Commenter Archive

Comments by Philip H

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/28/2025

The DNC needs to get over itself. The JD Pritzkers of the world don’t actually need them to get elected and he’s about the most senior person agewiae the DNC should support. If all the DNC does is keep sclerotic geriatric has been a in office nothing g will change and we will have witnessed a total collapse into authoritarian rule in a year. If they want to be a functional opposition Hogg is showing them the way.

On “Gender Critical: Legally Defining Sex

Biological context? Transphobe much?

"

Equally not-shockingly all the hullabaloo about protecting women’s spaces heaps insults on women AND defies statistical analysis. It’s also ONLY about trans women - trans men are apparently not a threat.

Guess you can’t have a Strict Father hierarchical society without cementing who gets to be a father and thus in control.

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/28/2025

So apparently Amazon - like a lot of businesses - is going to add a line to its billing about how much the total price of an item has increased due to the tariffs. The White House responded about as well as you’d expect, calling it a political move by Amazon.

We really are in a post-truth world I guess.

"

And they will celebrate as the “pain” necessary to defeat China or some such claptrap. The suffering of Americans will be morphed into a grand cause.

Classic fascist playbook stuff.

"

Good teachers - left to their own to use the skills they sought to become teachers - generally know who needs help and who doesn’t. They also know which way their students learn and which way is best to test their knowledge. There is no one size fits all test. Never will be never has been. Measuring educational success based on a single annual or every other year or every three year test only works if everyone learns and tests the same way.

It’s a red herring.

"

That we let teachers teach. Pay them well. Give students the additional support. Stop trying to meet production quotas and quantitative rubrics.

"

Yes I am. Because in many cases it’s not a failure to learn to read or comprehend - it’s a failure to regurgitate on specific tests in a specific way. Which then gets neglected as the child ages and becomes a barrier to future successful learning.

"

One of the “keys to success” is holding back kids in third grade who aren’t judged “ready” to take the four grade tests this “improvement” is based on. So only the kids who are going to do well get promoted. Call me nuts - I know a lot of folks here do - but all that means is you are willing to game the system not actually teach your kids

"

There is no bench depth in the red states and that’s where a lot of the senate elections next year are. Mississippi’s democrats will likely run the same black guy who got 42% against Wicker last year. And while he’s a solid moderate Democrat he’s goi g to need 9% more white people to get elected against Hyde-Smith.

Not happening.

On “Gender Critical: Legally Defining Sex

This is your money quote:

It will be something fascists will keep in their back pocket to use randomly against anyone that disagrees with the administration, same as revoking a visa. The best situations is where they can punish, at their own whim, literally any person they want.

Though the Whose Line reference is also well played.

As much as I despise this attempt at social control, why always stickers with me is how much these folks feel they have to twist words to hide intent. It’s like they know they are morally repugnant and don’t want to own that.

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/28/2025

Mississippi is playing statistical gamesz

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/21/2025

There’s supposedly been another arrest elsewhere.

"

What drives your inherent need to go find obscure stories no one else is talking about to feed your incessant “neither side has moral standing” argumentation?

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/14/2025

And therein is the fundamental difference between the left and the right. No leftist would ever declare due process as a thing that isn’t or shouldn’t be popular across the board, since due process affects everyone across the board.

"

This is indeed true in the south. Mostly because they believe privilege conveys freedom.

On “Back When Patriots Opposed Kings

Many of them are racists. And they are stepping up but the Lincoln Project running pithy ads won’t cut it.

"

The patriots are weary. We’d really like some of our right leaning colleagues to step up and save the republic.

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/21/2025

Not the same thing. If he’s doing this routinely he’s using the app so his communications aren’t captured and preserved. And for way more than this. It’s meant to prevent him or anyone else being held accountable by Congress and the courts.

"

SecDef is just following the P2025 playbook which directly calls for using apps like Signal to circumvent records retention laws. He’ll be fine.

On “SCOTUS Temporarily Halts Trump Administration Removal of Venezuelans

One has to wonder if Robert’s is regretting his blanket immunity ruling yet.

On “Open Mic for the Week of 4/14/2025

This should worry us way more then it does.

On “Pope Francis Dead at 88

He was nobody’s idea of a leftist; he was also not every Catholic’s idea of a Pope. He tried to call the wider church back to its foundations to minister at the margins, and to respect all the people the church encountered. In that his was a Christ centered papacy. I worry that his successor will walk the church away from those ministries.

May he rest in peace having been welcomed home as a good and faithful servant.

On “Throughput: Telling Women They’re Womening Wrong, But In Space

ThTh2 - you’ve seen the budget passback coverage for NOAA haven’t you?

The commenter archive features may be temporarily disabled at times.