doesn't match everyone else's, ergo there is a good chance that I'm wrong and everyone else…
on The Way Through is Donald Trump for PresidentThe vast majority of voters are incapable of forming an informed opinion on whether there should be…
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024"herding may make individual polls more accurate" I see what he's trying to say here but I don't thi…
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024What I have to keep reminding people is that it isn't just Trump, as if he is an isolated oddity. Le…
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024Oh yeah, if the baseline polls are cooked...so are we.
on The Way Through is Donald Trump for PresidentThus proving my point.
on The Way Through is Donald Trump for PresidentI'm sure that's exactly how Justice Alito will see it.
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024Here's the line that should make you take a little bit more of the covers tonight: "The irony, as I… on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024It's pretty sad that people's inability to understand poll results leads directly to polls purposely… on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024Nate Silver has a post on herding. I knew that something like this was happening but I never knew it…
November 1, 2024
Danny Thinks Halloween a Fine Chance to be Funny
October 31, 2024
October 30, 2024
October 29, 2024
on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024
on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back
on Weekend Plans Post: We’re Getting It Back on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024
I know that there are actual reasons for stuff like this. But there’s something about these kinds of decisions that feel like having Andy Rooney dictate policy.Report
This is an interesting comment. Listening to talking heads (not to mention just reading Facebook comments), it is the pro-penny side that is far more in the Andy Rooney realm. There’s lots of fear-mongering, irrational anger, conspiracy theories and general curmudgeonous.
The anti-penny side (excluding politicians) tend to be far more reasonable, relying on studies, reason and un-emotional analysis (at least from what I have encountered).Report
My impression of the Andy Roony (r.i.p.) take would be this: he’d talk about how the word “penny” begins with the letter “p” and how he can’t understand why the lower-case version of some letters don’t resemble the upper-case version the way the letter “p” does. After about 3 or 4 minutes of this, the show would be over.Report
Coin collector here.
I have an Australian penny and an Israeli one, both discontinued.
I already have a few Canadian ones, so that will make three discontinued pennies.
The US just came out with a redesigned penny, so I don’t think it’s going away anytime soon, although it does make sense that it should do so.
From what I’ve read, Canada also has a statute prohibiting purchases with more than 25 pennies at one time. We need that one here, but unfortunately, neither party has added this as a plank.Report
It’s my understanding, that the 25 pennies rule is a myth. If I recall correctly, the law is more vague, stating that shopkeepers don’t have to accept an unreasonable amount of coins – but it’s been a while since I’ve been in retail.Report
Yeah, I’ve definitely seen some old ladies pay for their groceries with a lot of pennies. I do wish I could have them arrested for it.Report
Yeah, it sucks. And on the receiving end, if you don’t just accept them all, you risk creating a big scene (which could hold up any line).
What was especially irritating was that I worked in a store where everything came out to the nickel, so pennies were useless to us.Report
Report
(Psst- check out Erik’s post I linked to)Report
Heh; “Great Minds”.Report
I actually have been pondering a post wondering if it would be possible for an individual state to “abolish the penny.” The word “abolish” meant in a looser context: Basically, require that all vendors within the state price things to the nearest nickel (after tax). Pennies would still be valid currency and all, but would stop being necessary.Report
Once they’ve made the transition I doubt they’ll miss it. We no longer have anything smaller than 10 cents.Report
So how does anyone ever manage to put in their two cents?Report
Electronically, like a civilised human being. What it this, the Middle Ages? Besides which, with inflation that 2 cents is going to cost more anyway.Report
I’m not really opposed to it, but it seems weird to have amounts of money that can’t be physically represented by our currency. For anything that comes out to $19.97, or $8.14, or whatever – the price will be meaningless, because it’s physically impossible to pay that amount without the penny.
My guess is that it will be good on the whole, though, not because the penny’s expensive to make (I doubt it makes any significant dent in the budget), but because everything will get incrementally cheaper as retailers downgrade costs from $x.99 to $x.95.Report
It’s not unlike gasoline, though, which it’s 9/10 tag at the end. You just round up. Or down. The only place you’re likely to see the .99 to .95 are states without sales taxes. Otherwise, it won’t really matter. Unless we require vendors to include sales taxes in posted prices.Report
We do not, in fact, have ‘states’.Report
Oh, I forgot you were up there. Does Canada do the 9/10 at the end of gasoline prices (if not, you’ll get used to it)? Are sales taxes a part of the listed price (if something is $1.99, is it $1.99 or $1.99 plus tax)?Report
Yes, the gas stations list the price to one digit beyond one cent. Most places don’t include sales taxes in the listed prices, but the actual prices also don’t typically round to the nearest $0.05.Report
Oh, and everywhere has sales taxes. Alberta may not have a provincial one, but everyone pays the federal sales tax (GST/HST). It’s how we afford public health care.Report
I get the sense that if we ever have a national sales tax down here, it will be included in the listed price.
Will the prices in Canada have to be rounded to the nearest 5c? I figured that it would work like the 9/10. The price can be whatever, but only has to be paid to the nearest five cents.Report
I greatly prefer when tax is included in the sale price. Just makes things so much easier. I don’t know that it should be required, but I personally would prefer to see it more often.Report
I would want it included in the event of a national sales tax. With local and state sales taxes, it’s a little more complicated. If you sell a magazine, for instance, the price will then be different in different states and even different counties. We can say “Oh, well the operator of the magazine rack ought to include the tax-included price,” but it would make things complicated. The ability to advertise a single price is an economic plus and is lost with different taxical add-ons here and there and everywhere.
But if the tax is uniform, then by all means it should be included. I might support making it mandatory.Report
Will the prices in Canada have to be rounded to the nearest 5c?
I think that’s how it’s going to work, yes.Report
Not necessarily, you still get prices marked in less than 10c increments in New Zealand. If you’re paying with EFTPOS or credit card you pay the listed prices, if you’re paying cash the bill gets rounded to the nearest 10c. The notion your currency is defined by your coinage is archaic.Report