Video Throughput: An Astronomer Reacts to Dune
I take off my critic hat and put on my scientist hat to see how the science of Dune holds up. And…it’s not too bad.
by Michael Siegel · November 18, 2021
I take off my critic hat and put on my scientist hat to see how the science of Dune holds up. And…it’s not too bad.
Michael Siegel
Michael Siegel is an astronomer living in Pennsylvania. He blogs at his own site, and has written a novel.
December 17, 2012
August 2, 2013
June 20, 2015
Devcat is watching over, but if you notice any problems contact the editors and Devcat will be notified and deployed immediately.
November 2, 2024
November 1, 2024
Danny Thinks Halloween a Fine Chance to be Funny
October 31, 2024
October 30, 2024
Another good episode.
Regarding the section on psychic powers… my (long ago) reading of that was less psychic than hyper genetic… the key (for me) was the ‘Mitochondrial Inheritance’ of the Bene Gesserit (literaly both ‘Do Gooders’ & ‘Good Bearers’) that enabled them to inherit the fullness of the previous lives via their genetic inheritance. It struck me as a balance between pure science and mystic discipline (powered by spice)… like a breakthrough that required proper breeding/genes to have access to the mystic discipline — which was then unlocked by a chemical, spice, via a mystic ritual that either granted access to the DNA memories or death. The absence of the Mystical Training/Discipline is the madness that overtakes Aliya. It’s all very rational; hyper rational; mystically rational.
[We can ignore, if we wish, Brian Herbert’s next evolutionary discovery regarding male orgasms… and insect like reflexes… but that’s part & parcel of their hyper genetic approach to mysticism.]
I like the pre-cognition comparing it to a hyper-mentat state… plausible… but oddly, here I’m not entirely sure how it reconciles with the Golden Path… the Path is Teleological, the computing the grains of sand is mathematical. I guess I just reduced the Teleology to preventing extinction… but that’s a pretty monstrous Teleology, all things considered.
Of course, the Teleology and Hyper-Genetics come together under Leto II rather spectacularly.Report
Good points!Report
I love this interpretation. I also quite enjoyed how Herberts children expanded his universe and at the same time rationalized many of the events as being, in a way, aberration caused by a historic schism (the human from AI schism caused by human cruelty and greed) and resolved by resolving that schism (rapprochement between human and artificial intelligence).Report
i very much enjoy these videos Michael!Report
An unfortunate choice of terminology: you said, more or less, ”Arrakis has no seasons because it is tilted 90°; Earth has seasons because it is tilted 23°.” That should be either 0° and 23° or 90° and 67°.Report