This week, you get a twin spin: I look at science in the movie Alien and its sequel Aliens. Is the xenomorph possible? Do reactors really explode like that? And what does this all have to do with the Spanish Armada? Join me for a double-dose of sci-fi awesomeness!
Michael Siegel
Michael Siegel is an astronomer living in Pennsylvania. He blogs at his own site, and has written a novel.
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
on I Told You SoI think the problem is the original post -- it seems to be aimed at a very small number of people, n…
on I Told You So"continue to blame the Muslims in Michigan..." dude, he isn't *blaming* them. on I Told You So"Like, with Captain Hindsight parked firmly next to me I ask myself “Would Klobuchar or Pete truly h… on Open Mic for the week of 11/25/2024" the farm owners want to pay wages that are less than an American would take for doing that kind of… on I Told You So"You’re familiar with the old saw from the War on Terror days, right?" mehhh, bro, that was a long t…
on I Told You SoYou're familiar with the old saw from the War on Terror days, right? "A Muslim extremist wants to ki… on I Told You SoMy original thesis is at the very root comment. We've got a bunch of Conservative Types who are comp…
on I Told You So*sigh* You are all over the place, Jaybird. You utterly fail to actually state your thesis so no one… on I Told You SoIn any case, I was under the impression that if Trump was, in fact, Hitlerian, that it would put obl… on I Told You SoIt's weird looking back at the year, huh? There were a handful of people who said "if Biden is the c…
Movie of a Man Awakened at Night
November 26, 2024
It’s Going to be a Hard Winter
November 25, 2024
Hunting the Wild Goose – It’s a Funny Game
November 24, 2024
November 23, 2024
on I Told You So on I Told You So on I Told You So on I Told You So on I Told You So on I Told You So on I Told You So
on Open Mic for the week of 11/25/2024 on I Told You So
on I Told You So
on I Told You So on I Told You So
on I Told You So on I Told You So
on I Told You So
Four stars. Highest rating. Great review(s). A couple of comments:
I did a bunch of re-writes for one of the producers of both films (I’m going to be shy about naming names) who spoke over lunch about originally wanting Richard Dreyfuss for the role of Ripley. Love me some Dreyfuss, but I’m very glad Weaver got the part.
My only objection to the masterful story-telling in “Aliens” is over a brief bit where most folks would probably disagree with me, but here goes: When Ripley is facing off with the Queen Mother, Ripley threatens the eggs with her flame-thrower and a tacit agreement is made. The Mother calls off her minions and Ripley doesn’t fry the eggs. Then Ripley fries the eggs anyway. I certainly understand why she does that. She’s had a rough time with those pesky xenos, but a) I honestly think that Ripley wouldn’t go back on her “word,” and b) particularly when she knows the reactor is going to blow in minutes anyway. Not a huge gripe, but I would rather the Queen had broken the agreement instead of Ripley.
Agains, thanks for a terrific run-down.Report
It’s funny I always read that moment not as an agreement but as a sort of ‘sizing each other up’ before a fight to the death between members of two species that can’t coexist. Ripley’s character is based around being clear-eyed about that where others in the movies aren’t. Did think it was kind of a waste of time when the whole place is about to blow up though.Report
It read that as the queen breaking the agreement first because one of the eggs opens, threatening to send a facehugger at Ripley.Report
I better watch it again (no problem there). Egg opening? Very immediate danger. Nuclear holocaust no guarantee of safety (weird sentence to type). Time for the flames!
Damn, that’s a fine movie.Report
I enjoyed this very much Michael, as Alien and Aliens are two of my favorite movies. Obviously there are plenty of liberties but I’ve always thought the less fantastical sensibility (at least for a movie involving alien monsters and deep space travel) put the first 3 in a different class.
And yes, I said the first 3. I hate what they did as much as anyone in the third but for all they got wrong with the story and the demise of great characters, including Ripley, at least it still feels like an Alien movie, visionary up and coming director adding his mark and all. While not rehabilitating it exactly I think it has also been helped by the fundamentally userious Resurrection and the AvP movies plus Ridley Scott coming back to pointlessly cheapen it all for no reason with the insufferable Prometheus films.Report
Agreed that this is one of the best Throughputs yet made. Packed with science, oozing with love for the movies, and demonstrating that paying attention to what’s real is helpful to storytelling.
Also, “warp and weft” is a great phrase that I haven’t used in a long time but may well have cause to use in a trial I have coming up in about two weeks. Thanks for the reminder of this terrific metaphor.Report