I got the mic, I rock it how I please

Avatar

Freddie

Freddie deBoer used to blog at lhote.blogspot.com, and may again someday. Now he blogs here.

Related Post Roulette

3 Responses

  1. Avatar Roque Nuevo
    Ignored
    says:

    “Here’s what I want: I want a two-state solution with Israel returning to its pre-1967 borders, which would have the little benefit of no longer being a violation of international law, laws Israel is bound by treaty agreement to adhere to and which explicitly outlaw the annexation of foreign land through military conquest.”

    What treaties are you talking about? Where do you get the idea that Israel has “annexed” the West Bank? Just a stab in the dark, but one treaty I know of is SCR 242, which says that Israel will give up territory (it doesn’t say “all the territory”) in the West Bank in return for peace. So, why is Israel “in violation” and Palestinians are not?

    The above is how you get from discussing international politics to discussing morality. Since your discussion only condemns Israel for violating international law, why is it wrong to assume that you favor the Palestinians?

    You say your little solution has been “blocked at every turn by the Israeli government and its patrons in the United Nations security council, the United States” even though it has the support of all the right-thinking people. But the fact is that it hasn’t been blocked by them. In fact, it was openly offered to them in the 2000 Camp David talks. It has been blocked by the Palestinians—unless you’d demand open borders with a state with openly genocidal intentions against Israel. If there were a group like Hamas in some part of LA, I don’t think you’d be demanding that they have full communications with the rest of the city, since they would use this to kill people in LA.Report

  2. Avatar E.D. Kain
    Ignored
    says:

    Freddie,

    I think I figured out what has rubbed me wrong about Max’s call to write policy. I think the entire purpose of the thoughtful blog is to wax theoretical–to opine, of course, but in a somewhat detached, philosophical manner. To write policy suggestions is to leave this theoretical world, where one can at least be useful in spurring on conversation, and enter into the realm of the concrete.

    Not only that, but policy suggestions are essentially futile. Policy makers could care less. One has a better chance arguing moral or philosophical points than they do laying out a policy approach. It is time better spent, which is why after my response to Max I felt as though I hadn’t really said much, or had somehow wasted my time, but couldn’t quite understand why…Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *