1 thought on “Conclave Results in First American Pope

  1. As I mentioned in another comment, there’s something spring-like about the sede vacante – conclave – loggia event. A period of renewal and hope. Before the dog days of summer.

    This is, in some ways, the high-point of the Leo XIV papacy where we all project our hopes for the entire church on a single man. Before he has made a single decision or issued his first decree. We all imagine what his priorities must be, until they are actually revealed.

    There’s the funny Italian saying that a skinny Pope follows a fat one; I think many assume this means ‘ideology’ but I don’t think so. Not entirely. There are real ‘ideological constraints’ that come from simply being part of the Church; we agree on more than we disagree; and folks imagining some wild careening into their faddish ideologies will be disappointed.

    However, in one sense, I do suspect we’re seeing a skinny Pope after Francis’ fat Pope (or is it the other way around?). I won’t pretend to know this new Pope’s priorities and plans for his papacy; but I think we can infer that he’s more of a ‘clean-up in aisle four’ after Francis’ ‘make a mess’ papacy. A canon lawyer who is reputed to be a careful and fair executor of his charge. In this area, I think we can say that the Cardinals thought a correction was needed.

    As to the ‘hot button’ issues people want to pigeon hole him into? I’ll repeat that I’m honestly unsure where he intends to lead; I’d be lying if I didn’t have trepidation about the Cardinals who seem most invested in his investiture… but the amazing thing about the Papacy is that he really doesn’t owe his ‘faction’ anything any more. That we’ve seen over and again. The Cardinal who emerges Pope owes nothing to the Popes who emerged as Cardinals.

    He chose as his name Leo XIV. Most assume he’s echoing Leo XIII (hopefully not Leo V) and that’s an interesting choice as Leo XIII is something of a Trad/Orthodox favorite. He revived Thomism as the ‘official’ theology of the seminaries, issued Rerum Novarum on the right relationship between Capital and Labor (vs. Pre-Revolutionary Marxism), and condemned Americanism (both more and less what you might assume Americanism means in this context). How Leo XIV will reimagine Leo XIII (or Leo IX [Gregorian Reform] or maybe Leo X [The Indulgences Pope]) remains to be seen.

    My projection, my hope is that he *is* a continuity Pope… continuity with Leo XIII more than Francis; more careful, more thoughtful, less petty, and less autocratic than the previous – skinny to his fat and fat to his skinny. Viva il Papa.Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *