Spain Debates UBI-type Program Amid Covid-19
In a country facing “the worst economic crisis since the end of the Spanish Civil War in 1939,” the ruling socialist government is turning to a basic income system to mitigate the economic crisis.
The coronavirus crisis has accelerated the debate in Spain over the introduction of a basic income, since state-funded social aid does not yet exist. It wasn’t until the death of the dictator Franco in 1975 that a welfare state developed here, though it was rather week. Families with children receive hardly any support.
The introduction of a basic income was therefore the main election promise of the leftist Podemos party and they made the program part of their coalition agreement with the Socialists last fall. Now the Sánchez government is rushing to get the project off the ground to prevent hundreds of thousands of people from plunging into the abyss.
“It is a historic moment for our democracy,” said Podemos leader and Deputy Prime Minister Pablo Iglesias, “the birth of a new social law.”
Spain, after all, still hasn’t fully recovered from the consequences of the financial and economic crisis of 2008. Even before the outbreak of the virus, the poverty rate hovered around 20 percent and the labor market is divided, with too few people enjoying permanent contracts with unemployment benefits, and too many having to make do with temporary contracts that often only last for a few days. According to statistics from the Spanish employment agency SEPE, 8.4 million people are now looking for a job.Thus far, only regional governments have allocated aid money — paltry sums that reached only 75,000 people, or barely a third of all the poor, according to social researcher Flores. Basic income would provide financial security for the most vulnerable 850,000 households.
But an “ingreso mínimo vital,” literally a “minimum income to live,” comes with strings attached. The program would only apply to people between the ages of 23 and 65 and they must have been registered as living in Spain for at least one year without interruption. They must also be actively looking for a steady job, be involved in a continuing education program or, in cases of drug dependency, be enrolled in a therapy program. The social welfare office would look into applicants’ assets and existing income and that would be topped up to a level of 462 euros per month for singles and up to 1,015 euros per month for a family of five.
So, there is hope for a better world after fascism?Report
probably – though Spain’s shift the last 20 years to mostly autonomous regional governance has not been devoid of problems. Frankly I still expect the Basques and Catalans to break away fully in the next decade or so.Report
I wonder if Spain has a housing crisis like we do?Report
I thought “that’s an interesting question…”
I mean, remember when we were all worried about the EU and specifically the PIIGS? Apparently, they had one back in 2008 (well, who didn’t?) and it was the usual bubble thing. Housing prices were going Up, Up, Up and that meant that it not only was a good idea to get a house RIGHT NOW but, if you already had a house, get a second one and rent it out because housing prices were going Up, Up, Up!
Anyway, it popped.
The housing crisis in Spain now, finally, shows signs of being over. Wait, you ask. What kind of crisis are they talking about?
Well, the crisis of people’s houses not being worth as much as they used to be.
What kind of crisis are you talking about?Report
Not enough supply to meet demand like we have here?
My one hesitation regarding a UBI is that if there is not enough housing, rents will rise to consume the UBI.Report
so housing in Spain is a different beast. In cities like Seville and Madrid there is a lot of densified housing – akin to American style coop buildings and condos. Cities have sprawled out, and do include single family residential developments that Americans would recognize, but its not yet on the scale we might see in say Denver. Most of the inner city is old (like hundreds of years old) residential and small scale mixed retail, and not subject to redevelopment.
The countryside is a real mix of traditional family owned villas and compounds and new development, but not in a planned sense. so the issues are not so much on supply and demand.Report
There are two crises.
On the one side, you have homeowners who view their houses like an investment and housing prices staying stagnant (OR GOING DOWN!!!!) means that their investment is losing money!
On the other side, you have people who want to buy a house. They don’t want to live in a dang apartment anymore or a dinky condo. They want to buy a *HOUSE*. And a housing market that keeps going up in value is a housing market that prices out new people who want to buy houses.
You gotta walk a tightrope between these two and figure out which side you want to fall over into because fall you will.Report
that’s the American approach. Spaniards are not really that way.Report
NIMBY-driven housing inflation seems to be a problem in many different countries. Not only is this not a uniquely American problem, but I don’t think it’s even especially bad in the US.
I would be surprised if there were any country where homeowners aren’t at least a bit unhappy at the devaluation of an asset that constitutes more than 100% of their net worth.Report
That’s the kicker though, innit? The thing DavidTC is always going on about, how people the value of housing to always appreciate, and by quite a lot.
You can do nothing to your home except the bare minimum maintenance to keep it habitable and if the value doesn’t rise faster than inflation, everyone will panic.Report
Note that the requirement to be seeking work or in training makes this more like an expanded unemployment program than an actual basic income.Report
However you gotta sell it…Report