Commenter Archive

Comments by LeeEsq in reply to Chris*

On “Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024

Netanyahu seems in danger again because of cover ups.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-media-organizations-request-removal-of-gag-order-on-pmo-security-affair/

"

Trump knows to fill his staff with loyalists this time.

"

There will be mandatory Tucker Carlson watching if Trump wins. He will be the anchor of the nation. The official dispenser of propaganda and public enlightenment.

"

So if Trump pulls out an electoral college win and governs as he said he would with revenge against his enemies and mass deportations, etc., what are you going to do? The amount of cognitive defenses that people are putting up is staggering.

We have lots of evidence from Trump's first administration, especially the last two years of it, that Trump is being literal and serious. Elon Musk is threatening to crash the economy and that is the least evil of Trump's plans. Yet, many people just refuse to take this seriously and go "oh Trump, you silly."

"

Trump calls for Liz Cheney to be executed in an interview with Tucker Carlson, the media has to sanewash it because reasons:

https://www.cnn.com/2024/11/01/politics/donald-trump-liz-cheney-war-hawk-battle/index.html

"

The Catholic Church apparently decided it needed an anime mascot for Japan. I'd really love to know what meetings led to this decision.

https://www.tokyoweekender.com/entertainment/anime-and-manga/the-vatican-unveils-its-anime-mascot-luce/

"

My guess that this seems to be the actions of a severely dumb activist as well.

"

Seeing how they deal with Happousai is going to be interesting.

"

The 2024 Ranma 1/2 anime attempts to deal with some of the more problematic aspects of the original series by saying that the series takes place in the 1980s and leaving the problematic elements, for both Japanese and Western audiences, in tact.

On “What If Kamala Wins?

There does seem to be an increased support among law and order policing in deep blue Democratic districts. More than a few recall for mayors and DAs deemed woke. One of the leading contenders for the Mayor's Office in SF is running on basically pro-broken windows policing.

"

Depends on whether the Democratic Party controls Congress or not. The worse thing that can happen is that the current policies continue.

On “The Way Through is Donald Trump for President

Do the Jewish people deserve freedom as Jews, Chris? Or is their big freaking exception to the principles of self-determination for Jews?

"

I've come to the opinion that the other Further Left basically finds the Jews do not fit into their cosmology and rather than re-examine their cosmology, they basically decide that all the principles they hold do not apply to the Jews. They basically seem to hold all three of these beliefs as once.

1. Jews do not have a right to self-determination as Jews because that involves disruptive settler-colonialism.

2. At the same time, the countries where Jews live are under no obligation to construct their identity to include Jews as Jews. If they do great but if they decide to exclude Jews or treat Jews as a side population, who cares?

3. Jews are not to be recognized as a unified people and given the rights given to other minority or oppressed groups because reasons. If we acknowledge the Jews as an oppressed group that valiantly worked to preserve their own culture and identity in the face of vast persecution than it is a grave insult to the groups we care about.

You can point out how all of this contradicts their beliefs till they are blue in the face but like the White Right or Islamic anti-Semites, the Left anti-Semites know that they out number Jews by considerable margins and will raise their fists in defiance forever because they can.

"

Chris, the Palestinians have this issue where they never exactly precisely define the type of freedom they want or what would be acceptable towards them. In fact, the only groups that give precise definitions are the groups that explicitly state "No Israel, No Jews" in one way or another. The alleged moderate Palestinians hem and haw around this but also kind of suggest they believe the same thing but are too intelligent to come out and say it.

On “Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024

Trying to grok where Jews are in the current political ideological cosmology is exceedingly difficult. On the one hand, we have a resurgent Right and a lot of White nationalists who most definitely believe that Jews aren't white and say so. On the other hand, Jews seem to be an awkward fit at best for the Intersectional Left or other other variants of the Left. As David Baddiel would put it, Jews do not fit into the "sacred circle of oppression" paradigm. We come across as too bougie and educated and most of them see us as mere wypipo with a different religion. You can explain Jewish history and identity to them very carefully and it is basically hitting a brick wall. They will just raise their first in defiance and say "Jews are wypipo, end of story." There is a feeling of political homelessness.

On “The Way Through is Donald Trump for President

I would have included a reference to Bunker Hill and Gettysburg but this is very good.

"

I just saw a Donald Trump ad that informed me that liberal border czar Kamala Harris has instituted on open border and bad hombres are coming from and that somehow this is paying for transgender surgeries. It is basically something that Julius Streicher would come up with. Anybody who thinks that putting Trump into office again needs some work done on themselves.

"

There are actually people who believe this and they say so out loud. It is the entire settler-colonial argument from the Further Left. There are other people who believe in a softer version of this in that they believe Jews should remain but not have any real say in what Palestine should look like because they aren't real true Palestinians. Jews will be given the formalities of citizenship but not any power.

Like if you do google searching, you can find groups calling cities in Israel proper as illegal settlements. The destroy Israel and take away all the Jews belief is a lot more common than you think it is.

On “Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024

I was today years old when I learned that there is a historical fantasy streaming series/YA novel about Lady Jane Grey that ends more happily with her and replaces the entire Protestant-Catholic conflict with a conflict about shapeshifters, as an analogy to LGBT people more below, and humans. I can understand why this would be a lot more interesting to secular 21st century people but at the same time these sorts of presentism in historical dramas brings out my inner curmudgeon.

There is something about this sort of approach to historical drama that seems really self-indulgent. Like somebody saying "I don't want to deal with reality, I want my fantasy and not having to do any hard grappling with the facts." The fact that the shapeshifters are supposed to be an LGBT analog but the main male shapeshifter is the love interest of Lady Jane Grey shows the problems.

"

They are obeying in advance.

"

Trump is only up by 5 points in Kansas. He won it be 15 points in 2020.

https://kansasreflector.com/2024/10/28/survey-reveals-potential-tapering-of-kansas-gap-between-gop-democratic-presidential-candidates/

On “What If Trump Wins?

They aren't necessarily correct either.

"

I'm so old that I remember when the Further Left was against Kamala because she was cop and now she is a woke avatar or something.

"

There is a lot of misogyny and racism in the people that are discounting Harris from the Right and from the Left.

On “Open Mic for the week of 10/28/2024

Sometimes you find an article and realize that other people are having the same thoughts that you are. One of the things that I've noticed in the I/P debate is that a lot of anti-Israel Palestinians and other Muslims make the argument that their Jews were happy living as second class citizens under Islam until the Zionist agitators showed up and that these arguments sound like White Southerners arguing about how Blacks were happy under Jim Crow until outside (((agitators))) showed up. For some reason, you have a lot of well meaning people in the West that would call bloody murder when dealing with White Southerners talking about African-Americans but fall for the same illogical argument hook, line and sinker when Muslims take about "their Jews." This article says the same thing but more elaborately:

https://www.meforum.org/middle-east-quarterly/uncle-tom-and-the-happy-dhimmi

*Comment archive for non-registered commenters assembled by email address as provided.

The commenter archive features may be temporarily disabled at times.