Search
TEN SECOND BUZZ
- From NPR: Germany’s coalition government collapses as Chancellor Scholz fires his finance chiefNovember 7, 2024No Comments
- The Shepherds have a Credibility ProblemNovember 6, 202428 Comments
- Open Mic for the week of 11/4/2024November 4, 202420 Comments
- From Twitter: Arnold Schwarzenegger announces that he will be voting for HarrisOctober 30, 20243 Comments
- Group Activity: Kamala Harris on Club Shay ShayOctober 28, 20241 Comment
Features
Hot Posts
A Message From Devcat
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
Recent Comments
- Chris in reply to Dark Matter on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?(1) is one I hear a lot, but if you have immigrants working and paying taxes, how are they any more…
- Chris in reply to Glyph on TrumpedI went carless for 10 years (and lived mostly as though I didn't have a car for a few years before t…
- InMD in reply to Jaybird on TrumpedHeh I know who Hawley is. And if they changed it back me and something like 98% of the fans would ch…
- Philip H in reply to Dark Matter on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?4) There is going to be “Unfair competition for jobs”, the lowering of wages/working conditions, and…
- Glyph in reply to Chris on TrumpedI'm hoping the cars I have now (2003 and 2011) are the last cars I ever had to buy but that's probab…
- Philip H in reply to Dark Matter on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?This person has no interest in good governance.
- Philip H in reply to Derek S on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?Guess how many request to reopen the shut down part of the refineries were approved by Biden’s peopl…
- Philip H in reply to Derek S on TrumpedI have dogged Biden on most of his people’s policies, but he definitely has Trump beat in showing cl…
- Philip H in reply to Dark Matter on TrumpedAnd talking about a problem the President can't solve does what exactly?
- Jaybird in reply to InMD on TrumpedJosh Hawley is one. Missouri. One of the most "conservative" senators in the senate. Oh, god. This m…
Comics
-
November 7, 2024
-
The End of the Political Parade
November 6, 2024
-
No Matter which Candidates You Bet on, You’ll Get a Shock or Two
November 5, 2024
-
November 4, 2024
More Comments
- Jaybird in reply to Dark Matter on Trumped
- InMD in reply to Glyph on Trumped
- Chris in reply to JoeSal on Trumped
- Jaybird on Open Mic for the week of 11/4/2024
- Glyph in reply to JoeSal on Trumped
- Jaybird in reply to CJColucci on The Shepherds have a Credibility Problem
- InMD in reply to Dark Matter on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?
- JoeSal in reply to Glyph on Trumped
- Dark Matter in reply to DavidTC on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?
- CJColucci in reply to Jaybird on The Shepherds have a Credibility Problem
- InMD in reply to DavidTC on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?
- InMD in reply to DavidTC on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?
- Roger W on Trumped
- DavidTC in reply to Jaybird on The Shepherds have a Credibility Problem
- DavidTC in reply to InMD on History Was Made in 2024 Election, Now What?
How popular are these gun laws with Canadians though? My Canadian friends are largely NDP types and seem to support very strong gun laws including the ones you go against here.
Posts like this always underly the tension in democratic government between popularity and good policy/liberty.
For the sake of hypothetical, suppose you are right and these policies and laws are as horrible as you describe but are also extremely popular with your fellow Canadians. Which should trump in a majoritarian-democracy: good policy or something that is the popular will? When does the popular will of a majority have a right to trump against what might be a better policy?Report
First, to be clear, “Suppose you are right” is not the correct formulation, as this is an opposite day post, I don’t actually hold this position. Now, to your questions:
There’s a big split on gun laws, and a lot of it is the red state vs. blue state (to use an American phrasing) sort of thing, as well as an urban vs rural divide. I would say that gun control is generally pretty popular, with most people disagreeing at the margins of the issue, rather than the core.
That being said, there appears to be a growing movement of gun-right activists (essentially calling for our own second amendment, even using its wording) who are trying to change things.
To your last question, personally, I think elected officials have to consider both the will of their constituents as well as what is good for the nation/province/citizens/whatever. Part of the reason, I would argue, that we elect these representatives is to have people who can focus completely on policy issues, and we need to trust them–to a certain extent–to use their best judgement even if it means making unpopular decisions.
But it really is a balancing act.Report
Actually, those laws seem very similar to US gun laws. There are lots of ‘gotcha’ laws that were sold with the intent to trip up criminals & gangsters, but that are more often than not applied harshly to people who are, for all intents & purposes, harmless.Report
I used to be abl? to find good ifo from your art?cles.Report