What does Trump’s dominance tell us about Massachusetts Republicans? – The Boston Globe

Avatar

Will Truman

Will Truman is the Editor-in-Chief of Ordinary Times. He is also on Twitter.

Related Post Roulette

23 Responses

  1. Avatar greginak says:

    It’s surprising Kasich isn’t doing better there, but its also clear he is cold toast. Rubio really fits the Mass R frame, Cruz is very much a nope. But the NE has a lot of very rough brash talking nativist peeps so it shouldn’t be a complete surprise.Report

  2. Avatar Koch Industries for Pres, 2016! says:

    “No True Moderate Republican”Report

  3. Avatar Christopher Carr says:

    Trump is the most moderate Republican in the field, hands down. He came out against the Iraq War early and doubled down two debates ago. During that same debate he praised planned parenthood.

    The other Republicans fall over themselves to represent their own (social) conservatism. That kind of nonsense doesn’t play well in Massachusetts.Report

  4. Avatar Saul Degraw says:

    Chris and Greg have it right. The Northeast likes brashness. People thought that Trump’s New Yawkerness would damn him. Turns out the Northeast is dominating this election. Trump in his own ways is moderate despite the tone. He doesn’t talk about privatizing Social Security or Medicare.Report

    • Avatar Brandon Berg in reply to Saul Degraw says:

      Sure, he wants to bar Muslims from the country and get Mexico to pay for a giant wall along the southern border, but he’s not advocating anything crazy, like letting people take the money they earned and save it for retirement.Report

      • Avatar Christopher Carr in reply to Brandon Berg says:

        For the record, I used the word “moderate”. I wasn’t talking about kindness or sanity. Trump support in Massachusetts makes sense because even the most extreme conservatives live in a state that is more or less a bastion of democratic socialism. Massachusetts has had universal health insurance coverage 4 years. It was the first state to legalize gay marriage. Those sorts of cultural beliefs are set. Any Republican candidate who’s going to stake his campaign on opposition to gay marriage or universal health insurance coverage is not going to win Massachusetts. On the other hand, Republican voters know the government gets in the way of successful businesses. This, first and foremost is what motivates their selection of candidates.

        Furthetmore, It may appear at first glance that something like baring Muslims from the country wouldn’t fly in state like Massachusetts. However, Massachusetts is a self-righteous State, and its solutions to problems historically have tended to be Swift, decisive, and authoritarian, with little regard for collateral damage. For instance, Massachusetts once decided to violently antagonize the British, and this ultimately led to the American Revolution. This tendency is also responsible for the way the Irish took over the city of politically. The fact that Massachusetts is better than all of your States in pretty much every metric is also due to a tendency to strong, pragmatic solutions that have little regard for whiners, people’s feelings, and anyone else. Massachusetts wins. Trump wins, like the Patriots. There’s no hesitation, there’s no weakness, there’s no vacillation, there’s no asking for permission. This is what a leader should be. You could, for instance , as a thought experiment, imagine who Bill the Butcher from Gangs of New York would support for President, and your answer would be Donald Trump.

        To illustrate this further, because it is a subtle point, when I ask my friends back home who they’re planning on voting for, I get answers such as: 1. Write-in illegal Obama 3rd term; 2. Bernie; 3. Trump; 4. I hate them all; 5. Vermin Supreme; … ; n. H-bomb. They hate that her wishy-washy values and methods are the antithesis to what is valued in Massachusetts. This is also why Kerry had lukewarm support his own state).

        And as for the Mexican wall, that’s pretty far down the list of problems for northeastern voters. But if it works, why not? You won’t catch any Massachusetts conservatives feeling bad for cheaters.

        Ted Cruz is the last person in the world that Massachusetts Republican voters would vote for. I imagine that if he went to Massachusetts he would get his ass kicked swiftly by drunken Red Sox hooligans.

        Some of my analysis here is generalizable to the northeast as a region, but some of it is unique to Massachusetts. New Hampshire as a state share similar values with Massachusetts conservatives. New Hampshire has no state tax, and its state motto is live free or die.

        Here, I definitely want to put a disclaimer that these are not my personal beliefs. But, I mean, of course the Northeast supports Trump.Report

      • Avatar greginak in reply to Brandon Berg says:

        It was tragic the day it became illegal to save money for retirement…..Weep for the days we could have 401k’s.

        Yeah i’m sure that is a rant about social security, but it does make more clear to me how Trump is winning.Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *