Commenter Archive

Comments by Andrew Donaldson

On “The Trump Trolley Problem

Write them up, would be happy to post them and expand the range.

On “The “Young Conservative Problem” is Current Conservatives’ Fault

It was this one I think:

To be fair, all of politics -- and political media/commentary especially -- is aimed at the upper-middle class to functional wealthy classes cause that's where the donations, views, consumerism, target marketing is aimed at. But I think you are correct, at least I agree from my own experience, that those drawn to Trump's personality was because they thought of him as the ultimate evolution of themselves if they had the money to do it.

"

A corollary to you thought here Saul, we all remarked and noticed how the MAGA rallies from the 2016 campaign throughout the Trump administration and including January 6th always seemed full of folks with plenty of disposable income, and wanted to be really loud about having disposable income while hollering about how they were part of the oppressed working class. Boat parades are not cheap thing to participate in. This is of course not universal, social media is full of loud jackasses of all ideological stripes. But to the point though I skirt around it in the piece, the more the "conservatism" label becomes exclusively a culture reactionary thing, not ideological and not even really political in the policy sense, the more it's going to fester with the MAGAbros as they have been called elsewhere like the Gaetz and other clowns.

On “Wednesday Writs: 21st Amendment Gets Liquored Up Edition

no doubt. It's amazing to me how such things have effects on everyday life and so few even know it

"

Its one of those things that makes the world go round that few people don't know about

On “A Letter to the Editors: Freddie deBoer and Writing About Forgiveness

Couple things right off the top here:

Everyone involved here knew before this piece was being published and talked with the editors before we posted so this is not an attack or swipe on anyone's part.

JDD didn't know Freddie was an OT Alumnus when he initially wrote the piece.

Nothing about Freddie's situation was in the original JDD piece that Freddie himself has written on publicly and extensively.

Having said all that, let's keep this one civil, like Kristin says in here piece the discourse is what makes this place special.

On “Rep Matt Gaetz Had A No Good, Terrible, Very Bad Day

I'm torn on this one, since "SEX TRAFFFICKING OMG" headlines almost always end up not, in fact, being about sex trafficking at all. My initial feel was that Gaetz was overlapping a very unsavory character in Greenberg and that's the gist of the DOJ push. What paused me from that was Tucker dropping information live on air that a half-decent defense attorney would tell him he probably shouldn't even if innocent. That tidbit Gaetz dropped about the dinner with Tucker got a good online discussion going as to whether his reaction was on of:
1. Your making that up didn't happen
2. I'll play dumb cause I don't remember
3. Dude, that wasn't my wife
4. Are you threatening me?
5. She was how old?

Just really bizarre stuff. See where it goes from here

On “Shooting at Boulder Grocery Store Leaves 10 Dead

The fact you think there is a curtain proves my point. If you actually leave this time, best of luck to you.

On “Ruling in Shawnee State “Preferred Pronouns” Case: Read It For Yourself

There was quite a bit of commentary back when this case was argued by folks listening to it (pandemic so it was streamed) about how poorly the counsel for Shawnee State was at the podium. Really bad, by all accounts from across the spectrum. The other item that was brought up in arguments was the student taking on the "I'll get you fired" which most legal folks felt was a not good look.

One other item to note here, this was a pre-emptive 1A filing from the professor.

On “Shooting at Boulder Grocery Store Leaves 10 Dead

I normally don't comment on such things but this is laughably ignorant. Not only do I rarely comment myself, since it isn't really fair for the person responsible for posting and promoting the content of the site to be doing so other than my personal opinions, I never "ghost" any comment from a regular commenter, whatever that is supposed to mean. We don't even have a mechanism to do so. If it's flagged it is for a reason, and almost all the flagged comments are still allowed. For example we have zero flagged comments right now as I write this. I can count on two hands the number of comments I've intervened on in the last 3 years and almost all of them was to discuss those comments with the other editors and leave to Will what to do about it. The one - ONE - case of me swinging the moderator hammer on someone in comments in the last three years was not involving you and was only with discussion with Will and unanimous approval of the editors.

Be mad elsewhere, your venting is misplaced here and makes you look silly.

On “Weekend Plans Post: Shaking My Head Like I’ve Napped Too Long

Folks don't understand the bulbous bow designs, it's like getting a fish hook out

On “Sunday Morning! “The Fugitive” by Marcel Proust

Thank you, occasionally I come up with good stuff

"

Point of order, The Fugitive film is a Tommy Lee Jones movie Harrison Ford happens to appear in.

On “Teaching 90s Kids Language Skills Via Mass Murder Through Advertising

It's amazing, I saw that commercial so many times, and they had that in the libraries of the schools I went too as well. And never noticed any of that. Funny how things work out.

On “USPS Inspector General’s Report on 2020 Election: Read It For Yourself

Part of the Union contract was what I was told when I inquired, but couldn't verify or get a consistent answer on it.

"

I fixed the blockquote for you

"

If you wish to write a point-by-point rebuttal you are welcome to write it up and submit it

On “The Trial of Derek Chauvin In The Death of George Floyd Begins

The morning started out with the state asking for a delay to jury selection to re-admit the 3rd degree murder charge, which the judge denied. That publicity stunt of bumping the initial charges to 2nd degree murder sure feels like the moment that doomed this prosecution. There is still apparently a chance they get the lesser charges in on jury instructions but it was such a bad look for what is going to be a complicated explainer of a prosecution. I'm with you, I hope I'm proven wrong, but unless they get get a lesser charge Chauvin is probably going to get off here. And God help the streets if he does.

The commenter archive features may be temporarily disabled at times.