Mount Rushmore – 1980s Comedies Edition

Avatar

Mike Dwyer

Mike Dwyer is a former writer and contributor at Ordinary Times.

Related Post Roulette

116 Responses

  1. Avatar Hari
    Ignored
    says:

    Ghostbusters and Tootsie for sure. Bill Murray’s face belongs on Mount Rushmore.Report

  2. Avatar Doctor Jay
    Ignored
    says:

    I’m not certain as to the boundaries of your “pure comedy” category. But my list of “funniest movies from the 80’s” definitely includes Airplane. Mrs Jay and I still quote it to each other. But my heart (and the “most quoted by Doctor Jay” award) belongs to The Princess Bride.

    Also on the list are Ghostbusters, Good Morning, Vietnam, Back to the Future, Radio Days (Wallace Shawn rulez!) and Ferris Bueller’s Day OffReport

  3. Avatar Burt Likko
    Ignored
    says:

    Ferris Bueller, Ghostbusters, Airplane, and Vacation.

    But the funniest moments and best quotes come from Princess Bride and Bull Durham. Those are not “pure comedies” as I understand that term, although they are both laced all through with very funny moments.Report

  4. Avatar Pinky
    Ignored
    says:

    No, no, no, it’s got to be four! Those are the rules!

    Spinal Tap
    Ferris Beuller’s Day Off
    Planes, Trains, and Automobiles
    Beverly Hills Cop (I’m not sure if this one shows its age too much, though)Report

  5. Avatar Glyph
    Ignored
    says:

    As others have pointed out, Ghostbusters is a must. Either Porky’s or Pee-Wee must give way.Report

    • Avatar Pinky in reply to Glyph
      Ignored
      says:

      I was disappointed in Ghostbusters. I guess my expectations were too high after all the praise it had received. On the other hand, I had very low expectations for Ghostbusters 2, and found it funnier than the original.

      That said, I agree that if you’re making a Mount Rushmore of 1980’s comedies, Ghostbusters belongs there.Report

    • Avatar Mike Schilling in reply to Glyph
      Ignored
      says:

      I feel about Ghostbusters the same way I do about It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad World: great achievement in its chose field (big-budget special-effect-driven film, and extravaganza respectively), I just wish they were funnier.Report

      • Avatar Glyph in reply to Mike Schilling
        Ignored
        says:

        I’m not sure any film will ever top the sight gag of a marauding malevolent multi-story marshmallow.

        Seriously, the first time you see the movie and it dawns on the audience, as it’s dawning on the characters (Ray’s resigned “It’s…the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man”; “Ray’s gone bye-bye”; “I’m terrified beyond the capacity for rational thought”) is just amazing.Report

  6. Avatar Saul Degraw
    Ignored
    says:

    After Hours, Ferris Bueller, One Crazy Summer, AirplaneReport

  7. Avatar Jim Heffman
    Ignored
    says:

    Porky’s is a lot less funny these days, now that “Clerks” and “American Pie” exist.

    I’d give props to “Trading Places”, which has the added bonus of being even more relevant now than it was in the 80s (although you need to watch it with an investment banker to understand what’s going on at the end.)

    “Used Cars” is some good dark humor. “Fifty bucks never killed anybody.” “YEAAAARGGGGH!” “Okay, OKAY! TAKE THE MONEY!” (dying car salesman reflexively grabs the cash)

    I agree that “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” ought to be there.

    I think the issue with things like “Ghostbuster” and “Back To The Future” is that they are sci-fi movies with comedy elements rather than specifically comedy movies. You could make a serious version of those movies and still have a workable movie, whereas a serious version of “Airplane” would be, well, “The High And The Mighty”, which Airplane was parodying.Report

  8. Avatar Jaybird
    Ignored
    says:

    3 O’Clock High has a special place in my heart.

    Googling it, I’m told that Ebert gave it one star.

    ONE STAR!

    This is why we can’t have nice things.Report

  9. Avatar greginak
    Ignored
    says:

    What? Where is Stripes…i think that should get some consideration. How about Blues Brothers?Report

  10. Avatar LeeEsq
    Ignored
    says:

    Airplane, Ghostbusters, Fast Times at Richmond High, Ferris Bueller, and the Princess Bride.

