In a decision with potentially large ramifications, New York Federal Judge LaShann DeArcy Hall won't dismiss a libel suit against "Shitty Media Men" creator Moira Donegan.
Explaining, the judge says it is possible that Donegan created the entry herself. The judge believes that Elliott should be able to explore whether the entry was fabricated. Accordingly, discovery proceeds, which will now put pressure on Google to respond to broad subpoena demands. The next motion stage could feature a high-stakes one about the reaches of CDA 230.
Thursday Throughput: First Galaxies
[ThTh1] As we look deeper into the universe, we have to look with different eyes. The expansion of the universe means that the further something is away from us, the faster it is moving away from us and the redder its light gets. So as we look further and further into space and earlier and earlier in time, we have to look at redder and redder light. Eventually, the universe becomes invisible to us in the optical and we have to look in the infrared and the radio.
But something else happens as we look further and further back in time: the nature of the universe changes. The universe was born from the fiery chaos of the Big Bang. The universe now consists of massive galaxies mostly in dense clusters. But the time in between those eras is not very well known. We do know that, at some point, the first stars began to form. We know that, at some point, small galaxies formed. We know that, at some point, those galaxies merged into larger galaxies which merged into larger galaxies which merged into larger ones. But the details of how we went from the Big Bang to the modern universe is hidden from us. Those parts of the universe are so far away, we can only see them in the infrared and no infrared telescope has yet been big enough to glimpse that era.
The figure at the top of this post illustrates the concept. The Hubble Space Telescope gave us the universe out to about a billion years after the Big Bang, when the big galaxies had formed. Later instruments extended its view into infrared getting to about 400 million years after the Big Bang, when small galaxies were merging into big ones. The Radiation Era, the first 300,000 years of the Universe, we can see in the Cosmic Microwave Background. In between that is the unknown.
It is into that unknown that the James Webb Telescope will look.1 We will finally get to see how the universe went from the chaos of the Big Bang to the relative order of small galaxies. JWST has had long delays and it’s not clear when it will fly.
But this week, we got a hint of what it might see:
In our 13.8 billion-year-old universe, most galaxies like our Milky Way form gradually, reaching their large mass relatively late. But a new discovery made with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) of a massive rotating disk galaxy, seen when the universe was only ten percent of its current age, challenges the traditional models of galaxy formation. This research appears on 20 May 2020 in the journal Nature.
Galaxy DLA0817g, nicknamed the Wolfe Disk after the late astronomer Arthur M. Wolfe, is the most distant rotating disk galaxy ever observed. The unparalleled power of ALMA made it possible to see this galaxy spinning at 170 miles (272 kilometers) per second, similar to our Milky Way.
This kind of galaxy is unlikely to have existed only a billion years after the Big Bang. What galaxies we can see at that distance are a wreck of merging and colliding galaxies. Even a large galaxy should be more like a ball of light. It takes billions of years for a young energetic galaxy to settle down into the relatively ordered middle age that galaxies like the Milky Way are in.
What does it mean? It’s hard to tell. But we’re going to be looking for more of these. And when JWST goes up, we’ll get a much clearer idea of where it fits into our understanding.
[ThTh2] A good look at 50 things we’ve learned during the first phase of COVID-19. And here is a look at what activities are low-risk and what are high-risk. One surprise for me: short- to medium-haul airplane flights appear to be low risk.
[ThTh3] And sticking with COVID-19, did Florida fire someone to hire data? Here’s a deep dive into how information gets to the public.
[ThTH4] Can Mars be terraformed? (H/T: Will)
[ThTh5] 40 years ago, Mount St. Helen’s exploded. Here’s the log from an astronomer who was only 90 miles away. Click through for the thread and his excellent description of the sky conditions.
Exactly #40YearsAgo Doug Geisler was asleep atop Manastash Ridge Observatory. An astronomy grad student, he’d just logged his first excellent night at the telescope for his PhD thesis.
— Emily Levesque 🤓✨🔭📚 (@emsque) May 18, 2020
[ThTh6] Space X’s first crewed launch was postponed by weather. Hopefully, they’ll have better luck on Saturday.
[ThTh7] Comet Swan hasn’t been as spectacular as hoped, but it should be visible through binoculars after sunset.
[ThTh8] I had never heard of this before. Amazing.
This is Johannes Kepler in a letter he wrote in 1610 telling Galileo that they need to do more telescopic observations of the Moon and Jupiter before spacecraft missions start visiting those planets. Yep, this conversation actually happened…in 1610 🤯 pic.twitter.com/O8oeBXzG16
— Dr. Phil Metzger (@DrPhiltill) May 26, 2020