Burt Likko
Pseudonymous Portlander. Pursuer of happiness. Bon vivant. Homebrewer. Atheist. Recovering Republican. Recovering Catholic. Recovering divorcé. Editor-in-Chief Emeritus of Ordinary Times. Relapsed Lawyer, admitted to practice law (under his real name) in California and Oregon. There's a Twitter account at @burtlikko, but not used for posting on the general feed anymore. House Likko's Words: Scite Verum. Colite Iusticia. Vivere Con Gaudium.
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
on The Mandate That Wasn’tThis. if we want to go back to situations other than those we found ourselves in, we can stipulate t…
on The Mandate That Wasn’tInterpreted by whom? I said in an earlier thread that the Dems are going to come crawling back to th… on The Mandate That Wasn’tHeh! I thought the analysis showed but for DJT turning his head at an extremely fortunate moment he'…
on The Mandate That Wasn’t"Hey, Vincent, don't you see? That sh*t don't matter. You're judging this sh*t the wrong way. I mean… on The Mandate That Wasn’tNo one dodges a bullet in real life. It's either bad aim or luck that saves you.
on The Mandate That Wasn’tGolly, I sure wish we had a press that wasn't obviously in the bag for the Democratic Party right ab… on The Mandate That Wasn’tIn the movies? No. But in real life? What would dodging bullets even look like in real life?
on The Mandate That Wasn’tThe interesting thing will be when the Congressional Democrats shut down government again, will it b… on The Mandate That Wasn’tThing is, “Kamala actually did pretty well. Nobody could have done better" appears to be true. Anywh…
on All the President’s Nominees: The Legion of GroomI think you need to re-read that Gabbard piece. She backed off her comments. And your memory of RTFL…
November 20, 2024
Movie of a Young Man Calling on a Lady Friend
November 19, 2024
November 18, 2024
November 17, 2024
on How Republicans Can Save Trump’s Presidency on Open Mic for the week of 11/18/2024
on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t
on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t
on The Mandate That Wasn’t
on The Mandate That Wasn’t on The Mandate That Wasn’t on Open Mic for the week of 11/18/2024
on How Republicans Can Save Trump’s Presidency
The list of films nominated for an Academy Award for best film editing and one for best screen play (either adapted or original) in each year of the 21st century.Report
That seems as good a guess as anything I could come up with without resorting to Teh Google.Report
Teh Google will be useless, I assure you. Wikipedia was the only resource I used to research this question. (Yes, I know. IMDB would have produced the same information, just not quite as fast because I am not as fluent with its search functions.)Report
For the record, I did resort to IMDB, and my post above is correct, afaict, but apparently not sufficient or not what you were looking for. (which I figured about 2 out of 3 probability of being the case, but have lost the race before when I have hesitated in some of the questions that have become sprints)Report
@kolohe you’re on the dartboard, for sure. I strongly suspect that with more clues you’ll throw a bulls-eye. Will you get it first, though? That’s the charm of Monday Trivia.Report
With “Crash” on the list, I have to assume this is a list of @russell-saunders ‘s favorite movies.Report
Hey, neat! When my blood pressure gets this high, all kinds of fun things start to happen.
Lookit them fun spots that are appearing in my visual fields! And wow! Now my whole arm is numb! COOL!Report
Movies I have never watched in my kitchen.Report
Tuesday hint: Do you want me to provide the list for the 1990’s too? If I took the time, I could go back much longer than that. It’ll be more of the same. And probably not very helpful to anyone.
So instead, piggybacking off of @Kolohe’s guess, obviously, not every movie here turned out to be a winner. But there is a way in which one might argue that these should have been the winners.Report
Must… fight… urge… to rant… about “Crash.”
Effective use of flashbacks with regard to editing?I changed my mind. Something about editing that involves effectively incorporating other footage or material into the action of the movie. A play in “Finding Neverland,” for example, or video footage for “127 Hours.”Report
Wednesday hint: One of each nominee wins the Oscar based upon the subjective, and some would say, arbitrary, vote of the members of the Academy. But my selection from among those same nominees is much, much more objective.Report
Thursday hint: Film editing exists for a lot of reasons. One of them is artistic, but the other one is practical. I’m interested in the practical reason: not only one’s bladder, but one’s attention span, can be taxed when film editing is not good.Report
Movies with the shortest running time of all the movies nominated for best film editing that year.Report
Boom goes the dynamite.
Seems to me that with the great aids to storytelling that visual and audio cues can bring, moviemakers have the ability to pack a whole lot more information into a few seconds of time than an author of written material. So at least one school of thought leads to the place that a well-edited movie ought to be a shorter movie. (Plus shorter movies mean more screenings per day, which means more revenue!)Report
moviemakers have the ability to pack a whole lot more information into a few seconds of time than an author of written material. So at least one school of thought leads to the place that a well-edited movie ought to be a shorter movie.
Not inherently wrong, and I definitely feel that most movies now are much longer than they need be, but by no means a hard and fast rule. More, and longer, shot lengths may be necessary to generate the desired impact (that is, increased shot length *itself* may be used to impart information regarding the “velocity” of the story and/or provoke specific emotional viewer responses). See below for a pretty interesting bit on average shot length’s impact (article and comments specifically call out longer, and well-edited, films like The Godfather and Lawrence of Arabia):
http://www.avclub.com/articles/its-not-just-the-direction-that-makes-donnie-darko,104624/Report
Also, I should clarify: It is obviously possible to have a shorter movie with longer ASL’s. Or a longer movie with shorter ASL’s. One doesn’t imply the other.
My point was just that many examples of longer ASL’s are ALSO long movies that are also considered “well-edited”movies.Report
I realize the truth of what you say, @glyph , and I readily admit that simply looking at the bottom line of runtime is a very clumsy index of proficient editing.
Inspiration for the question came from scrolling through movies to watch about a week ago, when Natasha announced that a two-hour movie was longer than she cared to sit through. So we spent nearly half an hour looking for a 90-minute movie that we both wanted to watch.Report
Dude, I am with you. 90 minutes is about as long as I ever want to (or can) go at a stretch, and I have definitely made viewing decisions based on length; plus, I’ve long liked the (probably specious, but appealing nonetheless) idea that 90-minute film durations map nicely to human dream cycles (a theory recently espoused again by Nicolas Winding Refn). Most movies are WAY too long now.
That said, Lawrence is incredible.Report
and I just noticed this: two-hour movie was longer than she cared to sit through. So we spent nearly half an hour looking for a 90-minute movie that we both wanted to watch.
Yep. Good thing you guys didn’t waste that extra half hour on the movie. 🙂Report
I’ve wondered if, at least within the genre of summer action blockbusters, running time is some sort of insider one-upmanship: my CGI special-effects budget was bigger than yours.Report
Something about the original, pre-editing run time, I’m guessing, though I haven’t a clue what. The number of minutes edited from the director’s cut, or the extended cut, to get to the theatrical release run time?Report