Ahmaud Arbery Preliminary Hearing: “He ran until he couldn’t run anymore”
However bad you think that video was, the facts coming out of the preliminary hearing for the McMichaels, who are charged with killing Ahmaud Arbery, are worse. Namely, we know now that by the time the now-infamous video of the slaying started, Arbery had already been hit by a truck and shot in the chest.
William Bryan told investigators he heard Travis McMichael use a racial epithet after fatally shooting Ahmaud Arbery in Glynn County, a Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent testified Thursday during preliminary hearings.
Bryan told police McMichael said “f***ing n***er” after three blasts from McMichael’s shotgun left Arbery dead in the streets of the Satilla Shores neighborhood in February, Assistant Special Agent in Charge Richard Dial said. Body camera footage also showed a Confederate flag sticker on the toolbox of McMichael’s truck, he said.
On cross-examination, Dial testified that Bryan mentioned the slur in a May 13 GBI interview, and to Dial’s knowledge, Bryan had not previously made the allegation, including during a May 11 interview.
However, the agent said, there were “numerous times” on social media and via messaging services that McMichael used the same slur, once messaging someone that he loved his job because there “weren’t any N-words anywhere.
In another instance sometime before the shooting, he replied in an Instagram message saying things would be better if someone had “blown that N-word’s head off,” Dial testified. Dial did not say to whom McMichael was referring. Dial was not asked for more context.
The allegations came as Dial outlined events that led to Arbery’s death and said that before Arbery was shot, the three men charged in his murder engaged in an elaborate chase, hitting the 25-year-old jogger with a truck as he tried to escape them.
Asked if he believed McMichael could’ve been acting in self-defense, Dial said the opposite was true.
“I believe Mr. Arbery was being pursued, and he ran till he couldn’t run anymore, and it was turn his back to a man with a shotgun or fight with his bare hands against the man with the shotgun. He chose to fight,” he said. “I believe Mr. Arbery’s decision was to just try to get away, and when he felt like he could not escape he chose to fight.”
As Travis and his father Gregory McMichael attempted to head him off, Arbery turned and ran past the truck of Bryan, who filmed the killing, and Bryan struck Arbery with the side of his truck, Dial said.
Bryan told police that at one point he thought Arbery was trying to enter his truck, Dial said, adding that he didn’t know if that was true but he felt Arbery was trying to escape.
I don’t use this word lightly–pretty sure I’ve never had to use it in writing before–but let’s call this by the name that it is:
This was a lynching.
You can watch the testimony quoted above here at the 3:19:00 mark, how this was not only not self- defense by the McMichaels, but was self-defense by Arbery after being hunted down.
Give the McMichaels, Bryant, and whoever else is involved the fair trial they are entitled to. But may they get justice, swiftly, for what they did to Ahmaud Arbery: denying him the basic rights of not being hunted down, struck by a truck, shot in the chest, and then killed when he had the gall to try and defend himself. They killed him because, in the words of Bryant, they “felt Arbery was trying to escape.” They murdered a black man for not doing what they told him to do, because they assumed he had done something wrong, then stood over his body uttering slurs while Arbery left this life in a pool of his own blood, all because of the McMichaels’ feelings, assumptions, and prejudices.
That’s a lynching. No other word for it.
There is a lot of wicked in the authorities in Brunswick who tried to sweep all this under the rug, excuse it, and justify it. Every single one of them should be brought up on charges as well. The McMichaels and Bryant will stand trial first, but it shouldn’t end there.
To hell with all of them. But since that isn’t in our purview to designate as punishment, because unlike the McMichaels we realize we are not God, we are left to trust the justice system to make this right.
Not sure there is such a thing in this case.
God have mercy on us all for that.
My hair is standing on end. My jaw is dropping. This is in reaction to how flagrant and egregious this was.
God have mercy on us, indeed. I saw a quote today of the nature of how God bestows wisdom on us even though we are unwilling and the process is painful. I’m afraid I can’t recreate it, but it seems apt to the moment. If not having the pain means not getting the wisdom, maybe I prefer the pain. But not for Ahmaud Arbery. For me.Report
Yeah. This wasn’t a close call for the DA. This was red hot screaming for prosecution of deliberate murder. And “somehow” they let these mf’ers off. At least until the video.Report
Welcome to the South.Report
I found the quote. It is from Aeschylus:
Report
Thank FSM the video surfaced. Whoever leaked it deserves a damn medal.
And for everyone who tried to bury this, at the very LEAST they deserve to be removed from any public office and banned from ever holding such a position of public trust again.Report
Oddly, the video was dropped by an attorney friend the men, because he thought it would exonerate them. He assumed when people saw Aubrey turn and try to defend himself, everyone would see what they did: a dangerous animal needing to be put down.Report
My guess: he was playing for a Stand Your Ground defense.Report
Now we know not only was he cornered, but struck by a vehicle, shot, then when he tried to fight they shot him twice more, after pursing him for an extended period of time.Report
Wait, seriously?
Well metaphysical entities work in mysterious ways, I guess.Report
Surely there has to be *some* law on the books by which the prosecutors, police chiefs, cops who actively tried to suppress all this evidence can be charged with conspiracy to *get away with murder* no? I mean, surely…Report
“QI, man. Sometimes you make mistakes.”
“But these guys weren’t cops.”
“Arbery didn’t know that!”Report
“Prosecutorial discretion.”Report
Ever since the awful business of John Yoo’s torture memo, I have held that rule of law is not the supreme power – politics is. If we want rule of law, we have to organize our political existence to get it. We have to make elections turn on rule of law, and not just on whether we like the outcomes, or the parties favored by questionable legal proceedings.
This is really, really hard to do.
Before we started sheltering in place, we visited a deli regularly that would show episodes of Gunsmoke on their TV. Matt Dillon is a major champion of rule of law. There’s nothing like that in media today. Cops are dark and edgy and always “doing whatever it takes to catch the bad guys”.
I’m not happy, Bob. Not. Happy.
In short, we can’t look to the law to fix broken law. We have to look to politics. We have to build up institutions. We have to build up habits.Report
And people actually can’t understand the protests.
Or demand we return to “law and order.”
And claim lynchings never occur.
And call protesters terrorists but these men very fine people.
I hate to say it but Steve Bannon may well have been right – periodically America may need to be lit afire and burned to the ground to be saved.
God help us all.Report
I am seeing this as more like the late 60’s where TV footage of police brutality brought home for a lot of white middle class Americans the reality of life which up till that point had only been witnessed by minorities.
Now there are countless hours of videos being circulated of cops committing brutality and overreaction against peaceful protesters, or even just pointless acts of cruelty for its own sake like smashing supplies of water and milk intended for protesters.
I have to believe that the public opinion of the police is changing from one of blind support to skepticism.
In the aftermath of this, there is going to be a rash of lawsuits against various police departments. I’m growing hopeful that juries are going to be a lot less willing to dismiss them than before.Report