Thursday Throughput: Big Whomping Space Explosion Edition

Michael Siegel

Michael Siegel is an astronomer living in Pennsylvania. He blogs at his own site, and has written a novel.

Related Post Roulette

16 Responses

  1. Jaybird says:

    ThTh7: Does this demonstrate that aliens have not surpassed 1970’s dentistry?Report

  2. Kazzy says:

    “In fact, it was so bright, we didn’t think it was a GRB at first. It turned out, it exploded while Swift was on the other side of the Earth. What we initially detected was the leftover explosion almost an hour after it went off.”

    I realize this will ring pedantic though I’m genuinely trying to understand how all this works when we’re talking about such massive distances.

    As this thing was 2B light years away, realistically this explosion happened 2B+ years ago, correct? And we’re just now seeing the effects of it now that the light has had time enough to travel into our observable range? So Swift wasn’t merely on the other side of the Earth… Swift didn’t even exist nor did humans or most of life on Earth when this thing ACTUALLY went off, right? But in the 2B+ years since that happened, everything happened here and we ended up in position to capture the 2B+ year-old evidence of the explosion?

    OR did this actually JUST happen and we have the technology to see things happening that far away in some degree of “real time”?

    Or is that all sort of one-and-the-same for space guys? Like do they talk about things in real time in terms of what we observe and just know in the back of their minds they’re really talking about past events?Report

    • Michael Siegel in reply to Kazzy says:

      It happened 2 billion years ago. But we talk about it in real time as the photons reach the Earth.Report

      • Kazzy in reply to Michael Siegel says:

        Thank you! Sorry, I realize that is probably a dumb question but it always confuses me.Report

        • Michael Siegel in reply to Kazzy says:

          Not a dumb question at all.Report

        • Jaybird in reply to Kazzy says:

          Imagine that you are sitting on one of the planets around Proxima Centauri.

          You have an *AMAZING* satellite dish. Or, really, a legion of satellite dishes that mimic being a really, really big satellite dish that allows you to pick up on earth’s radio signals.

          You might be tempted to say something like “Oooh, Russia just knocked out Spain from the World Cup!”

          Sure, that happened in July 2018. But you’re watching this on your space television and, in the bottom corner of the screen, it says “LIVE”.

          You might be tempted to wander into your space kitchen and get a space beer out of the space fridge and tell your space main squeeze “hey, Spain sucks now”.

          Even though, right now, that happened four years and three months ago and we’re a mere month away from the 2022 World Cup.Report

  3. Michael Cain says:

    ThTh8: Kaiser’s research on their large patient base says an annual stool test is as good as an every-five-years colonoscopy if you have no prior personal or family history of colon cancer. I return the sample promptly when they send me the test kit each year.Report

  4. Michael Cain says:

    ThTh6: There has been a flood of announcements on battery tech this year. Some of the solid electrolyte work has received major private sector funding for scaling up commercial production. Silicon oxide anodes. Sodium ion tech. Aluminum-sulfur chemistries that don’t have sufficient capacity per weight for EVs, but are enormously cheaper than li-ion for grid storage. California has reached about 6% of their peaking power coming from battery storage instead of natural gas.Report

  5. Chip Daniels says:

    ThTh3:
    This exemplifies how there is and never will be any environmental problem which can be attributable solely to climate change.

    But instead, climate change acts as a general accellerant to make all environmental problems worse.Report

    • James K in reply to Chip Daniels says:

      Yeah, people want to assign single causes to a given event, but natural systems are simply too complicated for that to work. Strictly speaking, climate change doesn’t make anything happen, but it contribute to almost everything.Report

  6. Saul Degraw says:

    There have also been years when Dungeness Crab season was eliminated or cut short because of environmental issues. In this case, toxis making them inedible to humans: https://www.sfchronicle.com/food/article/Dungeness-crab-season-nears-in-California-but-13327955.phpReport