The End of the Future Tense
Tomorrow, we will be taking our elder dog Lisby to the vet. We won’t be bringing her home. This has been coming for a while now. She’s roughly eighteen and we’ve had her longer than we ever could have hoped. You get a six year old dog you don’t expect to have them for twelve years. It’s been a long, slow, steady decline. There was a turning point when we got back from a trip visiting family and her deterioration was dramatic. It is not unusual for it to take a few days to reorient after we get her back but this was different. After about a week we made an appointment. After that she actually started improving so the euthanasia visit became a consultation. They ran some tests. The results indicated that her time with us was likely to be short, and her quality time with us was likely to be even shorter. We left the office knowing that we would be back in a couple of weeks.
I could go on and on about what a wonderful dog she was – and she was – but everybody has those stories. So many dogs are all wonderful in so many ways. As it was with her.
As I said, we’ve been navigating this decline for a while. We got our second dog Murray in 2017 believing that there was a good chance we wouldn’t have Lisby for another year and wanting there to be overlap. We had hoped that our next dog would learn good behavior from Lisby, but that part of the plan kind of backfired. It was about then that Lisby started losing control of her once hurculean bladder and that made it harder not easier to housetrain Murray. Then Murray would go in the house and it became a vicious cycle. This actually continued until Lisby reached a tipping point where she would go openly. Interestingly, Murray seeing that and seeing our reaction to that helped him turn a corner. But anyway, addressing urine mess (and more) took up an increasing amount of my mental bandwidth as time progressed.
Once it became clear that, after various false alarms and periods of uncertainty, we really weren’t going to have her much longer, it actually became easier. I hadn’t really thought about it, but a lot of what I had been doing with Lisby was at once trying to deal with the issues reactively and pro-actively. The former consisted mostly of cleaning it up when it happened (or interrupting her if I caught her in the middle of it) while the latter revolved around trying to get her to stop doing it. Clancy and I were a bit at odds with our approach and this stymied our efforts, but we tried various things from puppy pads to different taking-out routines. We’d have success and failure in waves. It seemed to depend mostly on her situational awareness which was slipping along with everything else.
There were other things I had been persisting in trying to get her to either change or not change and some of the same patterns developed there. I had been trying to encourage her to get herself down and back up the stairs rather than carry her, for example. Some of my reasoning here was misguided, some valid. But after visiting the vet last month, it became clear that the best thing to do is what is best for in the moment. The idea of trying to get certain behavior out of her was ultimately counterproductive. She had long hated being picked up but over the last six months or so was making peace with it. A lot of what I had been trying to do, from helping her maintain her independence to monitoring her progress on what she can and can’t do, had lost its meaning.
it gradually sunk in that there was no future to plan for. No future to manage. At this point it really was just about making her life as comfortable as it could be for as long as we had her.
This also made easier some of the inconveniences I was putting up with. When she wakes me up at four in the morning because she needs to go out, it’s a different experience doing that when the end is in sight. Sure, Lisby, whatever you want. Let’s go. I just started keeping some mud slippers by the door. If she poops in the bed, I will just change the sheets. Then I will change the sheets again if she does it again the next night. We have more sheets than we have nights left with her. These are calculations that never occurred to me that they would ever occur to me.
Not long after we first got her, when we were living out west, she escaped out of the yard. I remember how frantic with worry I was as I was driving around looking for her. The idea of losing this wonderful new dog we’d just gotten horrified me on so many levels.
In the summer of 2015, she got sicker than we’d ever seen. This was right at the time we lost Marvin – literally the day we got the news about Marvin I made the vet appointment – and I remember thinking how I couldn’t bear to lose Lisby too.
A few years ago, I let her out in the rain and she darted away into it like nothing I’d seen in a very long time. I hadn’t worried that much in a long time because by then there had been enough deterioration that I wasn’t 100% she could find her way back. That was already a point where I thought the end might be in sight, but in addition to worrying about her being out there I was simply not ready to let her go.
For a couple years there, when she was lying there peacefully, I’d worry that she had stopped breathing. About six months ago, it ceased to be a heart-stopping fear and more just a check. A switch had turned in my mind that if she was ready to go, she was ready to go. I never reached the point that I was hoping she’d be gone but I would find myself thinking that if she was it was then everybody was fortunate that it was quietly in her sleep.
Instead, tomorrow we will go as a family and do this the hard way. There is nothing left to plan for and no future to consider. It will be the last thing we can do for her.
That really sucks. It always is awful to say goodbye to an old friend.
It was a good run, though.Report
Oh, man.
The second picture is really adorable. He looks like he’s smiling for the camera.Report
Good luck. There is no good way to do it. I’m really lucky that all of my pets have left me very abruptly. It’s always been a grim trip to the vet with a very good idea of what was coming but never days and days to ruminate on the inevitable. I count it as a blessing. Well wishes to your family and to Lisby.Report
I found th is somewhere on the web. If you’ve even a semblance of a heart, you’ll cry your eyes out, but it is “on point”.
The BEST BOY
(Original by reddit user Euthenios)
The last thing I remember is My Person bringing my to the Sharp Place.
I never understood why My Person would bring me to the Sharp Place. The smells were sharp, and they poked me with sharp things. That’s why I called it the Sharp Place. It was a bad place. I didn’t like it.
I don’t know why My Person brought me there, that day of all days. I already hadn’t been feeling good. I’d been throwing up, and my hips hurt and my paws hurt. Even eating grass didn’t help. And then My Person brought me to the Sharp Place. I tried to be mad at him, but he seemed so sad about something, so I tried to wag my tail to cheer him up. I didn’t even really notice when the Sharp Man poked me.
Then my eyes got heavy and that was the last thing I remember.
**Buddy,** a voice said. **Buddy, wake up.**
I opened my eyes and got to my feet, and I realized my paws didn’t hurt anymore. I tried a wag, and that was fine, too. I sniffed the air. It smelled like the Play Park and like Our Home and the Car Window. I liked it a lot.
**Welcome, Buddy,** came the voice again, from behind me.
I turned around, and there was a person there. He wasn’t My Person, but he was all safe and good smells, so I trusted him.
*Where am I?* I said.
**You’re in the place that Good Boys go,** the person said.
*I was a Good Boy?* I said.
**You were a Very Good Boy,** he told me.
That was good. I always tried to be a Good Boy. *Where’s My Person?* I asked.
**He’s still down there,** the person said. And he waved his arm and all of a sudden we were in Our Home, and My Person was sitting on the Forbidden Chair and looking sad. Every so often, he’d look over at the Okay Couch, where I was allowed so sit, and his breath would catch because he was very sad. I tried to nuzzle him, but my nose just passed through his hand.
*What’s happening? I don’t understand,* I said.
The person sighed. **You can’t be with him right now, Buddy. I’m sorry. It’s the way of things.**
I thought about this. *So it’s like My Person is on the Person Bed, and I’m not allowed there?* I said.
**Exactly like that,** the person said. **But he can be with you someday. If you choose to wait for him.**
*Of course I want to wait for him!* I said. Not wait for My Person? Who did this person think he was talking to?
**Hold on, Buddy,** the person said. He seemed sad about this for some reason. **It’s not that simple. You have a choice.** He got down on one knee and he looked into my eyes. **There are bad things in this world, Buddy. Very bad things.**
*Like Neighbor Cat?*
**So much worse than her, Buddy.** He waved his hand, and I saw what he was talking about. He showed me dark things, that were like snakes and rats, only worse. Worse than the Sucking Machine. Worse than the Sharp Place. They smelled evil.
**These are the things that want to hurt him, Buddy. They want to hurt everybody. So you can wait for him, or you can keep him safe. But if you choose to keep him safe, then you can’t see him again.**
*What, never?* I said.
The person nodded. **Never, Buddy. I’m sorry. Those are the Rules. It’s a terrible choice.**
I looked at my paws. I didn’t want to not see My Person ever again. But I wanted to keep him safe even more.
*I know what I have to do,* I said, and the person waved his hand, and all of a sudden we were in a place with there were as many dogs as I have every seen before. More, even.
**These are all the Good Boys who chose to keep Their People safe,** the person said.
I looked at them all. I couldn’t believe it, still. *But there’s so many of us!* I said. *How many Good Boys are here?*
The person looked down at me. He smiled, but I could tell he was also partly very sad. **All of you, Buddy. Every single one.**
(And now, the rest of the story… by ProfessorMatt)
I battled evil for many years, never sleeping.
I watched over My Person day and night, learning more and more about his life. I finally saw where My Person went, all those times he left forever for the day. I learned so much about the ways of dogs and men, and I always kept him safe from harm.
I even made my peace with The Sucking Machine.
My Person brought new dogs, new people into his life. When My Person first brought home a new dog, I was jealous. *Interloper!* I barked, so loud that the new dog heard me, faintly. My Person did not, but went over to calm the New Puppy. He called the New Puppy by my name, but with a “II” at the end. This made me realize that My Person still missed and loved me.
He found a woman, and they had a child, and then another, and lived together for a long time.
When “II” eventually went to The Sharp Place, he made the Good Boy choice and joined me in keeping Our Family safe. He was a Good Boy, too.
So was the next one. And the next.
Always Our Pack of Good Boys (and eventually Girls) was vigilant. Always we were learning. Always we were keeping Our People safe.
And Our Pack grew, year by year, decade by decade.
We served without sleep, keeping the human members of our Pack safe from evil, even as My Person became old and tired, his pelt gray, surrounded by his pack of people as it grew in number.
He didn’t know we were there, but we knew, and we loved and protected him.
Finally came the day that Our Person went to the Human Sharp Place. He was in pain, but soon it would be over. His bed was surrounded by friends and family, and The Pack of Eight- all of the Good Boys and Girls he had known and loved over the years.
No evil would dare come to this place today.
I was closest to him, as befit my position as his First Good Boy. He held out his hand, and I tried to muzzle it, as though I was looking for a treat. I know that he did not know that I was there, but he smiled, and then he went away.
And so did we.
We found ourselves back in the First Place After, with the person standing there, ever kind. Standing next to him was… My Person!
**I’m so sorry I had to trick you, but you did not know then what you know now. You would have grown to resent the years waiting without seeing your Person. You would think he had abandoned you. And your Person needed your guidance and protection, for the rest of his life.**
He smiled.
**Besides, I knew you were all Good Boys and Girls. Now, you may all go with your Person, to what lies Next.**
And the Pack of Eight and One… of Nine… went away, barking and laughing.
Until I felt a hand hold my collar. It was strange. I was somehow watching myself run off into the distance with the rest of my Pack, but staying behind.
The Man looked down at me and smiled.
**You… you are The Best Boy. No more choices. You get everything… and then some. A part of you will go on with your Person; while you, you who have learned so much and worked so hard…**
And I found myself looking into a bright light, surrounded by loving faces, hearing the doctor say, “It’s a boy!”
The Best Boy…
And as the memories of my previous life ebbed away, my last thought before beginning my new life was that one day soon I would find my own Good Boy to love.Report
The poet said it best:
We’ve sorrow enough in the natural way,
When it comes to burying Christian clay.
Our loves are not given, but only lent,
At compound interest of cent per cent.
Though it is not always the case, I believe,
That the longer we’ve kept ’em, the more do we grieve:
For, when debts are payable, right or wrong,
A short-time loan is as bad as a long—
So why in—Heaven (before we are there)
Should we give our hearts to a dog to tear?
But despite his warning the Husbando and I adopted a puppy last week. He’s a happy healthy shepherd mix and I look at him with affection but no small trepidation. I am sorry for your pain Will, it’s payment due for all the joy your pup has brought. Blake is going after my avocado plant again and gives me this idiot grin when I scold him. In time, I know I’ll be where you are but God(ess?) let it be far far away.Report
I’m very sorry to hear this.Report
Anyone who says “they’re just pets” has no fishing clue. They are family – albeit short lived family with way more fur.
May her memory be of a blessing.Report
Condolences, Will. This is never easy.Report
I’m sorry for your loss. It’s so painful to read this. My dog died 5 months ago and I didn’t feel it then but this brings it back.Report
Glad you got all that time.Report
I’m so sorry. We’ve had to do this twice, with Buster and then Zoe. It hurt. Our current dog, Bella, looks a lot like Lisby, but, with any luck, we will have her for another decade, by which time any new, young dog we get will probably outlive me.Report
Very sad, Will. All the best to the Trumans.
It’s really kind of amazing how quickly the decline comes once Death decides to start making his way to you. I noticed the same progression you describe here with my wife. Excluding the 10 days she spent unconscious, it was about 4 weeks from entirely coherent to barely about to eke out a word.Report
So sorry, Will. It’s a hard thing.Report
I’m so sorry for your loss. Thinking of you all.Report
Condolences to you and your family. ❤️Report