Some people find the answers to life’s impossible question in the Bible. For the rest of us, there’s Star Trek.
David Ryan
David Ryan is a boat builder and USCG licensed master captain. He is the owner of Sailing Montauk and skipper of Montauk''s charter sailing catamaran MON TIKI You can follow him on Twitter @CaptDavidRyan
October 29, 2020
Richard Pryor’s Father and the Transforming Truth of Fatherhood
October 28, 2020
Wednesday Writs: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, SCOTUS, and Election Law
October 28, 2020
Best Meal I Ever Had: Philadelphia’s The Victor Café
October 27, 2020
October 29, 2020
October 29, 2020
October 28, 2020
Richard Pryor’s Father and the Transforming Truth of Fatherhood
October 28, 2020
Wednesday Writs: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, SCOTUS, and Election Law
October 28, 2020
October 28, 2020
The Curmudgeon’s Case for Biden
October 27, 2020
Best Meal I Ever Had: Philadelphia’s The Victor Café
October 27, 2020
There’s a Brown-nose In Every Office
October 27, 2020
The Curmudgeon’s Case for Biden
October 27, 2020
An Example Of Dystopian Leftist Culture
October 25, 2020
Joe Biden Won’t Restore America’s Norms
October 23, 2020
Wednesday Writs: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, SCOTUS, and Election Law
October 28, 2020
From CNN: CNN Poll: Biden wins final presidential debate
October 23, 2020
Weekend Plans Post: Specialized Kitchen Tools
October 22, 2020
Bae Humbug! Sacha Baron Cohen and the Pranking of Truth
October 25, 2020
October 26, 2020
Sunday Morning! Bowles on Film
October 25, 2020
on Wednesday Writs: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, SCOTUS, and Election LawI wonder, after the election is over, if anyone wi…
on The Curmudgeon’s Case for BidenIt's almost identical to the ways that liberals ha…
on Utah or WeimarA couple of random points: 1) I think you guys spe…
on Utah or WeimarI share the same worries. I do think the most like…
on The Curmudgeon’s Case for BidenOne of the big unexplored questions is ‘What if Tr…
on Wednesday Writs: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, SCOTUS, and Election LawCurbside voting avoids standing in line with the m…
on Collecting BennuHow would they know it's a rubble pile without pro… on Vanity, Thy Name is AnonymousAnd here's where we discussed anonymous back in 20…
Vote Like Your Life Depends On It, Because It Does
Classic Horror Films: The Best From The Original Universal Monsters
Rock Legend Eddie Van Halen, Dead at 65
Maybe Just Bet Chalk This Time, I Tell Myself Again
Between Nagorno-Karabakh and a Hard Place
The Riddle of The Mother
The Libertarian Case that Riots are Good, Achtually
Amy, Tell Me What You’re Gonna Do: Part 2
It’s hard to go wrong with the Wrath of Kahn, although I never got the point of the Kobayashi Maru – why prepare your officers for death in battle, when its something they’ll have to do once at the most? And no matter how they do it, they’ll end up dead shortly thereafter?Report
Well they still need to preform well in the face of impending death. A captain might be able to save some of his crew or his/her ship while staring death in the face or even through his/her own death.Report
Thing is, when officers order troops to advance into fire, they can only lead by example. It’s by no means certain who’s going to live or die. You can win or lose wars, or reach some stalemate but there’s no winning or losing in such engagements. It’s about who stays and who leaves, who has the drop on whom, which risks are worth taking and which result only in fruitless sacrifices. And there’s luck involved, both good and bad. For every D-Day Landing there’s a Hurtgen Forest.Report
I’m with Greginak. How you deal with the no win situation is important. There’re bad outcomes and there’re less bad outcomes. Being able to salvage the less bad out of the no win scenario without succumbing to despair or berserking would be an enormous asset for an officer on a star ship.Report
The Kobayashi Maru scenario isn’t necessarily fatal. Rather it’s a test that deals with a situation that’s impossible to solve without violating one of several conditions.
There’s some references to how other members of the Enterprise crew handle it. For example, Sulu decides not to violate the Neutral Zone and instead writes a personalized letter to the family members of the crew and passengers of the Kobayashi Maru.
And contra 2009’s Star Trek, IIRC Kirk originally cheated by making it so the Klingons would fear and respect his name, thereby letting him and the freighter go without firing a shot.Report
It’s a plot device, in that it sets us up for the revelation of Kirk’s cheating death In the KM scenario, and later on when he can’t cheat at Spock’s death (though they eventually cheated that, too, with another weaselly plot device). I realize I’m treading on thin ice by suggesting that a piece of the Star Trek canon should best be understood as mere dramatic artifice.Report
The purpose behind the scenario is not to prepare you for death, it is a test of character. What will you do and why do you do it?Report
That was not what i was taught at Star Fleet Academy. You must have been in a later class.Report
What will you do and why do you do it?
1.) Cheat.
2.) To win.
3.) Duh.
Now, where’s that green chick with the Romulan Ale?! WOOOOOO!Report