Andrew Cuomo Get Bad Covid Review From NY AG James
Andrew Cuomo may have a book titled American Crisis: Leadership Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic, but NY AG Letitia James has a bad review of said leadership, along with a 76-page report of receipts.
The New York State attorney general accused the Cuomo administration of undercounting coronavirus-related deaths at nursing homes by as much as 50 percent, according to a report released on Thursday.
The count of deaths in state nursing homes has been a source of controversy for Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and state Health Department officials, who have been sensitive to any suggestion that they played any role in the number of nursing home deaths, which the state put at more than 8,500.
They have also been accused of obscuring a more accurate estimate of nursing home deaths, because the state only counted deaths at the actual facilities, rather than including deaths of residents who were transferred to a hospital and died there.
In the 76-page report released by the attorney general, Letitia James, a survey of nursing homes found consistent discrepancies between deaths reported to the attorney general’s investigators and those officially released by the Health Department.
In one instance, an unnamed facility reported 11 confirmed and presumed deaths to the Health Department as happening on site through early August. The attorney general’s survey of that same facility, however, found 40 deaths, including 27 at the home and 13 in hospitals.
“Preliminary data obtained by O.A.G. suggests that many nursing home residents died from Covid-19 in hospitals after being transferred from their nursing homes, which is not reflected in D.O.H.’s published total nursing home death data,” a summary of the report’s findings reads.
The findings of Ms. James, a Democrat, could put her in direct conflict with Mr. Cuomo, the state’s three-term Democratic incumbent, who has touted his and his administration’s response to the coronavirus crisis, despite more than 42,000 deaths in the state.
Ms. James’s report also found a number of homes that “failed to comply with critical infection control policies,” including not isolating residents who had tested positive for the virus or screening employees for it.
The death toll in the state’s nursing homes has been a source of agony for residents and their families, and a political liability for Mr. Cuomo, who has pushed back on accusations that his administration did not do enough to safeguard a highly vulnerable population. In particular, Mr. Cuomo was criticized for a March 25 memo from the Health Department, which ordered nursing homes to accept patients who had tested positive.
ya know, if you read much right wing punditry you would never know this sort of thing happens between Democratic officials.Report
Your take on the story is that it’s an indictment of right-wing media? Really? You couldn’t have squeezed out an observation about how the left-wing media, which includes people like the governor’s brother the same media that touted his book about leadership, gave him an Emmy for press briefings, and ignored his anti-vax statements, might have missed a story?Report
Given that the story Andrew quotes in from the NYT, I doubt the MSM has missed much. And all those prior criticisms were also reported in the MSM as well prior to today.
That aside, I was making a pointedly snarky comment about how Republicans seem of late to be willing to heap mountains of criticism on democrats for not whipping each and every potentially wayward democrat on any issue Republicans think they don’t like – while a President and 147 congress members who aided and abetted a literal attack on the U.S. Capitol should all be allowed to move on.
I had hoped I didn’t need to actually lead any of my fellow interlocuters here through that explicitly since everyone comes off as really intelligent here.Report
Well, at least one of the “right wing punditry” I read periodically, posted about this. But the guy is a Jew, and he thinks Cuomo was even worse, given his treatment of the Orthodox Jews in NYC. His headline was:
“now that trump is no longer in office Cuomo gets thrown under the bus”.
I’d agree too.Report
Good. If he screwed up then give him hell.Report
As a quasi-New Yorker (live in NJ in the shadow of the city, work in Manhattan), there was a range of responses to his handling of Covid. There were definitely folks in the media calling him out for the March 25th policy and the manipulation of numbers. There were also those fawning over him, but that tended to be more the people on the ground. “Cuomo Crushes” were indeed a thing. Cuomo clashed with DeBlasio, who most NYC-ers have turned on, so many folks sided with Cuomo.
I’m glad to see this report come out. Because despite folks documenting and criticizing Cuomo for a disastrous policy and deceptive reporting*, he was largely able to avoid any accountability and was still largely fawned over, as evidenced by his book. It is hard to guage the totality of his impact and whether it was positive or negative, but where he was wrong, he was really, really wrong. And that shouldn’t be brushed aside for any reason.
* To the best of my knowledge, the decision to record those deaths as non-nursing home deaths didn’t change the overall death toll, but simply shifted them from one bucket to another. Which I assume was largely a CYA move by him once he realized that his policy was leading to dead bodies. So he was underreporting one number and overreporting another number. Not inconsequential but also not the “HE’S HIDING BODIES!” that some critics alleged.Report
He was an alternative to Trump.
Pick A or B. A is Trump, B is Cuomo.
Oh, you’re criticizing Cuomo? WHY DO YOU LOVE TRUMP JUST PUT ON THE RED HAT ALREADY
And then you get crap like this:
Lemme read the headline of the page as it appears at this moment on CNN:
“Andrew Cuomo’s Covid-19 performance may have been less stellar than it seemed”Report
I understand that government reports take time. It makes sense to me. The person who’s already inclined to mistrust looks at the timing of this kind of report and figures it was being suppressed. I have no reason to believe it was, so I assume it wasn’t. The ongoing lack of critique of Cuomo and the constant criticism of DeSantis should be called out, though. A governor doesn’t determine how badly his state is hit by a virus, but having a third fewer deaths per million and an R after his name hasn’t done DeSantis any favors.Report
You keep talking about a lack of critique of Mr. Cuomo. I don’t think those words mean what you think they mean:
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/10/19/andrew-cuomo-the-king-of-new-york
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/08/cuomo-new-york-coronavirus/615352/
https://www.heritage.org/public-health/commentary/andrew-cuomo-had-the-worst-coronavirus-response-the-country-why-should
https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/21401242/andrew-cuomo-coronavirus-covid-pandemic-new-yorkReport
And it keeps getting worse…..
“Cuomo said ‘he can destroy me’: NY assemblyman alleges governor threatened him over nursing homes scandal”
https://edition.cnn.com/2021/02/17/politics/cuomo-ron-kim-nursing-home/index.html
Sounds like someone is in panic mode. I’m going to admit, I think Cuomo’s an ass, so I’m enjoying this.Report