Featured Post

Netflix Delivers – Altered Carbon Review

A brief review of Altered Carbon, Netflix’s new Sci-Fi series.

Netflix Delivers - Altered Carbon Review

I just finished Netflix’s Altered Carbon, and if you are a fan of Sci-Fi in the feel of Blade Runner, you’ll enjoy it.  No happy egalitarian Federation here.  If you like Noir detective stories, I dare say you can also find a great deal to enjoy here as well, as the mystery holds until the very end.  By episode 8, I thought I had the big reveal all figured out, and by the end of episode 8, I knew I was wrong.

I won’t go into the details of the show, as there are lots of sites discussing the setting.  What I will say is that it’s a slow burn, but has enough action, and the plot keeps moving enough that I didn’t get bored.  It is also absolutely unafraid to kill characters for real (not just a sleeve death – that makes sense if you read up on the setting) to move the story along.  I didn’t feel like any key death was gratuitous or unnecessary.  They all served the story in a way.  Almost everything served to move the plot along.  Every spot of violence or nudity had a purpose.  Even when I thought a spot of nudity was gratuitous, a few minutes later, it suddenly has a reason.  IMHO, it was all very tightly put together.

And the story is dark.  Very dark.  It is not at all shy about showing us the callousness and human depravity it means to expose.  And the characters are flawed, all of them.  There is no Paladin of perfect virtue and character here.  The closest there is is Ortega’s mom, and, well, no one’s mom is perfect, right?  But the characters, each of them, have some core principle that is, in it’s own way, good.  Love of family, a sense of duty, etc.  Even the antagonists have it, which grants them a degree of sympathy, but for various reasons, it’s twisted.  And they know it’s twisted, but it’s what they got, so they hold onto it even as the rest of their humanity falls away.

Also, the characters, despite being flawed, and dark, are not needlessly self destructive.  In the first episode, Kovacs goes on a bit of a bender because he figures he’s going back to prison in the morning, but once he’s committed to the job, things go back to moderation.  He doesn’t spend the next 9 episodes jonesing for a fix.  Everyone has their vices, but no one is living in their own filth because they can’t keep the vice under control.  I actually appreciate this, because I personally feel that writers use self-destructive behavior too often as a way to show a flawed character.  To me, it’s lazy to have a person be an addict, or some other clumsy method of self-immolation, unless it really serves the story.  Not everyone needs to find escape in the bottom of a bottle or the point of a needle (or what have you).

Also, there is no Deus Ex Machina.  Actually, there is, but the writers smartly commit an entire arc of the story to developing the Deus Ex, so when it is needed to pull people out of the fire, you aren’t going “WTF?”, but rather cheering that the most unlikely cavalry has arrived.

And that is my final note on the series.  Nothing comes out of the blue.  There are no clues that you need to be super attentive to get.  There are no surprises unless you were asleep during the show.  At only one point did I have to call up Wikipedia to refresh my memory on something that was mentioned in the first episode.  As I alluded to earlier, even when there is a surprise, it only takes a minute of retrospection to see that all the elements were there, they’ve just finally come together.  There was only one spot, where you were wondering what just happened, at the very end of one episode, and in the first few minutes of the next, it all makes sense and yes, all the necessary elements were there.  I am certain that there are clues in the show that, if you are very attentive, will reveal details to you earlier, but everything that is important is called out explicitly at some point along the way.  By the time you get to the big reveal at the end, only one or two details are still outstanding, and they wrap those up, and they fit, logically, with the story.

So, if you have 10 hours to kill in the near future, and I’ve piqued your interest, give the series a try.

Image by U.S. Army Materiel Command Netflix Delivers - Altered Carbon Review


Contributor

A Navy Turbine Tech who learned to spin wrenches on old cars, Oscar has since been trained as an Engineer & Software Developer & now writes tools for other engineers. When not in his shop or at work, he can be found spending time with his family, gardening, hiking, kayaking, gaming, or whatever strikes his fancy & fits in the budget. ...more →

Please do be so kind as to share this post.
Share

12 thoughts on “Netflix Delivers – Altered Carbon Review

      • I know I read some reviews after watching it and thought the same thing you did and then there were reviews that obviously had not watched the whole season and were complaining about the show not addressing issues that were addressed throughout the ENTIRE show!

          Quote  Link

        Report

        • I was kinda annoyed by how many reviewers obviously didn’t watch the whole show, or openly admit they didn’t, and yet still feel perfectly fine writing a review of it. This isn’t an open ended story like a normal TV show, it’s more like a long movie or mini-series. You kinda need to watch the whole thing, or don’t bother writing a review.

            Quote  Link

          Report

    • You are welcome.

      I read quite a few negative reviews, but they all struck me as the reviewer being upset that the series wasn’t what they wanted, (projecting their expectations onto the show) rather than taking it for what it was. I went into it with no such expectations and was glad I did.

        Quote  Link

      Report

  1. I cheated a bit. Using my Super Editor Powers, I’d noticed this post in the pipe recently and pre-read it. Based on what I read, I watched episode 1 last night.

    It’s amazing. Netflix has made some high quality stuff before but this blows it all away. I can’t wait to binge the rest of it out this weekend.

      Quote  Link

    Report

  2. I finished it last week and thoroughly enjoyed it. Every episode left me wanting more, which is a contrast to Netflix’s Marvel shows. To me, even the best of those are slow in the middle. I think they would absolutely benefit from 10 episode seasons like Altered Carbon instead of the 13 they have now.

      Quote  Link

    Report

  3. I think I’ve mentioned before that the Takeshi Kovacs trilogy is one of my favorite book series, so I was strongly ambivalent about this when it was announced. Mostly, though, I just wanted it to not suck, and it certainly didn’t suck. I found the dialogue a bit clunky, but Joel Kinnaman and Martha Higareda were both amazing as Kovacs and Ortega, so I got the main thing I wanted out of it. I don’t know how many people here have read the books but they’re fairly different from the show (and honestly much better). I don’t love all the changes they made from the books, but I understand why you have simplify things to make it a coherent show, so I try not to hold that stuff against the show itself. And they do pretty much tell the same basic plot from the first book, and tell it well, so overall I’m satisfied with the show even though it’s not as good as it could be.

      Quote  Link

    Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *