The Onion ranks ’em – let the arguments commence! After reading the list, you begin to realize how consistently excellent the last few years of television have been. My personal top five consists of The Wire, The Office (UK), Deadwood, Freaks and Geeks, and the first two and a half seasons of Battlestar Galactica in no particular order. Did they overlook anything? Feel free to throw out your own preferences in comments.
Will
Will writes from Washington, D.C. (well, Arlington, Virginia). You can reach him at willblogcorrespondence at gmail dot com.
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024And that's really my point. The race will be close no matter who the Democrat is because about 45% o…
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024I’m claiming that “candidate quality” has only a very marginal effect... I disagree. Candidate quali…
on Final Thoughts Before November FifthIf it looks like moral panic, walks like moral panic, and quacks like moral panic, it's probably mor…
on Open Mic for the week of 11/4/2024It is getting lost in the run-up to the election but the Epstein tapes reveal some rather monstrous…
on Final Thoughts Before November FifthThe only help for them is a stint in federal prison. on Final Thoughts Before November FifthFor the record I don't disagree with any of that. I don't think there's some grand conspiracy. I do…
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024Well, yes, I saw. Hence the comment. Eric sends his regards.
on Final Thoughts Before November FifthHow about we figure out how folks who raided the Capitol and those laying the groundwork to subvert…
on Final Thoughts Before November FifthI know you're just having a go, but the guy was very careful to make it clear that his congregation… on Final Thoughts Before November FifthYes, unsarcastically.
November 3, 2024
November 2, 2024
November 1, 2024
Danny Thinks Halloween a Fine Chance to be Funny
October 31, 2024
on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024 on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth
on Final Thoughts Before November Fifth
on Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024
I’ve been making this argument for some time: We are in an absolute golden age of television. Sitcoms have never been this good; hour long dramas have never been this good; pay cable has opened up a whole new world of narrative possibilities. We’ve experienced a revolution in the format first hand.
And “The Shield” is easily top-three on any “shows of the decade” list.Report
Agree entirely re: the golden age of television.
As for The Shield, I never really watched it consistently enough to render final judgment. A top five show, though? The premise seems a little too far-fetched, albeit interesting.Report
You’re absolutely correct, Sonny. Then again, one of my pet peeves is when people decry the cultural wasteland that is television. In my opinion, the novel is in far worse shape. And American film hasn’t exactly come back, either. I tend to think people who wail about TV do so out of snobbishness–sure, reality TV sucks, as does most scripted stuff, but most of everything sucks. The question is: are there people out there doing good work in the medium? And like you, I think the case is very much so.Report
Much agreed.Report
Deadwood was good for the first season. Tanked after that. Agreed on BSG. Haven’t watched the others, though I like the US version of the Office a lot. I really think Lost is quite good. As was Rome.Report
The UK Office is too far down. Freaks and Geeks is way too far up.Report
Oh, and Wonder Showzen is way, way too far down.
It’s hard to compare absurdist scathing political children’s show parody to perpetual narrative drama, but to me Wonder Showzen is the most artistically forward and successful of any of them.Report
I seriously can’t believe their highest-ranked Adult Swim show is Tim & Eric. Venture Bros. was WAY too low as well. VB has greater, weirder depths than just about anything on today.Report
Incidentally, The Twilight Zone is my pick for best show of all time.Report
That’s a decent pick, although your lack of respect for Freaks and Geeks is disheartening.Report
Well, I’d still put it in the top 15 or so.Report
They overlooked quite a lot of my favorites, actually. Any Oughts top ten of mine would include Life On Mars (UK)- an awesome and brilliantly acted sci-fi pastiche, Farscape (No. 2 on my Top Five Space Opera shows and more consistent than BSG), New Doctor Who (but not Torchwood, which was a bit too soapy), and the romance-in-art-school josei anime Honey & Clover. Also, all three Bryan Fuller series (excluding Heroes and Star Trek Voyager). Dead Like Me, Wonderfalls, and Pushing Daisies were all better than half the shows on here. I can’t believe they didn’t include a single one of these.
My vote for best Adult Swim show (and favorite Western animated show period, actually) would probably be Home Movies, Brendan Small’s brilliant slice-of-life cartoon about a pretentious child filmmaker, his best friends, his single mom, and his asshole soccer coach.
