From Washington Post: The Trump Lexicon
The Trump Administration has some verbiage that might have folks wondering if those words they keep using mean what they thought they mean.
A sampling from WaPo:
‘Transparency’
Traditionally, transparency in the federal government has meant access to data, federal contracts and government reports, even if they shed light on problems.But Trump has fired nearly a score of inspectors general, who root out fraud and malfeasance in federal agencies. (Eight have filed suit, saying they were fired illegally.) One IG, for the U.S. Agency for International Development, was booted as soon as he issued a critical report on the aid stoppage ordered by the president. When reports emerged that a State Department website revealed that Tesla, a company owned by billionaire Elon Musk, Trump’s biggest financial backer, received a $400 million contract, the contract document was scrubbed to remove any reference to Tesla. Moreover, websites across the government were deleted — including every page for USAID.
Meanwhile, the Musk-led U.S. DOGE Service — which is targeting agencies for contract terminations and personnel cuts — operates in secret and the people on his team have not been revealed, though reporters have figured out the identity of some key players.
But the White House says the administration is transparent because Trump often answers questions from reporters. (His predecessor, Joe Biden, rarely did so and usually in controlled settings.)
“President Trump has led by example on this front as the leader of the free world, the president of the United States, with his show of access and transparency on a daily basis,” Leavitt told reporters. “The president takes questions from all of you almost every single day and really reveals what he’s thinking and feeling.”
Unfortunately, as we’ve documented, much of what Trump says is inaccurate or misleading. So he’s not an especially accurate source, compared to rigorously vetted reports and databases.
‘Free Speech’
The First Amendment enshrines a right to “free speech” — the right to articulate opinions and ideas without interference, retaliation or punishment from the government. There’s always been some tension in this notion — does this give someone the right to yell “fire” in a crowded theater when there is no fire?Conservatives objected to social media platforms such as Twitter (before Musk bought it and turned it into X) and Facebook downgrading or removing posts that contained inaccurate or false information, especially during the covid pandemic. Trump himself was removed from many platforms after he instigated a riot at the U.S. Capitol to prevent the certification of Biden’s victory in 2020. But he’s been reinstated and many social media companies have scaled back efforts to police false information circulating on their platforms.
“I stopped government censorship once and for all and we brought back free speech to America,” Trump told House GOP members after taking office.
But the White House in recent days has barred Associated Press reporters from news events because the agency still refers to the Gulf of Mexico, the internationally recognized name for the body of water that has been in use since the mid-17th century. In an executive order, Trump directed federal agencies to change the name to “Gulf of America.” The AP is an international news organization, and the rest of the world does not recognize Trump’s name change. Taylor Budowich, White House deputy chief of staff, said in a statement that the AP’s stance “is not just divisive, but it also exposes the Associated Press’ commitment to misinformation.” He said that as a result of “irresponsible and dishonest reporting” — citing the name used by the rest of the world — the AP could not expect the “privilege of unfettered access to limited spaces, like the Oval Office and Air Force One.”
Similarly, Leavitt told reporters: “I was very up front in my briefing on Day 1, that if we feel that there are lies being pushed by outlets in this room, we are going to hold those lies accountable. And it is a fact that the body of water off the coast of Louisiana is called the Gulf of America, and I’m not sure why news outlets don’t want to call it that, but that is what it is.”
‘Fraud and abuse’
Fraud generally means deception, often criminal, in pursuit of financial and personal gain. But the Trump administration has upended that definition — broadening it to include programs and policies it disagrees with — while at the same time making it harder to detect fraud.“We’re finding tremendous fraud and tremendous abuse,” Trump said as Musk stood by his side in Oval Office. But a Fact Checker accounting of the announcements from DOGE, or Department of Government Efficiency, of terminated programs found that most concern diversity, transgender and climate change programs. Musk has also led an assault on USAID, the agency that long had bipartisan support to distribute billions of dollars in development aid around the world.
“It’s a scam,” Trump said of USAID. “It’s a fraud. A lot of it, most of it, but it’s a fraud.” Asked for evidence, the White House provided a list that was often wrong or misleading — and in any case amounted only to a pittance of the agency’s $25 billion budget.
In addition to firing IGs, Trump fired top ethics officers and neutered offices that protect workers from retribution. He also suspended enforcement of a nearly half-century-old law that investigates corporate corruption in foreign countries, while his Justice Department ordered the dismissal of bribery charges against New York Mayor Eric Adams (D) for political reasons (Adams supports Trump’s immigration policies).
A Feb. 13 White House news release berated states and localities pushing back against Trump’s executives orders on diversity and immigration. “President Donald J. Trump and his administration have a simple message: follow the law,” the news release was titled.
So the example of “Free Speech” is a press outlet not getting privileged access?
60 Minutes had a segment last night where the reporters were interviewing German politicians who were explaining that it was illegal to insult someone. Like, “go to jail” illegal.
I understand that ceasing to extend a privilege can have a chilling effect! I can!
It’s just been a wild ride these last few years and the AP having privileges revoked for failing to recognize and follow a new government policy on the new name of the Gulf of Mexico seems like a fairly straightforward interaction.
It’s not like there isn’t a list of thousands of news outlets that would beg, borrow, or steal for the position that the AP cheerfully gave up.Report
This may look like “whataboutism” so I will attempt to clarify.
I am crazy and have no problem with not voting for either of the two real parties due to stuff like failure to support free speech and, more importantly, the Enlightenment Ideals behind the idea of it.
But if we’re in a zero-sum game between Team Good and Team Evil and both Teams are doing a good job of not supporting free speech and, more importantly, the Enlightenment Ideals behind the idea of it, the choice becomes something much more like “which side do you want to see lose more?”
And it’s not about “Free Speech” at that point. It’s just about which side is doing a less perfect job of making a mockery of the idea of Free Speech.
And so you’re stuck with “here’s Team Evil doing something awful” versus “here’s Team Good doing something awful”.Report
I don’t think it’s whataboutism. I think that media outlets like WaPo have either decided not to, or their worldview simply precludes, the ability to interrogate the assertions of particular officials and institutions. This causes a lot of their criticism of Trump, much of which is warranted, to fall flat.Report
I have *ZERO* problems with the interrogation of officials! Seriously, I wish we had a *LOT* more.
But the failure of the AP to say “the Gulf of America (the gulf formerly known as the Gulf of Mexico)” or “the Gulf of America (née Mexico)” comes across as stupid petulance instead of smart petulance.
On top of that, the AP isn’t being punished (defined as “the stick”). It’s merely not being rewarded (defined as “the carrot”).
“When you’re accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression.”Report
Not just that, but they operate from a space of seemingly studied incuriosity about the status quo. For example, as I understand it, Musk and his dorks have been given control of US Data Services which was set up by the Obama admin to conduct audits and similar stuff not that far removed from the steel-manned version of what Trump (and Musk) say they want to do.
I am sure Musk and co. are making a total hash of this, operating in a manner of total incompetence and corruption. But it all begs questions like ‘what was US Data Services doing before January of 2025? Did they ever uncover waste or abuse? Is every penny the federal government is spending truly beyond reproach? What about the inspector generals? Do we know they were all doing a good job?’
The WaPo is fundamentally incapable of asking questions like that, everyone knows it, and the result isn’t even the view from nowhere, it’s the view from a presumption of authority no one actually recognizes.Report
I listen to an hour of the BBC every morning and, boy, you should hear how they grill public officials that come on their show. It makes me wonder what the heck is going on with our press.Report
Yea I think the US press is way too cozy with power.Report
Seems like we’ve reached the inevitable conclusion of ideological drift in our institutions. No one is around anymore with enough epistemic humility to even understand why we have (well, used to have) those rules for free speech, hearing from multiple sides, journalistic distance, etc – to the extent it’s happening at all, it seems to be mostly vestigial, and worse yet, all financial incentives seem to pointed away from that sort of thing (outside a small niche).Report
“President Donald J. Trump and his administration have a simple message: follow the law..”
That’s rich.Report
Bezos pulled ads against Elon Musk so this is really richReport