The long-running debate on information security and data privacy has only intensified with the current need of public health officials to conduct “contact tracing” of potential Coronavirus patients.
Germany is backing away from a centralized digital contact tracing program it had been considering to combat the coronavirus, saying the effort will only work if people trust that their privacy is being respected.
German officials had planned to collect data from users’ cellphones and store the data in a central repository. That approach would give health officials greater access to information that could help slow the spread of the coronavirus. But it troubled privacy advocates, who worry about a slippery slope if the government has access to so much personal information about citizens’ interactions.
Over the weekend, governmental ministers reversed course, saying the country would move to a decentralized approach.
“This app should be voluntary, meet data protection standards and guarantee a high level of IT security,” Chancellery Minister Helge Braun and Health Minister Jens Spahn said in a statement, according to Reuters. “The main epidemiological goal is to recognize and break chains of infection as soon as possible.”
Contact tracing works by identifying anyone that an infected individual has come into contact with, and then notifying people who might have been exposed. Apple and Google announced earlier this month they are creating a tracing system that uses cellphones’ ability to detect nearby phones via Bluetooth.
Apple and Google are taking what is known as a decentralized approach, in which all the potentially identifying information is stored locally, on users’ phones.
The centralized system originally preferred by German officials would have required Apple to change the settings on its phones to allow for the collection of information. Reuters, citing a “senior government source,” says Germany backtracked after Apple refused to make that change.
I get that apps and other technology can help with this effort. and i understand the desire to be seen to be doing something. But this approach is way more intrusive and likely to lead to the violation of important rights then, ya know, hiring actual people to do the work (especially with so many unemployed in the US right now). I can see having a voluntary app or an opt in add on to individual cell phone plans, but it needs to be something the use can fully control. I carry a work cell phone and a personal cell phone for precisely this reason.Report
Contract tracing is probably the best tool we have for “reopening” the economy. The problem is that most Westerners have been primed to see it as an invasion of civil liberties. Probably with excellent justification but there are no easy solutions.Report
The People talking to other people version is the easiest solution. Yes there are some civil liberties issues potentially associated with it, but person to person contact tracing is a lot more like the census and a lot less like a manhunt.Report
Combating pandemics and other natural disasters challenges everybody’s ideological priors.Report