State of the Discussion

The posts in play...

A Dark Age
(35)
+
Open Mic for the week of 3/17/25
(238)
+
On Jethro Tull
(14)
+
The JFK Files Drop Today (Supposedly)
(31)
+
Spaghetti on the Wall: Autopens and Out to Lunch Presidents
(24)
+
 

The comments...

LeeESq in reply to InMD
+ I agree with the business stuff but not necessarily the pro-life stuff. The social reactionaries are definitely getting more bold with different policy preferences they [. . .]
InMD in reply to Chris
+ Heh in fairness to my wonderful professor the course was Medieval Europe. UMD's history department had plenty of courses on the Islamic world. [. . .]
LeeEsq in reply to Jaybird
+ Just because the global right only agrees on no "Open Borders" doesn't mean that they aren't communicating or cooperating with each other. I'd also argue [. . .]
LeeEsq in reply to Marchmaine

I'd start the early modern period at sometime in the early to mid-17th century and end it around the American/French Revolutions.

+ Also, at least after it became the center of the Muslim World before 1000 CE, the Middle East, trade with which made the Vikings and [. . .]
Jaybird in reply to InMD
+ I don't even think that arguing "hey, we need one billion immigrants" is necessarily a *BAD* play. "The Haitians are making Ohio better. Here's the [. . .]
InMD in reply to Jaybird
+ I don't want to do too much projecting of intelligence but it seems to me that the GOP's slight edge comes from apparent willingness to [. . .]
+ There are many problems with using the Dark Ages as an analogy, not the least of which is that the Dark Ages, to the extent [. . .]
CJColucci in reply to Philip H

Well, yes. But it works. And that's good enough for far too many people.

Marchmaine in reply to InMD

This is Ravenna and Belasarius erasure!

InMD in reply to Marchmaine
+ My recollection of the survey is that we talked 'fall' of Rome as prologue, spent 5 minutes on Byzantium and Clovis, then Einhard acting as [. . .]

Yeah, maybe that play will work. "Open borders?" you can ask with wide eyes. "But nobody is even pushing for those!"

Dark Matter in reply to LeeEsq
+ Far as I can tell, the cease fire technically ended a while ago. Ergo Hamas has stopped handing back hostages and Israel and Hamas [. . .]
Marchmaine in reply to InMD
+ My personal pet peeve was 'Early Modern' starting in 1500 and going to 1800. Felt like it was leading the witness. 410 to 793 is [. . .]
InMD in reply to Philip H
+ There are official policies and de facto policies. Chances are way lower that Trump is president if from the beginning Biden had approached the [. . .]

It’s dishonest to demand that people abandon policies they aren’t advocating for.

+ The only thing that the global right seems to agree upon is that "Open Borders" is not a good policy. Yeah, yeah. "Nobody is arguing for [. . .]
InMD in reply to LeeEsq
+ When I was getting my history BA the distinction they made was low medieval (approximately 410-1066 i.e. Alaric to William) versus high medieval (approximately 1066-1400). [. . .]
LeeEsq
+ Netanyahu apparently decided to launch a surprise attack on Gaza for no good reason with Trump's backing. We are in a world ruled by mad [. . .]
LeeEsq
+ The basic problem is that the global right is cooperating internationally in ways that that global left is not. This is both at the formal [. . .]
LeeEsq
+ I think most historians disagree with the idea of the dark ages and even the dark ages were seen as a thing, they were assumed [. . .]
Jaybird in reply to Anne
+ Tull has come out with three albums in the last three years!!! The Zealot Gene in 2022, RökFlöte in 2023, and Curious Ruminant came out TWO [. . .]
Anne
+ love me some Tull. Ian did an album with London Symphony Orchestra called A Classic Case pretty awesome. on a side not I just got [. . .]
Jaybird in reply to InMD
+ If we could allow for "conspiracy theories" to also cover stuff like "the authorities covering stuff up, obfuscating the truth, and opposing the story of [. . .]
InMD in reply to Jaybird
+ The occam's razor of conspiracy theories is not to attribute to intentional malfeasance emerging from smoke filled rooms that which is adequately explained by incompetence [. . .]
+ Everybody always thinks that their pet conspiracies are like MKULTRA or Operation Mockingbird but most of them are like the conspiracy theory that says that [. . .]
+ A couple of weeks ago, I wrote an article for the New Zealand Skeptics society where I argued that the Kennedy assassination conspiracies, along with [. . .]
+ Email it to me and I'll submit it under guest posts. If you don't want to do it that way, email Andrew Donaldson and he'll do [. . .]
DavidTC in reply to Jaybird

You know what? Fine. I just wrote something. How do I get it in here? I assume I have to make an account?

LeeEsq in reply to Saul Degraw

White supremacists are going to white supremacists.

+ One of Leonard Cohen's last poems was titled "What is Coming". what is coming ten million people in the street cannot stop what is coming the American Armed Forces cannot control the [. . .]
Marchmaine in reply to InMD

In my forties: Expensive restaurants are playing my Jams!

I sent a link to this essay to my EMF. I did not bother sending one to my JMF.

Saul Degraw
+ Bending the knee: https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/breaking-doge-strong-armed-usip-security-contractors-to-switch-sides Yesterday I noted that when DOGE showed up on Monday at the USIP offices, they came with what appeared to be private [. . .]
Saul Degraw
+ Germany revised its website on travel to the U.S. in light of recent detentions of German Citizens with valid visas. ComicCon is advising people not [. . .]
Saul Degraw

The DOD apparently removed info on Jackie Robinson from its website. A completely bonkers explanation as to why:

https://www.reddit.com/r/army/comments/1jf6zpp/pentagon_press_secretary_john_ullyot_said_the/

InMD in reply to Jaybird
+ Isn't there a meme about this? In my teens: The radio is playing my jams! In my twenties: The bar is playing my jams! In my thirties*: The [. . .]
+ Yeah, my moment for that was "Love Will Tear Us Apart" in the cookie aisle. "Why are they playing Joy Division?", I asked. Then I got [. . .]
CJColucci

Really don't mind if I sit this one out.

+ A few years ago, as I was walking through the produce section of the local Kroger chain store, they started Locomotive Breath. Played [. . .]

Ironically enough, today marks the 54th Anniversary of the release of Aqualung.

March 19th, 1971.

Slade the Leveller in reply to CJColucci

Those club championships aren't going to win themselves, buster.

Man, no wonder they wanted to keep this under wraps!

CJColucci in reply to Jaybird

Imagine having a President who would care about this information, read the document, and think about such things.

J_A in reply to Brandon Berg
+ As a general-ish thing, a lot of “conservatives” believe in some sort of “married women are not separate entities from their husbands; the married couple [. . .]

Ask the republicans who keep passing these bills. I agree it makes little sense but here we are.

 

This feature may come and go. You can also access comment history in the Commentareum.