10 thoughts on “23andMe Cashes In on Customer’s Data

  1. Will this drug actually be useful to help people or will it merely make money?

    Because if all it does is make money, we should probably get the government involved.Report

        1. I will admit that this goes against my Libertopian nature, but, for lack of a better word, it feels wrong. I know that the expression “the large print giveth, and the small print taketh away” is based in a reality that is served by lawyers, but at some point, we need to get away from that.Report

          1. Last week, I only lived in a world with 23&Me. This week, I live in a world with 23&Me and an additional inflammatory disease treatment.

            I guess I kinda understand why some people might be upset (“Hey! I deserve a piece of the profits for that medicine!”) but I’m not understanding the general sentiment that this is something that we want less of in the future.

            I would like 23&Me to come up with a couple dozen more medicines and I’m not sure why we’d want to nip those medicines in the bud.Report

  2. It is ironic that we now live with cameras and recording devices in every home that can be activated without our knowledge, and a national database of DNA available to the police, and it just seems so normal.Report

  3. At first I was gonna post “this is sort of like the copyright/IP debate” and then I realized that no, it isn’t sort-of-like, it’s exactly the copyright/IP debate, because what is more fundamentally your own property than your actual DNA?

    And, y’know, yeah, there’s nothing in the TOS that says they wouldn’t not avoid doing something that wasn’t not this thing that they didn’t not refuse to do. That doesn’t mean people were informed that their DNA sequences might (and would) be exploited to generate revenue for third parties.

    On the gripping hand, tho, remember how there was that art show where the guy just took Flickr posts and printed them out and sold them for $100,000 because it was “a famous artist” doing it? a-ha, Richard Prince. Writing on the wall, as it were. You control nothing that you do not hold in your hand.Report

Comments are closed.