Somniloquy!
Tonight, Mike S finishes off the collection entitled The Wake.
Glyph’s introduction to Sandman, in three parts, here, here, and here.
Preludes and Nocturnes recaps here: Glyph and Patrick tackled the first four issues, Jaybird tackled the fifth, Glyph recapped six and seven. Mike Schilling recapped number eight.
A Doll’s House recaps here: KatherineMW took on the first two issues, then the next two issues. KatherineMW and Jason Tank then reviewed the fifth and sixth, respectively. Mike Schilling reviewed the final two issues.
Dream Country recaps here: Glyph reviewed Calliope then Jaybird and Maribou reviewed Dream of a Thousand Cats in the first review post for Dream Country. Alan Scott reviewed A Midsummer Night’s Dream then Mike Schilling reviewed Façade in the second.
Season of Mists recaps here: Jaybird reviewed the first two in this post. Jason Tank reviewed the next two here. Boegiboe reviewed the next two after that here and here. Ken reviewed the final two here.
A Game of You recaps here: Mike Schilling reviewed the first two in this post. Jason Tank and Mike Schilling tackled the next two issues here. Russell Saunders gave us the last two issues here.
Fables and Reflections recaps here: Ken and Jaybird reviewed the preview plus the first two issues here. Mike Schilling and Jaybird did the next two issues here. KatherineMW did the next issue here. Glyph, Ken, and Russell did the Sandman Special issues here.
Brief Lives recaps here: Jason Tank recapped Chapter 1 and Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 2 here. Reformed Republican recapped Chapter 3 and Jaybird recapped Chapter 4 here. Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 5 and Glyph recapped Chapter 6 here. Mike Schilling recapped Chapter 7 and Glyph recapped Chapter 8 here.
World’s End issues #51 (A Tale of Two Cities) and #52 (Cluracan’s Tale) reviewed here by Jason Tank and James K. Issues #53 (Hob’s Leviathan) and #54 (The Golden Boy) reviewed here by KatherineMW and Reformed Republican. Ken reviewed Issues #55 (Cerements) and #56 (“World’s End”) here.
The Kindly Ones recaps here: Mike Schilling recapped the Prologue to and Part One here. Glyph and Jaybird recapped parts two and three, respectively, here. Jason Tank recapped parts four and five here. Mike Schilling recapped issues six and seven here. Jaybird and Jason Tank tackled issues eight and nine here. Jaybird recapped ten and eleven here. Mike recapped twelve and thirteen here.
The Wake recaps here: Mike Schilling recapped Chapters One and Two here. Jason Tank and James K did Three and Four respectively here.
It’s very difficult to discuss this book without discussing the next one (or the one after that, or the one after that (if there were one after that, anyway.[/efn_note] If you want to discuss something with a major plot point: please rot13 it. That’s a simple encryption that will allow the folks who want to avoid spoilers to avoid them and allow the people who want to argue them to argue them.
We good? We good! Everybody who has done the reading, see you below!
Exiles
This is told in first person and drawn in an unusual style for Sandman, almost like a heavily illustrated conventional story rather than a fully graphic one. The narrator is Master Li, an elderly Chinese bureaucrat who, because of his son’s unwise political decisions, has been exiled to a far city, quite possibly with the intention that he die before arriving there. He is composing in his mind the story of his downfall and exile, some of it quite real, some in dreams, like his encounter with his dead son (who was executed, not exiled).
Li has brought a kitten for companionship, not the brightest thing to do in a trackless desert. When it runs off, he chases it into the tent of a certain pale, unruly-haired person who knows his name, and indeed seems to know quite a lot about everything. He explains that Li has wandered into one of the Soft Places, and is hundreds of years off track. Li expresses astonishment, but lets it go. He asks Morpheus instead to grant him the boon of a cup of wine. Morpheus agrees and (of course) refuses payment. Morpheus tells the story of a friend (yeah, a friend) who also lost his son, but refused to mourn him. Li says, quite justly, that that ws foolishness. Morpheus wishes him farewell.
Li somehow wanders into an amusement park, complete with a hysterically laughing clown-in-a-box and a claw machine. From the latter he wins a toy bridge and uses it to cross a chasm. On the other side he meets Morpheus again, apparently hundreds of years later, although the kitten is still a kitten. A band of horseman approach. They have been condemned to ride through this desert for centuries, apparently since Roman times. Morpheus frees them, though whether back to Rome or to their final reward, we aren’t told. Morpheus offers Li a job in the Dreaming, but Li chooses to obey his Emperor by going to his appointed place of exile. And he remembers what the Roman soldier said just before Morpheus sent him to … wherever. “Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost”.
The Tempest
William Shakespeare is writing a play, His last, actually, of the same name as the current, and last, issue of Sandman. It’s especially written for the king, but not James I of England; I think we can all guess which king Will means. Temporarily blocked, Will goes out to the inn for a pint, though there’s a hell of a storm out.
At the inn, Will is mocked as a writer of godless plays, but the landlady, whose husband Will once did a huge favor, defends him. She alludes to his work on the King James bible, but he shushes her. Her son Tommy seems sweet on Will’s daughter. Two sailors bring a waterlogged corpse to the inn, and show it off for a few pennies. Later, their drunken singing awakens Will at his home.
The next day, Ben Jonson comes to visit. He patronizes Will, considering himself far the superior playwright. Will is uninterested in disputing this. They discuss the Guy Fawkes plot, which is appears that Ben betrayed, and together create the famous verse
Remember, remember!
The fifth of November,
The Gunpowder treason and plot;
I know of no reason
Why the Gunpowder treason
Should ever be forgot!
Will insists that The Tempest will be his last play, and that he is glad to be done writing. (We see a fragment of it, with Caliban looking remarkably like Despair.)
Will’s daughter Judith chides him for having been away from his family in London for most of her childhood. He half-apologizes that he was chasing a dream, but he’s almost done now. Will’s wife Anne is glad that Judith and Tommy appear headed for marriage, but Will is not, remembering that the favor he’d done Tommy’s father was to lend him thirty pounds when he’d spent all of his money on whores.
Will falls asleep and dreams of Morpheus. He complains that his plays give him no pleasure; rather than art, he sees the compromises he had to make to keep the actors happy. Morpheus reminds Will that he owes two plays: the first was the Midsummer Night’s Dream, and this is the second.
A priest has come down from London to congratulate Will for his work on the Psalms, and wishes that God had blessed him with Will’s talent for words. What, Will asks, if the talent came not from God, but from some Other Power? The priest cries that the result would be damnation, and insists on knowing why Will would even ask. Oh, replies Will, I have a character with that problem. (Sure, a character.) The priest suggests that Prospero renounce his magic at the end of the play.
Having finished the play, Will is visited by Morpheus, and suggests they visit the Dreaming for a celebratory libation. On the way, they discuss the play: Will sees all the characters as facets of himself. He is a bit taken aback by the wonders of the Dreaming. After a glass of wine, they discuss their bargain: Will receives the power to create dreams that will live forever; Morpheus, two plays. Had they not made that bargain, Will would have written a few unremarkable plays, returned to Stratford, and been successful but frustrated. But, Will says, I would have lived my life, rather than observing it as raw material for my work.
Now religion arises. Will accuses Morpheus of being a pagan god. (That’s not quite true, of course.) He also confesses hiding his name in Psalm 46. (The 46th word of which is “shake”; the 46th from the end “spear”. He translated it at age 46.) And he asks again, why did Morpheus want this play? Because it’s about a magician who renounces his magical kingdom and thus leaves it.
Exiles is the story that haunts me the most from this particular collection. I very much like the idea that Dream finds folks out there who would make good… somethings… and offers them positions.
They hinted at this with Abel’s story waaaay back there, but that was brought into question with The Furies’ speech when they killed him.
They could easily do a one-shot devoted to the people who were offered jobs… and I’m certain that we could quickly and easily find ourselves back in horror territory for some of them.Report
Oh, and of course, the fact that, once again, we have an example of a guy saying “I need to complete my duty even if I am the only person who knows or cares about it.”Report
I like the art and the writing in “Exiles” very much. Wasn’t much of a fan of “Soft Places”, but it was well worth revisiting here.
