Somniloquy!
Tonight, Mike is all at sixes and sevens recapping The Kindly Ones.
Glyph’s introduction to Sandman, in three parts, here, here, and here.
Preludes and Nocturnes recaps here: Glyph and Patrick tackled the first four issues, Jaybird tackled the fifth, Glyph recapped six and seven. Mike Schilling recapped number eight.
A Doll’s House recaps here: KatherineMW took on the first two issues, then the next two issues. KatherineMW and Jason Tank then reviewed the fifth and sixth, respectively. Mike Schilling reviewed the final two issues.
Dream Country recaps here: Glyph reviewed Calliope then Jaybird and Maribou reviewed Dream of a Thousand Cats in the first review post for Dream Country. Alan Scott reviewed A Midsummer Night’s Dream then Mike Schilling reviewed Façade in the second.
Season of Mists recaps here: Jaybird reviewed the first two in this post. Jason Tank reviewed the next two here. Boegiboe reviewed the next two after that here and here. Ken reviewed the final two here.
A Game of You recaps here: Mike Schilling reviewed the first two in this post. Jason Tank and Mike Schilling tackled the next two issues here. Russell Saunders gave us the last two issues here.
Fables and Reflections recaps here: Ken and Jaybird reviewed the preview plus the first two issues here. Mike Schilling and Jaybird did the next two issues here. KatherineMW did the next issue here. Glyph, Ken, and Russell did the Sandman Special issues here.
Brief Lives recaps here: Jason Tank recapped Chapter 1 and Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 2 here. Reformed Republican recapped Chapter 3 and Jaybird recapped Chapter 4 here. Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 5 and Glyph recapped Chapter 6 here. Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 7 and Glyph recapped Chapter 8 here.
World’s End issues #51 (A Tale of Two Cities) and #52 (Cluracan’s Tale) reviewed here by Jason Tank and James K. Issues #53 (Hob’s Leviathan) and #54 (The Golden Boy) reviewed here by KatherineMW and Reformed Republican. Ken reviewed Issues #55 (Cerements) and #56 (“World’s End”) here.
The Kindly Ones recaps here: Mike Schilling recapped the Prologue to and Part One here. Glyph and Jaybird recapped parts two and three, respectively, here. Jayson Tank recapped parts four and five here.
It’s very difficult to discuss this book without discussing the next one (or the one after that, or the one after that (if there were one after that, anyway.[/efn_note] If you want to discuss something with a major plot point: please rot13 it. That’s a simple encryption that will allow the folks who want to avoid spoilers to avoid them and allow the people who want to argue them to argue them.
We good? We good! Everybody who has done the reading, see you below!
PART SIX
This is the only issue of The Kindly Ones so far that stays with a single character’s POV. (Other than the interpolated story.) Rose, flying to the UK, dreams of the old days we saw in The Doll’s House. And once again she wakes uncomfortably and meets a lawyer at the airport. This time, it’s young Mr. Holdaway, the previous one’s nephew. He amuses us (and, I suspect himself) by talking like a stage Englishman: “dicky heart”, “a good innings”, and so on. He drives Rose to the nursing home where her grandmother had slept her life away, and then leaves to check her into the White Hart (which is where Arthur C. Clarke set his hi-tech tall tales, though the reference seems to be just a throwaway), first introducing her to Paul McGuire, the owner/manager/chief attorney (it’s unclear which), and the duty nurse. Rose tells them that she wants just to look around, and proceeds to do so.
She goes to her grandmother’s old room, but it’s empty, and there’s nothing to see. Next door is the janitor’s closet, again nothing, but she attracts the attention of one of the residents, a chatty woman named Amelia. By the time they go down to the day room, we’ve heard much of her life story: during WWII, she had an child with a black GI, and gave him up for adoption. She introduces Rose to two other women: a very old one named Magda, and the mysterious Helena, whose last name is hard to pronounce. Again, three women, and we know Amelia is a mother and Magda a crone. They’re playing a very odd game of checkers where the black and white pieces are on opposite colors, and so could never be captured.
Now Magda tells a story that seems like one of Grimm’s fairy tales before it was prettified. A man seduces a woman, promising to marry her, saying that if doesn’t, may the worms will eat him and their children grow wings and fly away. He then kills an old woman for her home, and moves himself and the woman in. He continues to treat her badly, eventually murdering her. At which point, of course, the children fly back to see what he’s done, and kill him with their beaks and talons. Then the dead woman, now a giant worm, proceeds to eat him.