    You can’t pull off many of the jokes in Airplane these days. The “you want me to have an abortion” conversation is hillarious but the debate is way too hot these days.Report

  11. Avatar Fish
    Ignored
    says:

    Spaceballs, anyone? Anyone? Top Secret? The Great Outdoors?

    Definitely Ghostbusters. Definitely Airplane. Definitely Caddyshack.

    Ugh. Delightfully too many to list. I’m compiling a list based on the idea that someday I have to make sure my two boys see this movie.Report

  12. Avatar Kim
    Ignored
    says:

    Recently watched Caddyshack with someone who had never seen it… but had been referencing it for a while…Report

  13. Avatar j r
    Ignored
    says:

    If Better off Dead ain’t on it, don’t even bother to build it.Report

    • Avatar Mike Dwyer in reply to j r
      Ignored
      says:

      Leaving of BoD was hard. It would have easily made a Top 10 list. Spaceballs was a tough one too. Mel Brooks deserves at least one mention per decade. And Animal House only missed by two years.

      I also remember Revenge of the Nerds having a big impact on us kids in the laugh department.Report

    • Avatar Burt Likko in reply to j r
      Ignored
      says:

      Not sure if Better Off Dead would hold up. Been a while since I saw it. But it did have the cruelest break-up line I can remember: “Lane, I think it’d be in my best interest if I dated somebody more popular. Better looking. Drives a nicer car.”

      And was I the only guy who was actively rooting for Duckie in Pretty In Pink? I hope I wasn’t the only one who rooted for Duckie.Report

  14. Avatar zic
    Ignored
    says:

    I like the dark humor of that bright and perky era, where cocaine was common (and supposedly harmless) and the video machine was driving working bands out of business. So stranger than Paradise.

    Report

  15. Avatar Mike Schilling
    Ignored
    says:

    No love for A Fish Called Wanda?Report

  16. Avatar KatherineMW
    Ignored
    says:

    I have not seen Caddyshack. I haven’t seen any of these. I haven’t seen anything that anyone on this thread has listed, in fact, aside from The Princess Bride (which I found far inferior to the book).Report

  17. Avatar Tod Kelly
    Ignored
    says:

    A few things…

    First off, Pinky is right. There… are… four… movies!!!

    Secondly, Porky’s was never, ever funny. Not even in the 80s.

    Thirdly, many consider both Brazil and Princess Bride to be comedies, but others don’t and so I don’t know if they qualify. If they are eligible for Mt. Rushmore, than they should immediate replace any of the four films below and, really, any of anyone else’s entires as well.

    Lastly, here is the way the list should read (assuming Brazil an Princess Bride are not eligible), in no particular order:

    1. This is Spinal Tap

    2. A Fish Called Wanda

    3. Raising Arizona

    4. Airplane/Naked Gun (Which I am allowing to be a tie since they are basically the same movie)Report

  18. Avatar Chris
    Ignored
    says:

    Spinal Tap, Ghostbusters, Airplane, and umm… either Caddy Shack or Beverly Hills Cop. It may be the only Eddie Murphy movie where he got to be anything close to full Eddie Murphy, and full Eddie Murphy is the funniest person on the planet. In fact, now that I think about it, Coming to America is pretty damn funny too.Report

    • Avatar greginak in reply to Chris
      Ignored
      says:

      BHC is as much a cop movie, if not more so, than a comedy. As i remember it was origanlly written for Stallone to be the lead. He dropped out and ending up making Cobra, a truly hateful nasty movie. Murphy is funny but it isn’t really a True Comedy.Report

  19. Avatar Mark Thompson
    Ignored
    says:

    1. Caddyshack. Definitely.
    2. National Lampoon’s Vacation. Again, this is indisputable, and any list that fails to include these two movies is invalid.
    3. Airplane! This clearly belongs, but I’m at least open to argument on it.

