The main discussion is here. If you want to talk about spoilers, you can talk about them in this thread.
Erik Kain
Erik writes about video games at Forbes and politics at Mother Jones. He's the contributor of The League though he hasn't written much here lately. He can be found occasionally composing 140 character cultural analysis on Twitter.
April 18, 2022
The Return of the Bedroom Police
May 9, 2022
Student Loan Forgiveness: Watch What Unfolds from Here
April 28, 2022
April 26, 2022
The Demise of the Big Tent Made Us Stupid
May 6, 2022
Recently comments that included the strings "zed" or "doug" were sent immediately to trash. This should be fixed now.
on Capacious, Ordered LibertyI'm talking about rights of the people which are unenumerated in the Constitution. You're talking about judici…
on Shooting in Buffalo Leaves 10 Dead, 13 WoundedWhite reactionary violence doesn't equal mass shootings. The Ahmaud Arbery murder was an example of white reac…
on Capacious, Ordered LibertyTypically the right doesn’t mind unenumerated rights UM . . . no. The right objected strenuously to same sex m… on Capacious, Ordered LibertyOr Gay marriage . . . or contraception . . . and there are constituencies for all three, some louder or larger… on Shooting in Buffalo Leaves 10 Dead, 13 WoundedIf every community is creating mass shooters at the same rate (although Asians seem to be unrepresented there)… on Shooting in Buffalo Leaves 10 Dead, 13 WoundedEverything I've been hearing about has been attacks by blacks on Asians. I mean, I'm sure there have been more… on Shooting in Buffalo Leaves 10 Dead, 13 WoundedDark Matter asked "So the next time we have a violent left wing nut shoot someone the police are targeting bla… on Shooting in Buffalo Leaves 10 Dead, 13 WoundedFair enough. I just made the comment because I have seen some people online elsewhere irresponsibly talking ab…
Screengrab from WIVB Buffalo Channel 4 News[/caption]
Perhaps the most striking example of Starkdom, it seems to me, is Sansa. And I think she provides a lense through which to see the rest of the family. Sansa believes in a world of beautiful things and this guides her decision-making process to many faults. She doesn’t understand what’s really at stake. She just knows the world that she wants to live in and seems to think it will come about through the power of assumption. At least Eddard realizes that there are games being played.
Now, we can more easily forgive Sansa on account of her youth. But I think her untempered nature is partly what makes Eddard easier to understand. One imagines, when he was younger, he was much the same way. Time and experience revealed a more complicated world, but when push comes to shove, it’s the uncomplicated world that he retreats to. The higher the stakes, the more he retreats. So he knows that Littlefinger is a bad dude, and yet in the thrust of events, he acts otherwise, retreating into the world he better understands.Report
That’s a very interesting way to look at Sansa. I hadn’t considered that angle, but it makes a great deal of sense. Perhaps Arya is not so different in a way, imagining a world where even little girls can become lords and sword-fighters. Just another refusal to believe in the world as it actually is. Even their gods are long-dead.Report
Harsh on their Gods E.D. since later in the books it looks like the Weirwoods have plenty of power still left in em.Report
I really like Sansa and can’t help but agree there. Having her learning the game at Littlefingers knee strikes me as a fearsome potential combination. All those Stark morals and dreams poured into the tempered vessle of Littlefinger’s razor sharp cynical scheming? And then frosted over with her burgoning beauty? The Queen had best watch her back.Report
That’s the best part, Cersei is too busy sparring with Margery. She won’t even see Sansa coming.Report
I wanted to also note that Jaimie Lannister has a bit of the Stark in him, and this begins to come out more in the third book. He’s never the schemer that his siblings are, nor as ambitious and power-hungry as his father or Cersei. And really, he can’t play the game either.Report
I don’t know if the fact he’s not a schemer make him Stark-like. I think it’s just that he’s too impulsive to scheme. If he wants somethign he just takes it, if that gets him into trouble he falls back on his sword. Sure things might go wrong and kill him, but I don’t think he cares much.Report
Jaime’s character develops as the books progress especially after his hand is lopped off. After some life-changing moments it looks like that if not for his unnatural attachment to his sister Cersei (Lady Macbeth) Lannister h would hav been a decent sort. As his Aunt says:
You smile like Gerion and fight like Tyg, and there’s some of Kevan in you, else you would not wear that cloak . . . but Tyrion is Tywin’s son, not you.
Jaime Lannister is in a way a tainted and fallen hero. While we see his worst side first in the beginning, as with Sandor Clegane, we find that they are not without redeeming qualities. It may be that pushing Bran did sort of push him off the moral event horizon (as well as screwing his own sister) But his own efforts to restore honour and dignity to the Kingsguard as well as to behave honourably with respect towards Ctelyn Stark and his promise to her as well as Brienne of Tarth and his subsequent severing of ties with his sister is making me want to re-appraise him. It is easy to perceive him as having shit for honour, but it is clearly not the case.Report
Why do you like to hate Littlefinger? I’m pretty much entirely in awe of him and can’t quite understand those who loathe him.Report
I feel similarly, he’s too much of a Magnificent Bastard for me to hate him.Report
It’s slightly OT, but that line is my favorite from any movie ever.Report
Now you have doomed us all TVtropes will ruin your lifeReport