I’d also like to nominate Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex. Don’t judge it based on the certain former commenter who took her (misspelled) name and avatar from it, please.Report
Okay, a ranking:
1. Honey & Clover
2. Life on Mars UK
3. Wonderfalls
4. BSG
5. Home Movies
6. Ghost In The Shell Stand Alone Complex
7. Farscape
8. Venture Bros.
9. Pushing Daisies
10. Dead Like Me
11. Firefly
12. Doctor Who
13. 30 Rock
14. Buffy/Angel
15. Mad Men
I’ve still never seen The Wire, though. I will eventually, I hope.Report
I could easily change my mind on the ordering though.Report
1) Watch The Wire.
2) Never saw Wonderfalls. Heard it was excellent.
3) Farscape > BSG? Seriously? I refuse to take that ranking seriously.Report
I will whenever I can rent DVDs and have time.
And I didn’t say it was better, I said it was more consistent. Notice how BSG is at #4 and Farscape at #7?Report
Also, my memories could be a little skewed on that one, as it’s been a while since I’ve seen it. I know some people didn’t care for the later seasons for that either. But I thought it was delightfully strange and original. I don’t expect too many people to agree anyway.Report
For my money:
1. the wire
2. freaks & geeks (although the fact that it only really aired on “Fox Family” in the 2000s makes me question its inclusion)
3. friday night lights
4. big love
5. arrested development
6. dexter
7. the venture brothers
8. 30 rock
9. curb your enthusiasm
10. gossip girl
XOXOReport
What I wonder is how one would rank The Daily Show, Colbert Report and SNL in this list. I think all three shows have been brilliant, especially the last few years. And in terms of cultural impact, Jon Stewart has definitely outpaced his audience.Report
It’s kind of strange that they put the UK Office on there, but no other non-US shows (none that I noticed, anyway). As a fan of Britcoms, I’d have to say that Spaced and Black Books deserve spots in at least the top-15.Report
It’s odd that South Park isn’t making any lists. It began before the decade, but so did Buffy (1997), and that’s on the list.
I’d go:
1) Deadwood (even the last season, which was just weird and ended poorly, was one of the best seasons of television I’ve watched. The previous seasons were twice as good)
2) The Wire
3) South Park
4) Venture Brothers (this is twice the show of Tim & Erik’s Awesome Show Great Job)
5) Battlestar Galactica
6) Rome
7) Top Chef
8) Monk
9) Psych
10) MetalocalypseReport
Oh, and honorable mention goes to Korgoth of Barbaria, which produced only a single episode (the pilot) that was one of the best things I’d ever seen. Pitch perfect mockery of Conan.Report
Glad someone else is giving Deadwood some love, Sidereal.Report
Metalocalypse is pretty great, I agree.
IMO South Park is too topical, which means a lot of it gets dated really fast. I was never a big fan to begin with though.Report
In no particular order but numbered for clarity:
1.) BSG
2.) Futurama
3.) The West Wing
4.) 30 Rock
5.) Dead Like Me – as a bildungsroman variant it’s fantastic.
6.) Queer As Folk
7.) Friday Night Lights – from what little I’ve seen, fantastic.
8.) Damages – just started but so far, so good
Honorable Mention to SATC for cultural contributions.
Honorable Mention for potential to Glee.
Honorable Mention for raising the bar, Project Runway/Top Chef. They both could’ve been cheap explorations of the banal but I think married entertaining eccentricity with respect for the artistry and professionalism of the fashion and culinary industries.
Just missed: First Season Brothers & SistersReport
Have you seen Wonderfalls at all?
Part of me thinks Dead Like Me suffers in comparison to Fuller’s other shows due to having lasted two full seasons. The entire season-2 subplot about Daisy and Evil TV Producer Eric McCormack was not so great. (And lets not get started on the DVD movie that doesn’t exist.)Report
although i havn’t seen all of the shows on this list, it isn’t bad. but one that i would think of would go something like:
1. arrested development
2. the boondocks
3. psych
4. rob & big
5. futurama
6. venture bros.
7. royal pains
8. white collar
9. burn notice
10. life (although the final season tanked in on itself and was disappointing to say the least)
11. dexter
12. generation kill
13. manswers (mostly for the gaudy comedy embraced in it)
14. the office (UK) (i LOVE ricky gervais)
15. the office (US)
16. how i met your mother (NPH is just wayyy to memorable)
17. two and a half men (although it goes somewhat up and down, it’ll still produce some worthwhile laughs)
18. metalocalypse
19. chappelle’s show (some of the best sketch comedy i’ve ever watched)
20. harvey birdman: attorney at law (under appreciated greatness)Report