Helena volunteers that revenge is sacred; she herself had spent decades pursuing a man who had killed someone she loved, to at last ruin his life and then kill him. When Rose asks if she’s joking, She says “Yes, of course.” Uh-huh. (Needless to say, it’s a good description of what Lyta intends for Dream.) All three agree that it was a tragedy for Unity to have slept her life away, since being a woman is an important job: as a mother, says Amelia; and a maiden, adds Helena; and at the end of their lives, finishes Magda.
Roses says good-bye, to wander off. Playing with her grandmother’s ring, she sees a cat (inside) and an owl (outside, in the lightning.) Paul McGuire comes by, and tells Rose that the Hundred Acre Wood is nearby; as a boy he had spent time there looking for the lost, original Piglet doll. He takes her downstairs to see another sleeper, Alex Burgess (the son of the magician who had captured Dream), who holds what looks for all the world like Piglet. Rose leaves him her grandmother’s ring and goes, as McGuire holds Burgess’s hand and reflects on the sins of the father.
PART SEVEN
Thessaly takes a cab to the (pretty awful) part of town where Lyta has wandered to. Lyta is sleeping. A homeless man had tried to touch her, but she dissuaded him by breaking his arm. Thessaly speaks to Lyta, calling herself Larissa, which is a town in Thessaly. Lyta sees her as a white bird and follows her. They leave in the taxi. The homeless men invent a story to explain what they’ve just seen, involving robots, space aliens, and the CIA, little knowing that its real flaw is not being weird enough.
Meanwhile, back in the Dreaming, Dream has a caller, fella name of Odin, who is none too happy with him for freeing Loki. Doesn’t he know that Loki is incapable of gratitude, and will repay good with evil? The ravens will soon be coming to the Dreaming, whatever that means. (It sounds bad. At least Matthew will have some company. and maybe get his questions answered.) Odin asks the big question: Is Dream behind everything that’s happening, or its victim? He gets no answer, and leaves more in sorrow than in anger.
Delirium, whom we last saw as fish (not a euphemism), is concerned that Barnabas the dog is missing. She has come to Destiny’s realm to ask about him, and he warns her that if she finds the dog, she’ll also find troubles. They are standing in front of a set of statues of their family. Dream still looks as devastated as he did after Orpheus’s death. Delirium asks if she should help him, and Destiny duplicates himself to say both yes and no. Then he disappears, and Del must choose which one to listen to.
Back at Thessaly’s house, Lyta still sees her as a bird. Thessaly gives her magical protections, first a potion of honey and leaves, then she sacrifices a lamb, and, a bit bloody, sits down with a good book. (One about Richard Dadd, a 19th Century painter known for fairies and other supernatural subjects.) Lyta now dreams than she is climbing down a steep cliff, She finds a vanity, where she sees herself at various ages, none of whom are happy with her. She smashes the mirror (like Tommy?) and finds a small cottage where she has at last found the Furies.
We now intercut between stories quickly:
Dream visits Fiddler’s Green, in a snippy mood. He and Gilbert quibble.
The Furies offer Lyta a fortune cookie, with a suitably dark and portentous fortune.
Gilbert tries to be kind to Dream, but he talks only of his responsibilities.
The Furies suggest that they are the Furies but also much more.
The Raven who attends the goddess of war joins a passing flock of ravens. (Even though ravens do not flock.)
The Furies do not like that name. It’s sexist.
Matthew and The Corinthian come to Lyta’s apartment, clearly much too late.
Lyta announces that she wants to destroy Dream.
Ravens are flying from everywhere, even Hell. Also London, where the old belief is that if the ravens ever leave the Tower, the kingdom will fall.
The Furies tell Lyta that they can’t avenge her husband and son. They could hound and destroy Dream only if he had a blood debt, that is, had killed his own family. She is in such despair that she claws her own arm bloody. Only then do they let her know — Dream did just that.
The fortune from the fortune cookie comes from “The White Devil”. A horror play from 1612.
http://www.thecabinet.com/plays/play.php?sub_id=classic_horror_plays&play_id=the_white_devil
Act V, Scene VI.
(Flipping through it, it’s not… well, it’s not bad…)Report
Mysterious Helena… there’s a theory that she’s actually Uryran Xbfzngbf, gur bevtvany Shel, zbgure bs Ylgn. Vg znxrf frafr gung fur jbhyq xabj nyy nobhg gur fnperqarff bs eriratr, nf fur jnf tenagrq ure cbjref ol gur Shevrf gurzfryirf. (Fur unq gur Uhyx-yvxr dhnyvgl bs trggvat cbffrffrq ol bar jura fur jnf natel.)
I love the talk with Odin, with the smoke or mist echoing their conversation.
Finally, the reintroduction of Thessaly reminds me of something else I’ve read recently: the three main loves of Dream in the series were also mother, maiden and crone: Calliope, Nada and Thessaly. They’re everywhere in this story!Report
the three main loves of Dream in the series were also mother, maiden and crone
This is awesome.
Also, Thessaly prizing vengeance as the highest good – almost as a religious obligation – fits quite well with what we’ve seen of her in the past.
I actually haven’t had a chance to re-read these issues yet, will hopefully do so today, but it’s explicit that Paul McGuire is “Paul”, Alex Burgess’ lover, right? It’s nice to see that he loyally stuck around all these years with his man essentially in a coma. The Order of Ancient Mysteries might have been an evil coven bent on capturing Death and disrupting the fabric of the universe for their own gain, but they had family values.Report
Yes, Paul’s relationship is made explicit. He is trapped by his love for Alex.
I agree that Thessaly is acting out of obligation, but not an obligation to her ideal of vengeance. She owes the Ladies after her trick with the moon.Report
Goodness I loved this one. The furies were great and Thessaly! I love that snippy snappy old witch.
I do wish, though, that Gaiman hadn’t included the element of the Furies resentment at Orpheus’s making them weep. It made their whole agenda seem so pettily motivated.Report
It’s not surprising that the Furies/Kindly Ones, coming as they do from Greek mythology, would be petty… after all, most of the greek pantheon are as willful, petty and fallible asthe humans they preside over.
Also, isn’t one of the differences between revenge and justice pettiness itself??Report
I do wish, though, that Gaiman hadn’t included the element of the Furies resentment at Orpheus’s making them weep.
Is this a reference back all the way to Sandman Special? I think remembering back to Pluto/Hades saying “they’re never going to forgive you for that” provides a nice little “goose walked over my grave” moment for us…Report
Nf V erpnyy gur shevrf fcrpvsvpnyyl zragvba, va na hcpbzvat fprar jvgu Ylgn, gung Becurhf “jebatrq” gurz fb vg’f zber guna whfg n pnyybhg VZB.Report
I had assumed that the attack by the Bacchanate was the Furies’ getting their revenge. It’s not much of a revenge if the person who wronged you is already dead. (Are they upset that Morpheus ended their eternal punishment?)Report
I mentioned last week the first panel of every issue having the thread motif. The first of this weeks issues does not have the panel, and now I figured out why. It comes from a Vertigo anthology, which also explains the single POV and different artist. My mind is now at rest.
Of course, the Morrigan is yet another example of three ladies, so likely another aspect of the Fates/Furies/Kindly Ones/etc. in this story.
I am pretty sure Dream knew it was in Loki’s nature to betray those to whom he owes a favor, which is why he was the right god for the job. The gods are stories, and they are part of Dream’s domain.
The exchange with Gilbert was a good one. Dream hates being imprisoned, but he does not seem to realize that Gilbert sees himself as being a prisoner. It is not really accurate to say he came back of his own free will if the alternative was uncreation.
That leads me to another thought. After being a prisoner for so long, Dream came to despise being a prisoner. After escaping, he realized he was a prisoner of his own responsibilities. Before, he seemed to derive satisfaction from fulfilling those duties, but now they are just another cage. Throwing off responsibilities (and the consequences of doing so) is a repeated theme of this series. Lucifer abandons his, making them Dream’s problem. Destruction walked away from his, though he did not hand them off to another.
Being freed from prison is another repeated theme. The Cuckoo was a prisoner on the island who wanted to be free to fly. Calliope was a prisoner of the writer, and she was freed. Orpheus was a prisoner inside his head. Johanna Constantine was a prisoner. Nada in hell. Rose’s brother. John Dee. Cluracan in his story from World’s End. I am sure there are some I am forgetting, but I do not think there was a single major arc that did feature a prisoner as a significant plot point.Report
That’s an awesome insight.Report
Being a prisoner by virtue of having responsibilities, particularly to other people, is a core point of exploration for the Existentialists. The horror of war and the despair of prison drove Camus’ writing as well, for example. I think of Dream as a prisoner of war, who, being trapped in torment for 70 years, realizes that the life he loved before being a prisoner has ended. That Dream is already dead. He has to find some way of loving life again, or die trying.Report