Daniel knows he must one day smash his emerald, as Morpheus’ ruby was smashed; but Daniel knows this ahead of time, whereas Morpheus realized it after the fact.
Everything changes, nothing is lost.
Since time is…slippy in Sandman, the scenes with Shakespeare at the inn seem to be an echo of the scene from World’s End, when Morpheus’ body is paraded across the sky; here in gross parody with the drunken sailors parading their corpse of a “savage” (which nonetheless still inspires Will a bit).
I wonder how much Will’s “Dark Lady” (referenced by Ben Johnson) parallels Morpheus’ own; the hints we’ve gotten of his long-running and possibly-tempestuous (Tempestuous?) relationship with Titania.
Speaking of, that’s as good a place as any to segue into this:
http://comic-academic.00server.com/suspects.html
And as this is the end of the Sandman story proper (though it’s my understanding we may do Endless Nights and/or some other related stories) – what did everybody think?
If this was your first time, did it live up to the hype?
If this was a re-read, did you discover new stuff, or did the story change its character for you at all?
http://www.theguardian.com/culture/2013/oct/22/how-we-made-sandman-gaiman
http://www.theguardian.com/books/gallery/2013/oct/22/sandman-dave-mckean-neil-gaiman-picturesReport
You realize that, thanks to that last link there, I have just learned that “Sandman: Overture” is to be published in six days.Report
I am gonna have to wait for some sort of collected edition 🙁Report
My favorite aspect of “Exiles” is how nicely it encapsulates the moral ambiguity that has been a hallmark of the title character (and others) throughout the entire series.
We have a character in Li who is, to my reading, meant to be considered sympathetic. Yet he mentions in passing that his wife tortured a servant to death, employing wire whips somewhere along the way, only to find her reasons for doing so baseless. Horrible, monstrous behavior, mentioned in passing by a man who presumably might have stopped it, a man wise enough to be invited to be Daniel’s advisor in the Dreaming.Report
Also I like that Li gives Morpheus essentially the speech Morpheus gave Orpheus after Eurydice’s death (you grieve and move on; they are dead, you are alive, so live).Report
Man, not with a bang, eh? Where’d everybody go?
Many, many thanks to Mike for bringing us on home, and to Jaybird for OK’ing this particular bookclub idea, and to everyone else who contributed recaps or commentary along the way. It’s been a long strange trip – 75 issues, which may not seem like all that much, except for the fact that each page often contained text, and subtext, and metatext – plus, you know, visual information! – all layered up like a big crazy casserole.
An approximately-two-thousand-page casserole!
I’ve read better books than Sandman, but I’m not sure there’s any single story that I love more. I love its sprawl, and its fractal nature, and its snippets of historical and literary trivia, and most of all its optimistic pessimism (or is it pessimistic optimism?)
I will re-read it again in a couple years, as I always do, and I can’t wait for my kids to be old enough to read it.
I said this early on in ROT13, but I will say it again now unencrypted, for those who didn’t read that for fear of spoilers – on my previous readings, it’s always been my take that the tragedy of Morpheus was that he couldn’t change – that it was an inability to be other than he was that ultimately doomed him.
But this time around, I saw the mirror image – that it was precisely his efforts TO change, to be a LESS stupid, self-centered, appallingly pathetic excuse for an anthropomorphic personification on this particular plane; to take notice of others’ needs, to be better, that ultimately does him in.
And on some level, he knows that it will; and he does it anyway.
See? Optimistic pessimism.
Pessimistic optimism.
I love this book; and if Gaiman had never written another word, these would be more than enough.Report
I’m delighted by the number of stories we’ve read together and thrilled that we made it all the way through. Proud, even.
Thank all of you for all you’ve done. It was surprising what I noticed this time that I overlooked last time… and what I noticed was conspicuously not as conspicuous this time around. The stories never change… but we change.Report
Have you seen this pretty awesome ‘shop of Hans Langseth as Odin?Report
That is awesome.
I suspect that he would have loved it too.Report
As good as Sunday Mourning would have been as an ending for Sandman, The Tempest was the right choice. It spells out, as much as this series spells anything out, what led Morpheus to his end.Report