    The top 3 are all easy picks in my book. Picking the best out of the sizable next tier of movies is really difficult though. Ferris Bueller, Spaceballs, Stripes, Trading Places, Blues Brothers and Better Off Dead are clearly the lead contenders for me. Princess Bride and Good Morning Vietnam also really belong in this group, but since we only have one spot and since they’re not “pure” comedies, they get dropped. Planes, Trains, and Automobiles and The Great Outdoors also both just barely miss being in the running, if only because they both have some pretty sappy moments that reduce their comedy quotient ever so slightly, however much it pains me that this means my list will have no movies in which John Candy played more than a bit role.

    Stripes gets dropped because Harold Ramis and Bill Murray are both already represented on the list, with Ramis represented twice. Spaceballs gets dropped because it’s no better than my third favorite Mel Brooks movie, and the ’80s were too rich in great comedies to warrant including something by a director who did even better work in the ’70s. While it pains me greatly, I’m also going to cut Ferris Bueller for the completely arbitrary reason that I don’t find myself quoting it very often. Blues Brothers gets dropped for similarly arbitrary reasons. So that leaves Trading Places and Better Off Dead, both of which The Wife and I quote several times a month, and which are incredibly rewatchable.

    4. I’m going with Trading Places. If I have to choose between a movie that has John Cusack and Booger and one with Eddie Murphy and Dan Aykroyd at the height of their powers, there really shouldn’t be a choice, especially when both Murphy and Aykroyd would otherwise be missing from the list. It was hard for me to imagine a Mount Rushmore of 80s comedies without at least one of John Candy or Dan Aykroyd, but it would be outright criminal to have a Mount Rushmore of 80s comedies without Eddie Murphy.Report

  20. Avatar Mike Dwyer
    Ignored
    says:

    IMDB has this list, just in case people want to make their heads explode:

    http://www.imdb.com/list/ls009872562/

    Nine to Five and Smoky and the Bandit II both in the the Top 5. Craziness… The also list A Christmas Story which IS a comedy and IS among the greats, but I didn’t include it because it has transcended into ‘Christmas Movie’ and that is a whole other list (likewise for Christmas Vacation). I also like that Major League is on there. That came out during my Little League days and it was quoted a lot in the dugout.Report

    • Avatar Jim Heffman in reply to Mike Dwyer
      Ignored
      says:

      The funniest part of Major League was how they accidentally made an inspiring sports story movie instead of the raunchy comedy they were going for, but they said the F-word too many times and people wouldn’t take their kids to see it, and that’s how we got two sequels.Report

    • Avatar Pinky in reply to Mike Dwyer
      Ignored
      says:

      I liked Major League. I thought it was funny. But it’s almost the opposite of a Mount Rushmore film. It’s always my go-to example of a movie that tried and succeeded at clearing a low hurdle. A lot of people fail at making good funny movies; they succeeded. But Airplane, Spinal Tap, and a few of the others succeeded at something great. That’s the reason I’d vote for Ghostbusters over Caddyshack. Ghostbusters had goals. Caddyshack just put a camera on a bunch of funny actors.Report

  21. Avatar ScarletNumbers
    Ignored
    says:

    1) Back to School

    2) Caddyshack

    3) The Blues Brothers

    4) When Harry Met Sally…Report

  22. Avatar Patrick
    Ignored
    says:

    Jesus, this is hard.

    Okay, “Raising Arizona” needs to be on the list because it’s one of two movies that have ever been produced that almost made my father asphyxiate with laughter (the other one is Arsenic and Old Lace). Plus, it’s just perfectly cast.

    “This is Spinal Tap” is far too iconic to not be on the list.

    Now I’ve got a problem, because you’ve got Chevy Chase, Bill Murray, Dan Ackroyd, Eddie Murphy, John Belushi, Leslie Nielsen, Michael Keaton, Tom Hanks, Harold Ramis, Rodney Dangerfield, and John Cusack and only two spots left.

    “Mr. Mom” is a pretty big 80s movie. “Let it Ride” is probably the funniest movie about gambling ever, and it’s technically an 80s movie, but it doesn’t feel 80s the way, say any John Hughes movie feels 80s. Seems Like Old Times is 80s… but… argh.

    I’ll have to think about this.Report

    • Avatar zic in reply to Patrick
      Ignored
      says:

      +1 on Raising Arizona.

      And the Blues Brothers is from 1980; is that the 80s or the 70s? If the 80s. . .Report

      • Avatar Patrick in reply to zic
        Ignored
        says:

        Decade-as-genre movies really shouldn’t be from the edges.

        I mean, I remember 1980 through 1990 pretty well, and when I think 80s I think big hair and acid-washed jeans and Van Halen and The Smiths (not Morrissey) and The Cure and 80s 1-hit wonders.

        Most really-in-the-decade movies are 1983-1987. That’s when the decade was really established as being different from the 1970s.

        Chevy Chase’s funniest movie is “Foul Play”. Caddyshack is a very close second, but look at the characters in Caddyshack and you see a bunch of 70s characters, not 80s characters. Google Images Cindy Morgan in Caddyshack and you don’t see 80s style, you see 70s style.

        I’m calling Caddyshack a 70s movie.Report

  23. Avatar Kazzy
    Ignored
    says:

    @mike-dwyer

    THANK YOU for jumping in on Mount Rushmore. And for tackling this specific topic, as my youth leaves me ill-equipped to weigh in on the 80’s.

    But, brah, you put FIVE movies up there. FOUR! FOUR IS THE LIMIT!!!Report

  24. Avatar Murali
    Ignored
    says:

    Kung Pow, enter the fist
    Police Academy
    Monty Python and the search for the holy grail
    I can’t choose between naked gun and Mr MagooReport

  25. Avatar Tod Kelly
    Ignored
    says:

    I have to say, I’m surprised that no one else even mentioned Princess Bride. I’m not sure there is a more iconic 80s movie, regardless of genre.Report

  26. Avatar Kolohe
    Ignored
    says:

    1) Bill Cosby, Himself
    2) A Christmas Story
    3) Robocop
    4) 3 hommes et un couffinReport

    • Avatar Murali in reply to Kolohe
      Ignored
      says:

      Robocop is a comedy? I thought it was just bad scifi.Report

      • Avatar El Muneco in reply to Murali
        Ignored
        says:

        I disagree, to a great extent. In the hands of a director capable of any subtlety whatsoever, “Robocop” could have been transcendent. Unfortunately, the dice gave us Verhoeven. Even so, it was excellent for what it was.
        Could have been worse, could have been Luc Besson, whose vice is “Despite no background whatsoever, I know more about SF than literally everyone who is a professional in the genre. And I know more about what ‘literally’ means than all professors of English”.Report

      • Avatar Murali in reply to Murali
        Ignored
        says:

        Taxi (the French one) is good as is transporterReport

      • Avatar El Muneco in reply to Murali
        Ignored
        says:

        Sorry, didn’t mean to imply that he’s a bad director. Hell, Verhoeven isn’t a bad director. They’re just both bad /SF/ directors.Report

      • Avatar Murali in reply to Murali
        Ignored
        says:

        I was looking forward to watching lucy. Is it worth it?Report

      • Avatar El Muneco in reply to Murali
        Ignored
        says:

        Aargh. I have to admit I haven’t actually seen “Lucy”. I’m just going from his interviews and comparing them against the equivalent interviews after “The Fifth Element”, and I have to admit they turned me off seeing it a bit. But as you see I’ve already judged him, so I admit to a wee bit of bias.

        It’s probably similar to “Fifth Element” in that it’s going to be a bit “out there”, but once you’ve adjusted your mind, then the action takes over, and from all accounts it’s perfectly fine from then on.

        And I think that’s the thing, the SF hook is something that leads you into the real movie, but it’s not part and parcel of the real movie like “The Matrix” or “Blade Runner”.Report

  27. Avatar Gabriel Conroy
    Ignored
    says:

    I confess, my list is derivative because I’ve already read almost all of the comments, but here goes:

    1. Caddyshack
    2. Trading Places
    3. Ghostbusters
    4. Fast Times

    A few notes: The only versions of Caddyshack and Fast Times I actually saw during the 80s were the edited-for-TV version. I never saw the film versions until the 90s or later (I was born in the early 70s, so I wasn’t old enough to see those in the theaters). I personally like the edited-for-tv versions for two reasons:

    1. I grew up watching those versions and got used to them and those are what I grew attached to.

    2. The tv versions actually have some scenes the film versions don’t. That is, I’m talking about the tv versions from the 80s, maybe more modern-day tv versions are different. (However, the Baby Ruth candy bar scene in Caddyshack was a must-see.)

    I almost put Airplane! on the list, but for me, it feels too much like a 70s movie.Report

  28. Avatar Michael Cain
    Ignored
    says:

    1. Time Bandits
    2. Ferris Bueller
    3. Ghostbusters
    4. Princess Bride

    For some reason, of the Python movies, I’ve always preferred Time Bandits.Report

  29. Avatar Doctor Jay
    Ignored
    says:

    A comedy that definitely deserves attention here is _Clue_. I don’t know where it belongs, but it should be mentioned.Report

  30. Avatar Patrick
    Ignored
    says:

    Why Airplane! doesn’t make the list:

    Because Kentucky Fried Movie is better, and it’s a 70s movie.Report

  31. Avatar El Muneco
    Ignored
    says:

    (-) Major League – The sports movie. “Bull Durham” (Tim Robbins pitching?) and to a lesser extent “Caddyshack” weren’t Sports Movies ™. Neither was “Jerry Maguire” in a later Rushmore. “Semi-Tough” /should/ have been the best sports movie of all time, but it ended up bearing the same resemblance to the book that Adam Sandler’s “The Longest Yard” did to the real “The Longest Yard”. Let me have this one and I won’t extol the virtues of “The Replacements” when we get to that era…

    (-) Airplane! – The parody/homage/reboot. Mel Brooks was already showing signs of what he would later become, so “Spaceballs” is out. “Porky’s” wasn’t funny and I never liked that genre anyway, same with “Meatballs”. “Naked Gun” and “Top Secret” are both worthy, but didn’t do enough to distinguish themselves from the first and foremost. “Dragnet” had a great soundtrack, and we’ll see Aykroyd later – his co-star probably won’t amount to anything, either.

    (-) A Fish Called Wanda – The “is it a really just a funny action movie?” movie. This allows us to dispose of “Fletch”, “Beverly Hills Cop (I and II)”, “The Princess Bride” (better movie, not as funny), “Ghostbusters”, “The Blues Brothers”, and “Stripes”. And if anyone says it was a 90s movie in disguise, well, “Life of Brian” gets left out of a lot of 70s movies lists because it was ’79, Cleese must be on the mountain somehow, and although I love it dearly, I’m not nominating “Clockwise” for a movie-of-the-decade list.

    This leaves us without probably the two iconic 80s comic actors, so we are forced to put in the one where they were so brilliant together…

    (-) Trading PlacesReport

  32. Avatar Mike Schilling
    Ignored
    says:

    Another suggestion: Ruthless People. Its one of the best-consructed comedies I’ve ever seen almost like a Wodehouse novel.Report

  33. Avatar Doctor Jay
    Ignored
    says:

    I’m not sure if it belongs on Mt. Rushmore, but I find Clue to be conspicuously missing from this list. Of course, I overlooked it at first, too.Report

  34. Avatar Slade the Leveller
    Ignored
    says:

    1. This Is Spinal Tap – without question the funniest, most often quoted movie of the ’80s. To think they made most of it up as they went. And the sheer musical invention of the songs, too. “Lick My Love Pump”. I’m still waiting for the other 2 parts of the trilogy.

    2. A close second is Planes, Trains, and Automobiles. The uptight Steve Martin playing off the slovenly John Candy made every scene a classic. “How ’bout those Bears.” A Thanksgiving staple at the Slade home.

    3. Caddyshack – if only for the Cinderella story scene. Weirdly, I took my son to see it last year and he hardly laughed, while my brother and I were giggling through the whole movie. “He got alla dat one!”

    4. The Princess Bride – every character a character, and eminently quotable. “My name is Inigo Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die.” Whoever thought Andre the Giant could act?Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *