Ohisashiburi Desu Ne!

Christopher Carr

Christopher Carr does stuff and writes about stuff.

Related Post Roulette

7 Responses

  1. InMD
    Ignored
    says:

    I ended up watching 3 body problem all the way through and would rate it a bit higher. However I can see why you left it at the point you did. The 2nd half of the first episode and the entire second episode I found to be the least compelling parts. I nearly walked away from it myself, but persevered and ended up finding it more interesting than I had thought. There is an Irish actor Liam Cunningham whose character gets more involved deeper into the season and who I think steals the show.

    I want to watch the Shogun series very badly but don’t seem to have time. I read the book a very long time ago and remember liking it a lot, even with the intimidating length. This seems superficial but part of my concern is also that the guy they cast as Blackthorne looks so far from how I imagined the character that I’m not sure I could get over it. It doesn’t help that my main recollection of that actor is as a somewhat sleazy stable hand in the movie Lady MacBeth (also a good movie, but not a helpful performance for someone aspiring to be the hero in an epic sized drama).Report

  2. Jaybird
    Ignored
    says:

    Dude! Welcome back!

    I haven’t gone back to The Sopranos but someone on the twitters also went back and mentioned something to the effect of “I forgot how funny this show was”. I’m going back and re-thinking about it and I don’t remember it being particularly funny. There were particularly funny moments… Paulie Walnuts, mostly… but funny-in-general?

    I *ADORE* Fallout… And, by that, I mean the games. One of the things I’ve heard about the show is that they completely mess with the continuity of the games. Shady Sands? Nuked. Mister House? He *WANTED* the war. He loves money! What? That goes completely against what he was doing! I have a friend who isn’t someone who played (and beat) all of the Fallout games. He’s watching the show. He likes it. I’m glad that he does.

    As for 3 Body Problem, Maribou and I are watching it and I’m percolating an essay. I’m told that the Amazon Prime series keeps the insane stuff that the books do without dumbing it down at the cost of heavily downplaying the Cultural Revolution stuff. Netflix plays up the Cultural Revolution stuff… but at the cost of writing the science stuff for what it thinks Americans are. Alas.

    Good to see you! (And I agree about Facebook. I use it to write my uncle in Florida and I scroll through it and like the pictures of my various cousins’ kids and consistently find myself sidetracked by a 5-minute crafts video where a person takes a Sawzall to the feet of a clawfoot bathtub or someone melting brass and pouring it into a kinetic sand mold. How is it so hypnotizing? Wait. I came here to tell my uncle about the cats…)Report

  3. Andrew Donaldson
    Ignored
    says:

    Great having you back writingReport

  4. Saul Degraw
    Ignored
    says:

    I like The Three Body Problem but I never read the books. Someone did snark that the Netflix Invasion was Alien Invasion 90210 and I thought the line was funny.Report

  5. North
    Ignored
    says:

    Chris! So good to see writing from you!!

    Agree on Facebook. The absolute stream of advertisement monetized crap is agonizing. It’s the only way to keep track of the peeps back in Canada but if I didn’t have that one element I would boot it and never look back. Just awful. I don’t hate it like I hate twitter/X but I greatly dislike it.

    I’ve been meaning to see Civil War but ehh… probably will catch it on TV.

    Husbando and I have watched Shogun and enormously enjoyed it. As gay men we thought several of the characters including the English lead were cute as heck which surely helped but we were utterly immersed in the series. I partially credit this to my not having read any of the original base novels.

    Fallout: I was so enormously obsessed with Fallout 1 and 2 but then boycotted new Vegas and 3 due to the end of turn based combat. Base construction lured me back into 4 which I enjoyed massively (and don’t get me started on how much of a hoot Far Harbour was to a Maritimer) but I wisely avoided the disaster of Vault 72. So far we’ve greatly enjoyed the show- possibly because we went in fearing so much worse. I think your criticisms have bite when considered on a wide scale of shows but when considered on a scale of video game adaptations Fallout is, so far, near or at the very top of that more rarified niche.

    Three-body problem: My problem for this was I’d skimmed the books and was, thus, both spoiled and soured on the underlying story. I’m watching my husband watch it with interest.Report

  6. LeeEsq
    Ignored
    says:

    On the other blog we had a robust discussion of the book Shogun a couple of weeks ago. The debate is on where James Clavell, who I always thought was an American until literally this year, would sit in the modern genre cannon. My basic argument was that authors like Clavell, Michener, Howard Fast, Leon Uris, and company were high grade pulp fiction writers. A lot of the stuff was really low brow but because the writing was fancier and the plots more complicated than typical low-brow fiction it was hard to place. There isn’t really a modern equivalent because they weren’t genre works as we understand them today.Report

    • InMD in reply to LeeEsq
      Ignored
      says:

      I think they’re just historical fiction. I read both Shogun and Gai-Jin. Seemed not that different from a lot of British authors in the genre. I used to also read a lot of Bernard Cornwell, though Clavell always felt a little more sophisticated.Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *