Scary Monsters, Super Creeps, Keep me Running

Like many of us, I prefer to start my day with a very low-level experience of panic. The morning news report, which I scan within twenty minutes of my alarm going off, doesn’t trigger a genuine fight-or-flight response, but it does stir up those tiny feelings of unease, worry, frustration, and discontent that I need to get going. While I make the pot of morning coffee that will give me another required jolt, I pour over the headlines in the Associated Press, Washington Post (a reminder of home), Le Monde, the Atlantic, and the New York Times for signs of trouble in my external environment, however tenuously they might be connected to my person, in order to prepare for the worst, however unlikely it might be to actually occur.

The prehistoric forebears of my species were probably more fortunate in having larger predators to wake them up, while I only have reports about scattered pockets of white supremacists in the Midwest, terrorist cells, “active shooters”, a dysfunctional government south of the border (and in Ontario), and looming environmental devastation to worry about, all of which remain, thankfully, as distant from my daily experience as the dragon in a medieval chanson de geste, although perhaps serving basically the same function. Nearly everyone notes that news reports tend towards the alarming and dispiriting, of course, but few acknowledge that an obvious explanation for this is simply audience demand. We want to know they worst and tend to overemphasize the importance of bad news, however minor it might be, and as a species we’re pretty lousy at assessing risk; so, as a result, we wish to keep abreast of panic-inducing “warning signs” of threats to our own safety, while recognizing that other people with different viewpoints tend to freak out over every damned thing.

It becomes even more complicated when you have friends of differing political viewpoints on social media because they will keep you informed of minor threats from alternate dialectical positions. A baker thousands of miles away refuses to bake a cake for a marrying gay couple, who then take the matter to court, and your right-leaning friends sound the alarm that the state may soon be outlawing acts of religious conscience, while your left-leaning friends warn that discrimination is possibly going to be enshrined once more in the law. The possibility that neither of these outcomes will come to pass doesn’t get much play, while both sides proclaim the unlikelihood of what it is their alternates are worried about.

To a certain extent, of course, political tribalism is all about the people with whom you seek shelter. And, from a practical standpoint, environmental devastation is probably the most pressing issue we face collectively; unless, of course, it turns out to be societal collapse. Which is to say: not all threats are equal. Nevertheless, we seem to have an intrinsic desire to keep vigilantly aware of everything that might pose a threat to us, something I suspect isn’t far removed from the taste that some people (myself included) have for horror movies. In a sense, too, I suspect we prepare ourselves for our own mortality through the mediated deaths of others. The irony, however, is that high levels of stress actually pose a greater threat to our health than most of the things we insist on keeping cognizant about.

I remember once reading during the Bush administration that an alarmingly high percentage of Americans did not know the name of the Vice President and thinking that they were troublingly uninformed. Yet I couldn’t help wondering: if I remained oblivious to the existence of Dick Cheney until the end of days, would my life be better or worse?


Associate Editor
Home Page 

Rufus is an American curmudgeon in Canada. He has a PhD in History, sings in a garage rock band, and does a bunch of other stuff.

Please do be so kind as to share this post.
Share

8 thoughts on “Scary Monsters, Super Creeps, Keep me Running

  1. Yet I couldn’t help wondering: if I remained oblivious to the existence of Dick Cheney until the end of days, would my life be better or worse?

    You come from a culture that says that more data is better, more information is better, and understanding things is one of the highest goods.

    Intelligence is seen as a moral trait and cleverness is seen as a reliable indicator of intelligence.

    You have been lied to. Interestingly, it’s in one of the most subtle ways of lying. It’s not that P is False therefore ~P must be True, it’s that P is a category mistake and so ~P will not bring you any closer to truth.

    It sucks.

    (For what it’s worth, I fell for that crap too.)

      Quote  Link

    Report

    • You come from a culture that says that more data is better, more information is better, and understanding things is one of the highest goods.

      Which is derived from a culture that has a creation myth that the original human condition was one of child like innocence. And knowing stuff is for fa…fallen people.

      You know what? That’s BS. Knowlege is good. It’s not a trick of the devil; it’s not the exclusive providence of a jealous G-d.

        Quote  Link

      Report

      • I don’t know what The Good is anymore.

        I’m wandering back toward something approaching “happiness” (or in the ballpark where other terms might be… stuff like “contentment” or “inner peace”).

        Accurately modelling reality has upsides, lemme tell ya, but I’m not certain that it’s in the same ballpark as The Good.

          Quote  Link

        Report

        • Watching “The Good Place” from Season One has messed me up more than it should. (And I still want to read Kant now, even though I suspect that will end in tears for me).

          What is a good life? What if you are doing “good” things but for the “wrong” reasons (I am eternally guilty of doing stuff that is arguably “good” because I want people to like or respect me).

          I don’t even know what “happiness” consists of any more. I used to think “working towards some goal and making progress” was it but the past few years have left me wondering if some of my “goals” aren’t just totally fished and….I don’t know what new goal to seek. “Not making things worse than they are” seems a hopelessly small goal but some days it seems all I can manage.

          Doing things to serve others – which I also used to think of as a source of happiness – at times leaves me overwhelmed and resentful because people can be such TAKERS.

          I suppose being nearly 50 has me worrying more about “What is the meaning of life and have I wasted mine?”

            Quote  Link

          Report

      • Surely, there has to be a happy medium between childlike innocence and my mother whose phone gets texts from Fox News so she won’t miss out on the latest outrage while eating dinner in a restaurant. I mean, yes, knowledge is good, but is it useful?

          Quote  Link

        Report

        • It’s also the case that for most of history Fox News text alerts might be classified more as “gossip” and less as “knowledge”. And certainly I’d say they are a lower class of knowledge than the knowledge she might gain from paying attention to her surroundings.

          The question of whether particular bits of information are knowledge, or aren’t knowledge, is a vexed one, as I’m sure you know. (and reference above.)

            Quote  Link

          Report

        • Just a couple of items before this one came up in my RSS reader, there was this one. It seems super relevant.

          A new information technology, the printing press, doesn’t just foster the Reformation and the Scientific Revolution. It also helps the witch craze go viral.

          Nevertheless, I think the printing press is a good thing. There’s far more enjoyment in my life because of it than there is misery. Even though it has added misery.

            Quote  Link

          Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *